Live data from Hacker News

Soundcloud Releases New App, Allows Universal to Flag Your Account

doandroidsdance.com

11–20 of 94 posts

Re: Soundcloud Releases New App, Allows Universal to Flag Your Account

#11
First, that is a low blow linking to others doing it. They know, or haven't got to them yet. Websites like Etsy do the same on license content. Two, they choose you be set an example. Three, I always thought of Soundcloud the Vimeo of music. If it is an artisans music website, upload your own creations.

Unfortunately for soundcloud, aren't they killing their main userbase? DJ's mixing mainstream songs.

Re: Soundcloud Releases New App, Allows Universal to Flag Your Account

#13
post #2

Original article from a couple of days ago http://doandroidsdance.com/features/soundcloud-boldly-releas... "SoundCloud seems to have given Universal the keys to the car within the last month, and is allowing the media giant full access to flag accounts’ records without any communication whatsoever with SoundCloud. "

Thanks. We changed the url from http://www.dancingastronaut.com/2014/07/soundcloud-continues....

Btw, stories can't have both urls and text, so your submission text was lost. We're going to fix that so a message comes up when users do it.

Re: Soundcloud Releases New App, Allows Universal to Flag Your Account

#14
post #13
post #2

Original article from a couple of days ago http://doandroidsdance.com/features/soundcloud-boldly-releas... "SoundCloud seems to have given Universal the keys to the car within the last month, and is allowing the media giant full access to flag accounts’ records without any communication whatsoever with SoundCloud. "

Thanks. We changed the url from http://www.dancingastronaut.com/2014/07/soundcloud-continues... . Btw, stories can't have both urls and text, so your submission text was lost. We're going to fix that so a message comes up when users do it.

Maybe the ability to have a seed post to go along with the link might be a feature worth evaluating?

Re: Soundcloud Releases New App, Allows Universal to Flag Your Account

#15
post #11

First, that is a low blow linking to others doing it. They know, or haven't got to them yet. Websites like Etsy do the same on license content. Two, they choose you be set an example. Three, I always thought of Soundcloud the Vimeo of music. If it is an artisans music website, upload your own creations. Unfortunately for soundcloud, aren't they killing their main userbase? DJ's mixing mainstream songs.

>Unfortunately for soundcloud, aren't they killing their main userbase?

It is possible that it was an "offer you can't refuse" type thing. I doubt they'd do it voluntarily.

Re: Soundcloud Releases New App, Allows Universal to Flag Your Account

#16
post #11

First, that is a low blow linking to others doing it. They know, or haven't got to them yet. Websites like Etsy do the same on license content. Two, they choose you be set an example. Three, I always thought of Soundcloud the Vimeo of music. If it is an artisans music website, upload your own creations. Unfortunately for soundcloud, aren't they killing their main userbase? DJ's mixing mainstream songs.

> First, that is a low blow linking to others doing it.

I thought the same thing at first, but the users that are linked to are all big, big names that get millions of plays on Soundcloud that will never get takedowns, whether they have clearances or not. It's more like saying "why are you hassling me for my $10 unpaid fine when you don't care about these corporations' $100,000 unpaid fines" than it is about narcing on the competition.

Re: Soundcloud Releases New App, Allows Universal to Flag Your Account

#17
It's been really interesting over the last 24 hours or so to watch the reaction from Joe Kay[0], whose label/collective Soulection[1] has shared hundreds of hours of mixes and dozens of original tracks and remixes on Soundcloud[2], and to an extent (at least initially) built their following on the site (not to take anything away from the impact performances, etc. have had on their growing popularity), but were always at high risk of this sort of takedown due to remixes of popular rap/r&b tracks.

One of my initial takeaways from this development is that while Soulection may not have come to exist without Soundcloud, the "next Soulection" will almost certainly take root anywhere but Soundcloud.

It's a shame.

[0] https://twitter.com/J0EKAY

[1] http://soulection.com

[2] https://soundcloud.com/soulection

Re: Soundcloud Releases New App, Allows Universal to Flag Your Account

#18
post #8
post #4

oh that's why some DJ's that I follow are moving to mixcloud

I think something similar will happen to Mixcloud too. See U.S. licensing rules: http://support.mixcloud.com/customer/portal/articles/1595564

Then comes another service... The circle of life...

Re: Soundcloud Releases New App, Allows Universal to Flag Your Account

#19

Also their interface for tracking plays has gotten significantly worse. And you have to pay extra to get most of the same information you get for free from youtube.

>And you have to pay extra to get most of the same information you get for free from youtube.

Well Youtube has advertisements, and soundcloud doesn't. Someone is still paying for you to get that information, it's just not you, on youtube. I do agree that their interface has gotten worse, though. Especially for tracking.

Re: Soundcloud Releases New App, Allows Universal to Flag Your Account

#20
post #14
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thanks. We changed the url from http://www.dancingastronaut.com/2014/07/soundcloud-continues... . Btw, stories can't have both urls and text, so your submission text was lost. We're going to fix that so a message comes up when users do it.

Maybe the ability to have a seed post to go along with the link might be a feature worth evaluating?

You can do that now by posting a comment to the thread. I realize that's not exactly what you mean, but (a) it's close, (b) we're biased in favor of reusing existing features wherever possible, and (c) I'm not convinced that the submitter's comment should be privileged over other users', other than by being first to appear. What chippy wrote was fine, but that would not always be the case.
Post reply on HN