Live data from Hacker News

Average IQ in Europe by country (map)

jakubmarian.com

51–60 of 62 posts

Re: Average IQ in Europe by country (map)

#51

I wonder why people focus so much on IQ instead of better metrics. In this article, "The play deficit": http://aeon.co/magazine/being-human/children-today-are-suffe... there are these very interesting sentences: "Other research, by the psychologist Mark Runco and colleagues at the Torrance Creativity Center at the University of Georgia, shows that scores on the TTCT are the best childhood predictors we have of future…

Probably because general intelligence is "the best-established, most predictive, most heritable mental trait ever discovered in psychology." (Geoffrey Miller, Spent)

Re: Average IQ in Europe by country (map)

#52
post #11

How can you get an accurate average IQ? I've never taken a formal IQ test in my life. I asked serval people around if they have and no one else has in their adult life.

> How can you get an accurate average IQ? The linked source has both maps based on only IQ data and maps based on IQ data adjusted with additional data from other assessments that have a demonstrated correlation to IQ results.

I dont find it very accurate to adjust an hard score based on other assessments, presumably those test arent IQ scores. Did every country take the same test?

Re: Average IQ in Europe by country (map)

#53
post #17
post #11

How can you get an accurate average IQ? I've never taken a formal IQ test in my life. I asked serval people around if they have and no one else has in their adult life.

I have, in high school we were all asked to take a test.

Did you go to a public school? Most tests I remember taking were the ITBS, PSAT, SAT and ACT.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_standardized_tests_in_t...

Re: Average IQ in Europe by country (map)

#54
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Unless other continents have significantly more intelligent people than in Europe (seems unlikely) Why does this seem unlikely?

It's unlikely that 1) there are significant differences in intelligence between different continents 2) that IQ, which is significantly influenced by education, would be lower in Europe where education is rather decent (probably at least in the better half, if you were to sort the world by quality of education).

> It's unlikely that 1) there are significant differences in intelligence between different continents

Given the known individual drivers of IQ, which are things not equal by continent, that seems dubious.

> that IQ, which is significantly influenced by education, would be lower in Europe where education is rather decent (probably at least in the better half, if you were to sort the world by quality of education).

Yeah, but the 100 IQ average wasn't set globally in the first place, its the average of the norming sample of the test, and most (all) of the test were developed in the first world with norming samples drawn from there.

Western Europe being a hair below first-world average (and Eastern europe farther below it) in the first world isn't at all surprising.

Re: Average IQ in Europe by country (map)

#55

The blog post author did a terrible job of research on IQ by encountering the writings of Richard Lynn (funded by the Pioneer Fund, and later an administrator of the Pioneer Fund) and not finding the writings of James R. Flynn,[1] the acknowledged expert on IQ trends over time, after whom the Flynn effect[2] is named. Flynn's TED talk[3] is the place to start for understanding what is really going on in IQ score tren…

Excellent critique, Sir.

Re: Average IQ in Europe by country (map)

#56
post #24

One of the authors of one of the reference materials (Tatu Vanhanen) of Lynn and Vanhanen is fairly suspect in his methodology of applying and analysing of IQ scores. Fact #1: It's not actually obvious what IQ scores measure, what amount of cultural bias the scores have and does it even make sense to compare IQ scores between different populations. Well, it's a number so yes, you can numerically compare it, but - as…

It turns out that calling things "facts" does not, unfortunately, make them facts.

To go beyond the armchair, try looking at, for example, http://books.google.ca/books?id=jj4tKn9gb1IC&pg=PT172

Re: Average IQ in Europe by country (map)

#57
post #21

Interesting how you'll never meet a person whose IQ is less than 100 (or even 120) on the Internet. It's a rather flawed metric.

Have you tried twitter?

The point is, nobody would ever admit to having low (even above average) IQ, not that they are actually smart.

Re: Average IQ in Europe by country (map)

#58

I wonder why people focus so much on IQ instead of better metrics. In this article, "The play deficit": http://aeon.co/magazine/being-human/children-today-are-suffe... there are these very interesting sentences: "Other research, by the psychologist Mark Runco and colleagues at the Torrance Creativity Center at the University of Georgia, shows that scores on the TTCT are the best childhood predictors we have of future…

Probably because general intelligence is "the best-established, most predictive, most heritable mental trait ever discovered in psychology." (Geoffrey Miller, Spent)

I googled it and found the following:

http://www.barrelstrength.com/2013/12/31/ramachandran-iq/

where there is:

"Intelligence (says Prof. Miller at page 189 of Spent) is positively correlated to:

    brain size
    speed of performing basic sensory motor tasks (“reaction time is a factor”, as the cop said in Blade Runner)
    height
    symmetry of face and body
    semen quality (!)
    health, physical and mental
    longevity
    sexual attractiveness for long term relationships"
So it is most predictive of many things, but maybe not of future real-world achievements...

Re: Average IQ in Europe by country (map)

#59
post #53
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have, in high school we were all asked to take a test.

Did you go to a public school? Most tests I remember taking were the ITBS, PSAT, SAT and ACT. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_standardized_tests_in_t...

Yes however this was in Europe.

Romania to be specific.

It wasn't mandatory or anything just encouraged.

Re: Average IQ in Europe by country (map)

#60
post #50
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When I was young, as part of my move into the public school system (from a private school in my first and second grades), I had to take one. Later, I was identified by a gifted program and had to take an entire battery of tests for most of the rest of my schooling, including numerous IQ tests. In those circles, I didn't know anybody who had never taken an IQ test.

Interesting perhaps I took one but didnt realize it. How accurate can an IQ test for elementary schoolers be for an adult population? Maybe the test I took were not called IQ tests but were very similar. Most test I took were similar to what the SAT was, but I never got back an "IQ" score. Usually they gave us back a percentile score against the whole pool, but never an IQ number or range.

Yeah, I took a bunch of those as well, like the ITBS. They're more aptitude tests than IQ tests, but I imagine there some correlation. Usually they're looking for specific subjects or learning styles

There's a bunch of different IQ tests as well (WISC, SB5, DAS, WJ) and some designed for adults, but they should give you a score. There's some special tests for people with high percentile IQs as well.

I don't know if I'd call any IQ test accurate. Mine have varied wildly over time and depending on the test.

Post reply on HN