Live data from Hacker News

The IUD: The Best Form of Birth Control is the One No One is Using

time.com

11–20 of 56 posts

Re: The IUD: The Best Form of Birth Control is the One No One is Using

#11

One of the biggest plus point for condoms is that both the partners can be confident about whether it's being used or not. IUD may be verify effective but as a male, I have to trust my partner that she is using IUD. Of course, this is not important when couple already trusts each other and are committed. [Similar logic applies for vasectomy]

[deleted]

Re: The IUD: The Best Form of Birth Control is the One No One is Using

#12
post #11

One of the biggest plus point for condoms is that both the partners can be confident about whether it's being used or not. IUD may be verify effective but as a male, I have to trust my partner that she is using IUD. Of course, this is not important when couple already trusts each other and are committed. [Similar logic applies for vasectomy]

[deleted]

"Hold on, let me scan your crotch with my smartphone" is about as likely to happen as "Hold on, please sign this form giving consent" for two people about to fuck. Let's be realistic here.

This also ignores the obvious issue of data leakage. You work/live in a location with objections to the use of birth control. What's stopping your boss from covertly finding out who among his employees is "sinning" or what have you.

Re: The IUD: The Best Form of Birth Control is the One No One is Using

#13
However the problem these various anti-BC people have (and the court cases that has again bought up IUDs) is that "birth control" drugs are used by huge numbers of people for completely unrelated reasons - numerous thyroid conditions are best treated with "birth control".

Also IUDs are solely for BC, and require (out patient) procedures that fall under the 'religious' exemptions. So you don't get coverage for that either.

Re: The IUD: The Best Form of Birth Control is the One No One is Using

#14
post #11

One of the biggest plus point for condoms is that both the partners can be confident about whether it's being used or not. IUD may be verify effective but as a male, I have to trust my partner that she is using IUD. Of course, this is not important when couple already trusts each other and are committed. [Similar logic applies for vasectomy]

[deleted]

Um, if you don't trust your parter, the solution is not a gross invasion of privacy.

Re: The IUD: The Best Form of Birth Control is the One No One is Using

#15
post #11

One of the biggest plus point for condoms is that both the partners can be confident about whether it's being used or not. IUD may be verify effective but as a male, I have to trust my partner that she is using IUD. Of course, this is not important when couple already trusts each other and are committed. [Similar logic applies for vasectomy]

[deleted]

I imagine that would be easily spoofable (though that obviously takes a bit more preparation than lying about having an IUD), and almost certainly raises some privacy concerns.

Not to mention the social aspects. "Awww yeah baby, let's do this thing. Let me just... take out my RF scanner and verify that you have an IUD."

Re: The IUD: The Best Form of Birth Control is the One No One is Using

#16

From the chart in the article I'm surprised the pill has such a poor performance record of 6-12 pregnancies out of 100 women. When I was in high school, university and in my 20's almost all the women I knew were on the pill and I didn't hear once about an unplanned pregnancy or abortion. Infact all the women I know joked about how they were surprised when they went off the pill how easy it was for them to get pregnan…

That's probably typical use. Perfect use is is %99.9.

Re: The IUD: The Best Form of Birth Control is the One No One is Using

#17
post #11

One of the biggest plus point for condoms is that both the partners can be confident about whether it's being used or not. IUD may be verify effective but as a male, I have to trust my partner that she is using IUD. Of course, this is not important when couple already trusts each other and are committed. [Similar logic applies for vasectomy]

[deleted]

Do you really need a radio emitter so close to egg DNA?

Re: The IUD: The Best Form of Birth Control is the One No One is Using

#18

One of the biggest plus point for condoms is that both the partners can be confident about whether it's being used or not. IUD may be verify effective but as a male, I have to trust my partner that she is using IUD. Of course, this is not important when couple already trusts each other and are committed. [Similar logic applies for vasectomy]

In non-committed relationships, or in the early days of a relationship, surely it's sensible to use condoms anyway - as much for protection against STDs as for having to trust that your partner isn't lying when she says she's using a contraceptive.

I might be an outlier and I've also got the benefit of free health care and sexual health clinics being in the UK, but it seems like sensible practice to not stop using condoms until you've both had an STD screen - which takes all of ten minutes plus a week to get results - just to be safe. Especially since it's possible to have an STD while also being unaware of it.

Re: The IUD: The Best Form of Birth Control is the One No One is Using

#19

From the chart in the article I'm surprised the pill has such a poor performance record of 6-12 pregnancies out of 100 women. When I was in high school, university and in my 20's almost all the women I knew were on the pill and I didn't hear once about an unplanned pregnancy or abortion. Infact all the women I know joked about how they were surprised when they went off the pill how easy it was for them to get pregnan…

Part of the performance record might well be due to not everyone taking the pill remembering to always take it. If you miss the odd day, I'd imagine that the chance of accidental pregnancy goes up a fair bit.
Post reply on HN