Live data from Hacker News

We have the potential to solve the biggest problems of today

christophmccann.com

11–20 of 188 posts

Re: We have the potential to solve the biggest problems of today

#11
post #6

Yo's popularity entirely rides two facts: (1) it's a silly app, (2) it got a million dollars. We currently know nothing about user engagement and retention. I'd be surprised if anyone uses it for more than a few weeks.

If an app that does nothing and has a half life of 3 weeks can raise $1 million, then the industry has a problem.

It doesn't mean the industry has a problem, it means the people who put the $1 million into the company have a problem.

Re: We have the potential to solve the biggest problems of today

#15

The future is tricky to predict. A lot of things look like toys, until all of a sudden they're not. Worth reading the counterpoint: http://avc.com/2013/04/return-and-ridicule/ "This notion also plays into Clayton Christensen's framework for disruptive innovation. Many of the most disruptive technologies started out as what Clay calls "toys". The PC is a great example of that. PCs came out of the homebrew computer mov…

Precisely. Who would have predicted that Twitter would have been used to organize people in a meaningful way during the Arab Spring?

The overthrow of tyrannical regimes is a noble cause that a startup would almost certainly never been able to focus on as a solution to a big picture problem.

Re: We have the potential to solve the biggest problems of today

#16
Unfortunately, this line of criticism works equally well about all games, art, haute cuisine, movies, national parks, and about 96% of our economy.

More importantly, it also works against articles that gripe about effort wasted on apps the author doesn't care for.

Re: We have the potential to solve the biggest problems of today

#17
We have the potential to solve the big problems. But the big problems cost a lot more than $1 million to solve and aren't likely to get funded unless the founder is already a Silicon Valley billionaire with VC connections.

So let's build apps like Yo because Silicon Valley deems them to be a prerequisite to being allowed to solve the big problems.

Re: We have the potential to solve the biggest problems of today

#18
post #2

Let's build apps like Yo. They're good practice. Doing silly things that amuse oneself is a critical component of hackerdom. Let's just not fund them.

Let's fund them, let's just not acquire them. That way they won't be funded in the future :)

Let's acquire them, just not for too much money. Otherwise we tell people that anything on the internets is worth billions. :)

Re: We have the potential to solve the biggest problems of today

#19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Let's fund them, let's just not acquire them. That way they won't be funded in the future :)

Let's acquire them, just not for too much money. Otherwise we tell people that anything on the internets is worth billions. :)

Oh what the hell, fine, let's acquire them for billions.

Re: We have the potential to solve the biggest problems of today

#20
Lets not take ourselves so seriously. Lets not let YO be representative of what investors, entrepreneurs, developers and technologists are doing as a whole, despite its outsize media coverage. Lets remember that quirky, weird, seemingly useless things like YO can still put a smile on someones face, even if it didnt solve any of society's problems. What a dry place the world would be if we didnt have things like YO.

Variety is the spice of life. Some will make YO, some will build Tesla, and most of us will fall somewhere in between. Not every startup needs to be a world changer, and thats OK. Thats life.

The author insists that he's not being pretentious, but evaluating what is a good and poor use of someone elses time and smarts seems like just that.

Post reply on HN