Live data from Hacker News

Living the Fitbit life

newyorker.com

11–20 of 75 posts

Re: Living the Fitbit life

#11
I'm fairly active — running on a treadmill for 20 minutes then lifting weights for 30 every day of the week, walking nearly everywhere, only using stairs, etc. — but I can't bring myself to use these types of trackers.

I eagerly ordered the SE Nike+ band when it was announced, I used it for maybe a week before giving it away to a friend. Perhaps it wasn't as interesting to me because there was no way to compare my numbers (no personal friends used similar devices).

The idea of personal fitness trackers still intrigues me (it sounds fun), but in reality the moment you discover your "number" as an average, it's easy to lose interest.

Re: Living the Fitbit life

#12
post #8

>> “It’s a Fitbit. You synch it with your computer, and it tracks your physical activity.” Is it sync, or synch? The 'h' really bothers me for some reason.

Both are correct, though I believe "synch" is slightly British.

Re: Living the Fitbit life

#13
post #2

My wife and I are avid fitbit'ers. We used to walk about an hour every day before we got them so it wasn't like we became fanatics when we got them but things have changed in some very subtle ways: We can get the same amount of walking in even when we travel to a new city, we used to slack off sometimes when we travelled because we didn’t have a “route” to follow. Now we just go and often walk until we get to 1/2 our…

My wife and I are also slightly obsessive fitbit'ers.

We use fitbit's aria smart scale and like to use trendweight.com to track our weight trends. I've lost over 15 lbs over 6% body fat, and my wife has lost more as well.

Re: Living the Fitbit life

#14
post #2

My wife and I are avid fitbit'ers. We used to walk about an hour every day before we got them so it wasn't like we became fanatics when we got them but things have changed in some very subtle ways: We can get the same amount of walking in even when we travel to a new city, we used to slack off sometimes when we travelled because we didn’t have a “route” to follow. Now we just go and often walk until we get to 1/2 our…

My wife and I are also slightly obsessive fitbit'ers. We use fitbit's aria smart scale and like to use trendweight.com to track our weight trends. I've lost over 15 lbs over 6% body fat, and my wife has lost more as well.

How does the scale measure BF%? My impression was that calipers were really the only way to do it accurately without expensive equipment.

Re: Living the Fitbit life

#15
post #9
post #5

Once we start seeing reliable metrics for other common vitals, I'm optimistic we'll see massive benefits from data insights. With a large enough sample size and the right vitals, I'm hopeful we can find highly correlated early predictors of some massive events: e.g., does 20 minutes before a heart attack have a reliable signature? Is there any boilerplate legalese for open sourcing that kind of data?

I can't wait for a device that can measure how many calories you've eaten. The possibilities for that would be endless. Beeping after you've hit your goal/limit for the day?

I tend to just pay attention roughly to what I eat, and not eat foods that are generally bad for me/empty calories. However on some days I'll consume twice the amount of "recommended daily calories" for an adult my size. Yet I remain an 140lb adult male.

There are no hard/fast rules for calorie consumption, and I don't believe a calorie counter will help. In-fact, it is the precise quantification of food that leads to poor diets/eating habits.

EDIT: My fear is that focusing on only a small part of nutrition will further harm the nutrition of individuals. If we place too much attention on calories other things can be overlooked such as vital fats and acids or minerals. I'm trying to make the case that increased awareness and education of food and the human diet/nutrition is more important than counting calories. As someone points out below, there are many situations where calories are not labeled. In my case, I'm aware of what food is decent, and what food is junk and this allows me to forgo strict quantification of the food I consume. I know that food from most food chains is generally junk. This extends beyond the nutrition of the food as well. Food chains typically source their food from the cheapest distributors, and these are often the same distributors that end up distributing massive quantities of contaminated foods.

Here's another case. I could potentially consume 5 sodas in a single day and remain under my caloric restriction, but I would have consumed a ton of empty calories. A calorie monitor is not able to help in this case, but my own awareness of health and nutrition keeps me from doing this.

The issue of health is far larger simple quantification of a few metrics. It is within any individuals ability to determine for themselves general effects of the food they are consuming.

For some of the best arguments contrary to my own: http://www.foodpolitics.com/tag/calorie-labeling/

Re: Living the Fitbit life

#16
post #9
post #5

Once we start seeing reliable metrics for other common vitals, I'm optimistic we'll see massive benefits from data insights. With a large enough sample size and the right vitals, I'm hopeful we can find highly correlated early predictors of some massive events: e.g., does 20 minutes before a heart attack have a reliable signature? Is there any boilerplate legalese for open sourcing that kind of data?

I can't wait for a device that can measure how many calories you've eaten. The possibilities for that would be endless. Beeping after you've hit your goal/limit for the day?

There is actually a new company, Proteus (http://www.proteus.com/), which has addressed a similar problem. Basically, they've developed a way to make a drug pill "smart" by embedding a tiny disposable transmitter in the pill. It uses stomach acid to create an "in-situ" battery and then transmits a unique ID to a receiver patch worn by the patient. Something like this perhaps could scale in the future if we could "pepper" FOOD with such nanotransmitters (eg a populate a food item with a certain density of transmitters to indicate calories).

Re: Living the Fitbit life

#17
post #3
post #2

My wife and I are avid fitbit'ers. We used to walk about an hour every day before we got them so it wasn't like we became fanatics when we got them but things have changed in some very subtle ways: We can get the same amount of walking in even when we travel to a new city, we used to slack off sometimes when we travelled because we didn’t have a “route” to follow. Now we just go and often walk until we get to 1/2 our…

Great story about the tech. Now... What actual benefits have you seen? For example, weight loss, increased muscle strength, blood pressure, heart rate?

I get a discount on my health insurance premium from my company.

Re: Living the Fitbit life

#18
post #2

My wife and I are avid fitbit'ers. We used to walk about an hour every day before we got them so it wasn't like we became fanatics when we got them but things have changed in some very subtle ways: We can get the same amount of walking in even when we travel to a new city, we used to slack off sometimes when we travelled because we didn’t have a “route” to follow. Now we just go and often walk until we get to 1/2 our…

How come you got the Withings scale instead of the Fitbit one?

Re: Living the Fitbit life

#19
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My wife and I are also slightly obsessive fitbit'ers. We use fitbit's aria smart scale and like to use trendweight.com to track our weight trends. I've lost over 15 lbs over 6% body fat, and my wife has lost more as well.

How does the scale measure BF%? My impression was that calipers were really the only way to do it accurately without expensive equipment.

A number of consumer scales use some form of electrical pulse timing to determine the composition of tissue in the feet, which is extrapolated for the body. For these results to be meaningful, you have to be very consistent with your hydration before you use the scale.

Re: Living the Fitbit life

#20
post #3
post #2

My wife and I are avid fitbit'ers. We used to walk about an hour every day before we got them so it wasn't like we became fanatics when we got them but things have changed in some very subtle ways: We can get the same amount of walking in even when we travel to a new city, we used to slack off sometimes when we travelled because we didn’t have a “route” to follow. Now we just go and often walk until we get to 1/2 our…

Great story about the tech. Now... What actual benefits have you seen? For example, weight loss, increased muscle strength, blood pressure, heart rate?

The biggest benefit of the technology/data is the motivation it provides to continue being active. If that doesn't motivate you, then there is no value... unless you share the data with a physician who finds value in it, which seems increasingly likely, but not yet common.
Post reply on HN