Live data from Hacker News

Real-time wind map

sightwind.com

1–10 of 20 posts

Re: Real-time wind map

#3
80% off topic, but wind related question I've been wondering about for a while.

Why don't power companies attach wind turbines to high voltage powerline towers? They already own the land and already have the structure built, plus the wiring. Would that make any sense?

Even if reinforcements (or adding height) to the tower are required it seems like a good idea.

Re: Real-time wind map

#4
post #3

80% off topic, but wind related question I've been wondering about for a while. Why don't power companies attach wind turbines to high voltage powerline towers? They already own the land and already have the structure built, plus the wiring. Would that make any sense? Even if reinforcements (or adding height) to the tower are required it seems like a good idea.

The blades on turbines are massive and would require adding a lot of height to the existing towers. Also working around live transmission lines is extremely dangerous much less trying to add to the tower. It's just too dangerous.

Re: Real-time wind map

#5
post #4
post #3

80% off topic, but wind related question I've been wondering about for a while. Why don't power companies attach wind turbines to high voltage powerline towers? They already own the land and already have the structure built, plus the wiring. Would that make any sense? Even if reinforcements (or adding height) to the tower are required it seems like a good idea.

The blades on turbines are massive and would require adding a lot of height to the existing towers. Also working around live transmission lines is extremely dangerous much less trying to add to the tower. It's just too dangerous.

see also: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CqEccgR0q-o or search for 'wind turbine brake failure' on youtube. you don't want this stuff anywhere near high voltage lines.

Re: Real-time wind map

#6
post #3

80% off topic, but wind related question I've been wondering about for a while. Why don't power companies attach wind turbines to high voltage powerline towers? They already own the land and already have the structure built, plus the wiring. Would that make any sense? Even if reinforcements (or adding height) to the tower are required it seems like a good idea.

The place to start would be to figure out how big a turbine the existing towers could support. If you look at the towers for big turbines, they are big tubes of steel, I guess the cylindrical shape is important (strong). If you look at really big power poles, they are lattices (not as strong).

There are power poles that are sort of in between, roundish with flat sides, but they are usually more medium sized.

So you quickly get to asking why do utility companies put their money towards building large (which helps with efficiency) turbines on the best wind sites, rather than smaller turbines on random sites that they own.

Re: Real-time wind map

#10
post #4
post #3

80% off topic, but wind related question I've been wondering about for a while. Why don't power companies attach wind turbines to high voltage powerline towers? They already own the land and already have the structure built, plus the wiring. Would that make any sense? Even if reinforcements (or adding height) to the tower are required it seems like a good idea.

The blades on turbines are massive and would require adding a lot of height to the existing towers. Also working around live transmission lines is extremely dangerous much less trying to add to the tower. It's just too dangerous.

Plus there's the established hazard to wildlife getting chopped in half. A couple months back I read about some kind of passive system involving ionizing water (memory fails; I may be wrong about the method) instead of using turbines. I wonder if building that kind of structure onto a power tower would work.
Post reply on HN