Live data from Hacker News

The Man Who Saves You from Yourself (2013)

harpers.org

141–143 of 143 posts

Re: The Man Who Saves You from Yourself (2013)

#141

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We are also wired for racism and magical thinking but we tend to just avoid it with the use of education, not debating how we are left with racistm-shaped hole.

Good point. I'm not an expert on racism, but it would seem that racism does have positive attributes, especially for the "in" group - social cohesion first among them. I'd argue that the racist hole left in Americans, anyway, was filled with it's opposite: tolerance. The only thing we don't tolerate anymore is intolerance (which, BTW, is a very good change). The "shape" of the hole left by religion is more complex. I…

It's hard for me to see how a belief that you can have a personal relationship with creator of the universe can make you more aware of your insignificance. Scientific view that places you on speck of dust for barely a moment in universes time, until you dissolve into nothing leaving at best some memories in your culture is much more humbling.

People use religion mostly to keep disbelieving in injustice of physical world and to combat loneliness and meaninglessness.

You are spot on that in USA intolerance towards intolerant replaced racism. Nowadays people get fired over careless comments that can be percieved as racially loaded. It's almost funny when observed from a country that has 99.9% of population of one skin color and nationality and where racism by pople who hate it is perceived more of a sheer stupidity than capital offence.

Re: The Man Who Saves You from Yourself (2013)

#142

Earlier quoted context omitted.

... The Iraq war ...

... Anything social group that you don't agree with ...

No, I think even groups I do on later reflection agree with are acting questionably if they try to influence my early education. They probably think it's usually wrong to do so but they make an exception in the case of their ideas because they consider them uniquely urgent and important. That's just an old mistake. Twas ever thus. The more important an idea is, the more important it is to be able to think freely about it.

Re: The Man Who Saves You from Yourself (2013)

#143
post #128

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Those are really passive techniques. Cults have active, planned techniques of mind control. Try this: http://www.scribd.com/doc/514598/How-Cults-Seduce

I was a Jehovah's Witness and since leaving three years ago I have been struggling to differentiate between cult tactics and the control tactics of that particular religion.

JW tactics are definitely taken from the cult playbook.
Post reply on HN