Live data from Hacker News

Facebook Slingshot – A new way to share photos and videos

sling.me

51–60 of 161 posts

Re: Facebook Slingshot – A new way to share photos and videos

#51

We live in the age of wonders. The internet and mobile devices create endless possibilities for people to communicate, learn and interact. And at Facebook, a company which can, if it chooses, pick from among the brightest engineering minds and focus their efforts on any problem it chooses, the power to concentrate years of programming knowledge on the capabilities afforded to us by this astonishing bounty of personal…

The monetization strategy is to pump ads in to it.

Re: Facebook Slingshot – A new way to share photos and videos

#52
post #8

I'm not sure I understand the allure of this; perhaps I'm missing something. So I have to send a video/photo in response to someone who sent me one, in order to see what they sent? It seems like there would be a massive disparity in interesting activities between two parties at any given time to make this concept work. If one of my buddies is having a riot at Coachella and sends me a crazy festival pic for instance,…

Well for one, you wouldn't know what his pic was. And two, that's going to be very very normal in this app.

I like it because it's a pic conversation app (which i enjoy, with close friends) that forces interaction. For those of us already using similar things, this sort of structures our interaction into a conversation, rather than one person simply sending pics to the other.

With that said, i can't help but feel i am the minority of users. Not just here on HN (lets be honest, most things are received poorly on HN), but all around. People have the sense of needing to send something meaningful in a picture, but i like simply idle chat, in picture form. It's neat

Re: Facebook Slingshot – A new way to share photos and videos

#53

We live in the age of wonders. The internet and mobile devices create endless possibilities for people to communicate, learn and interact. And at Facebook, a company which can, if it chooses, pick from among the brightest engineering minds and focus their efforts on any problem it chooses, the power to concentrate years of programming knowledge on the capabilities afforded to us by this astonishing bounty of personal…

So don't work for Facebook. Build something that matters, or work for someone who is. Simple as that.

Re: Facebook Slingshot – A new way to share photos and videos

#55
post #35

This app brings to mind an excerpt for Larry Page - The untold Story: ... Up front, an executive pitched a new product that helped users find the right offline store to do their shopping. The executive was well into his pitch when, suddenly, Page interrupted him. “No,” Page said emphatically. “We don’t do this.” The room grew quiet. “We build products that leverage technology to solve huge problems for hundreds of mi…

Also called the "toothbrush rule". Larry wouldn't allow a product that you didn't use twice a day to be developed at Google.

Re: Facebook Slingshot – A new way to share photos and videos

#56

We live in the age of wonders. The internet and mobile devices create endless possibilities for people to communicate, learn and interact. And at Facebook, a company which can, if it chooses, pick from among the brightest engineering minds and focus their efforts on any problem it chooses, the power to concentrate years of programming knowledge on the capabilities afforded to us by this astonishing bounty of personal…

People want to spend lots of time sharing photos of themselves and cats. Blame humans not Facebook.

Re: Facebook Slingshot – A new way to share photos and videos

#58
post #2

The catch is a pretty big deal, and by deal I mean a deal breaker for me. Why do I have to share something back with someone in order to see what they've shared back at me? I understand it's great for engagement but who would use this over Snapchat or Instagram.

It's called "pic for pic" and I hear the kids are really into it.

Its definitely because they are taking naked pictures of themselves.

Re: Facebook Slingshot – A new way to share photos and videos

#59
post #18

I'm curious to know whether the slingshot team extensively "dogfooded" their application and found that the mandatory slingback requirement wasn't as bad as I'm expecting. I imagine they did. Surely they wouldn't release an app without adequate market research/qa. Still, I'm not convinced. I'll have to try it.

I'm not convinced either, but I'm not going to try it. My immediate thought was DOA.

Same here. Its like sharing, but you have to share to let people share. Seems fucking stupid. Sending a picture is essentially asking for a picture. I can't imagine enough use cases where I think "I'll definitely want to send them this picture if they send me one first" to make this app stick, outside of sending naked pictures of myself in exchange for another one - which I never do.

Outside of using the "must-share-to-care" rule as some sort of teasing or game mechanic, why would they literally create work to share? I simply don't get it.

I'm also more than likely not their target market.

Re: Facebook Slingshot – A new way to share photos and videos

#60
post #8

I'm not sure I understand the allure of this; perhaps I'm missing something. So I have to send a video/photo in response to someone who sent me one, in order to see what they sent? It seems like there would be a massive disparity in interesting activities between two parties at any given time to make this concept work. If one of my buddies is having a riot at Coachella and sends me a crazy festival pic for instance,…

Well for one, you wouldn't know what his pic was. And two, that's going to be very very normal in this app. I like it because it's a pic conversation app (which i enjoy, with close friends) that forces interaction. For those of us already using similar things, this sort of structures our interaction into a conversation, rather than one person simply sending pics to the other. With that said, i can't help but feel i a…

Why the hell would sending dud pictures to see a picture someone sent you be "normal" for the app? Couldn't we use Facebook, Snapchat, or SMS to get the same effect without literally working around a feature? Fucking retarded.

Why would you want to use an app that "forces" interaction? Either the two mutual parties are interested in talking to each other, or they are not. Im sorry, but a photo sharing app like this one will not help my conversations be more engaging. It actually puts up barriers.

"Neat" does not justify the money or engineering talent invested in it. If I was a Facebook share holder, I'd be confused as all hell.

Post reply on HN