Live data from Hacker News

I’m Just Now Realizing How Stupid We Are

fool.com

41–50 of 111 posts

Re: I’m Just Now Realizing How Stupid We Are

#41
/insightful

Not said often, but thanks for taking the time to submit.

> I've learned that there's a strong correlation between knowledge and humility.

Although I think, arrogance is sometimes required to make people understand that it's the Right Thing.

Re: I’m Just Now Realizing How Stupid We Are

#42
post #31

Mostly insightful, but this bit: Those who criticize the behavior of "greedy Wall Street bankers" underestimate their tendency to do the same thing if offered an eight-figure salary. You have to be greedy to go into Wall Street banking in the first place. Most of us deliberately didn't become bankers because we aren't motivated by greed. This makes bankers fair game for criticism.

"You have to be greedy to go into Wall Street banking in the first place."

That sounds false. It also sounds like, after assuming that, literally any thing you can think about investment bankers will automatically be against them, so I would really really make sure that what you say is true before just assuming it.

Also:

"Most of us deliberately didn't become bankers because we aren't motivated by greed."

Really? That's why most people didn't do it? I think most people would become investment bankers with eight-figure salaries, but can't.

"This makes bankers fair game for criticism."

I think everyone is fair game for criticism if they've done something wrong. It's dangerous if you have to first assume someone is a bad person to criticize them.

Re: I’m Just Now Realizing How Stupid We Are

#43
post #31

Mostly insightful, but this bit: Those who criticize the behavior of "greedy Wall Street bankers" underestimate their tendency to do the same thing if offered an eight-figure salary. You have to be greedy to go into Wall Street banking in the first place. Most of us deliberately didn't become bankers because we aren't motivated by greed. This makes bankers fair game for criticism.

You have an insight (bankers are self-selected to be more greedy than average), but the author's point still stands: people underestimate their tendency to do bad things when offered enough money. He phrased it in a way that might seem to morally protect the bankers ("he who is not guilty of greed may throw the first stone..!"), but I don't think that he is trying to argue that the guilty shouldn't be punished.

Re: I’m Just Now Realizing How Stupid We Are

#44
post #31

Mostly insightful, but this bit: Those who criticize the behavior of "greedy Wall Street bankers" underestimate their tendency to do the same thing if offered an eight-figure salary. You have to be greedy to go into Wall Street banking in the first place. Most of us deliberately didn't become bankers because we aren't motivated by greed. This makes bankers fair game for criticism.

"Most of us ... because we aren't motivated by greed"

History would indicate otherwise. Maybe most of us aren't dominated by our greed to the exclusion of all else / to sociopathic levels. But, most of us certainly are greedy. I suspect it's in our genes. Greed/hoarding (to a degree) being evolutionary strengths.

Re: I’m Just Now Realizing How Stupid We Are

#45
"I've learned that journalists' need to write far exceeds the number of things that need to be written. No writer can say to their boss, 'There's nothing important to write about today,' although it is the truth most days."

These words should be inscribed at the top of HN's "submit" page.

Re: I’m Just Now Realizing How Stupid We Are

#46
Tbh, "I've learned that changing your mind is one of the most difficult things we do. It is far easier to fool yourself into believing a falsehood than admit a mistake."

That is probably the one from which many other's stem. If you only make the same mistake a couple of times before changing your mind, you are far, far better off than everyone else because I've seen people repeat the exact same mistake dozens of times.

Tbh, I have too...which is probably why I generally assume I've made a mistake until someone tells me otherwise alot of the time. Well, except for a few things I feel strongly about that aren't simple binaries where everyone might have radically different end goals.

Re: I’m Just Now Realizing How Stupid We Are

#47

If you enjoy reading and absorbing this kind of knowledge, I suggest reading Meditations by Marcus Aurelius. It's a book of personal thoughts/writings/observations that Aurelius wrote while he was emperor of Rome. It's absolutely stunning how much knowledge from back then is still applicable in the modern world. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meditations

+2

Aurelius's Philosophy is timeless.

"The Wisdom of Life, by Arthur Schopenhauer" is another good wisdom book.

Re: I’m Just Now Realizing How Stupid We Are

#50
post #4

> I've learned that there's a strong correlation between knowledge and humility. People who spend 10 minutes on Google studying monetary policy think they have it all figured out, while people with Ph.D.s and decades of experience throw up their hands in frustration. The more you study economics, the more you realize how little we know about it. This is the problem with Congress making decisions about science, the in…

"The trouble with the world is that the stupid are cocksure and the intelligent are full of doubt." Bertrand Russell
Post reply on HN