Live data from Hacker News

Only Apple

daringfireball.net

21–30 of 182 posts

Re: Only Apple

#21
post #2

Oh look, it's a Daring Fireball post where Gruber is talking at length about how awesome Apple is.

Maybe, but the reason it's long is that it's a series of arguments.. supporting points, etc. At least you COULD engage with it if you wanted, unlike so many other pro/con {insert company/platform}.

Re: Only Apple

#22
post #7

I find it hard to argue with any of the points he makes. I'm sure someone here will, but I found myself doing the mental "gulp of air and raising a finger" then getting silenced again. I really wish Microsoft had pulled off Windows Phone; it arguably had a much better user experience than Android did (and still does) -- and interesting Nokia hardware. I simply don't believe Google has the best interests of anyone at…

> I simply don't believe Google has the best interests of anyone at heart except themselves and advertisers. You think Apple has your interests at heart? Or Microsoft? Like Google, they have your cash at heart. Not a thing more.

Yes, my cash - the end user.

Not other companies looking to get my "attention"

Re: Only Apple

#23

There is always a lot of careful insight in Gruber's posts that I like but it is tainted with a type of enthusiasm that doesn't belong in journalism. Even if he is correct, being a cheerleader with liberal praise isn't analysis. It's opinion, and Gruber often reads like an opinionist. Apple is an amazing position to build all kinds of wonderful technology, and Samsung does come across as a shallow copy cat that throw…

he is an apple-centric blogger writing for his own site. where exactly does journalism ever come in play here? don't think gruber ever claimed to be a "journalist".

Re: Only Apple

#24
post #7

I find it hard to argue with any of the points he makes. I'm sure someone here will, but I found myself doing the mental "gulp of air and raising a finger" then getting silenced again. I really wish Microsoft had pulled off Windows Phone; it arguably had a much better user experience than Android did (and still does) -- and interesting Nokia hardware. I simply don't believe Google has the best interests of anyone at…

> I simply don't believe Google has the best interests of anyone at heart except themselves and advertisers. You think Apple has your interests at heart? Or Microsoft? Like Google, they have your cash at heart. Not a thing more.

To march out some old tropes: Apple makes money by delighting users so they will continue to buy products. Google makes money by tracking users, forcefully if necessary, and abusing their advertisers. Microsoft makes money out of legacy ties these days—they don't deserve to continue existing.

Re: Only Apple

#25

Apple is doing well to optimize what the company already has, but has shown little regarding what they plan to do next. Seems like they're playing very safe.

For anyone paying attention, the SDK has been specifically modified to allow for:

1) Smaller satellite devices for iPhone (iWatch? I don't know, but something like it. Look for it in the Continuity & notification widget APIs).

2) More varied size devices (higher resolution iPhone? Look for it in the Xcode size "traits" APIs).

3) A hint that Macs may move to ARM in the next couple of years (look for it in the way they're rolling out new graphics APIs like Metal).

4) Apple TV may be getting native apps connected to your iPhone/iPad apps (look for it in the new Extensions APIs).

While none of the above are hard promises about where Apple's going, they pretty much have no choice than spill this out in the open, as they need to release the SDK and prepare devs for the changes at least some time ahead.

It seems their new strategy is to release software/SDK updates in preparation for new hardware in June during WWDC, then we have a few months padding until developers get their air back, and... starting August/September the new hardware starts coming, just in time for school, and just in time for the winter holiday season.

Neat, I think.

Re: Only Apple

#26
post #5
post #2

Oh look, it's a Daring Fireball post where Gruber is talking at length about how awesome Apple is.

Oh look, it's a snarky comment on Hacker News dismissing Gruber for writing an article on the topic of Apple, without even attempting to address any of the contents of the article.

[deleted]

Re: Only Apple

#27
Finding your one differentiating feature is incredibly valuable for any company, especially in the context of sales.

When customers ask how you compare to competitor A or B, it's awesome to be able to say "we're the only people in the world who offer ______". Having one thing that only you do, allows you to completely reframe the conversation. If the customer cares enough about that feature, you become the obvious choice.

A nice side-effect is increased focus on your team because everyone knows the one thing that matters most.

Re: Only Apple

#28

There is always a lot of careful insight in Gruber's posts that I like but it is tainted with a type of enthusiasm that doesn't belong in journalism. Even if he is correct, being a cheerleader with liberal praise isn't analysis. It's opinion, and Gruber often reads like an opinionist. Apple is an amazing position to build all kinds of wonderful technology, and Samsung does come across as a shallow copy cat that throw…

The other problem is he just doesn't know anything about the industry he's writing on, because he's been a tunnel-vision mac fan for decades.

Current example: just below this article he credits Amazon with inventing a button that connects you to live customer service. The counterexample to that claim is Bloomberg, whose terminals have a dedicated Help key. Striking this key once gets you a help screen, but if you hit it twice someone from Bloomberg calls you immediately. Bloomberg has had that for decades.

Re: Only Apple

#29
post #15

I don't get what the significance of this post is, and why it is at the top of HN. Company A does this and Company B does that and these two are a little similar but not really and this other Company wants this but can't get it. Only this Company. Yeah not that Company. See I figured all this out; see how smart I am? Now and then on a lazy sunday morning with a cuppa in hand and the business news in my lap, I sink in…

I don't feel like addressing your question directly, but it is ironic that the criticism of Gruber is coming from a user named "markdown", which is something Gruber invented. :)

hehe nice!

I am Mark, and any accounts I use for things I do in my downtime are called markdown. Work related accounts have the username markup.

Re: Only Apple

#30
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I simply don't believe Google has the best interests of anyone at heart except themselves and advertisers. You think Apple has your interests at heart? Or Microsoft? Like Google, they have your cash at heart. Not a thing more.

To march out some old tropes: Apple makes money by delighting users so they will continue to buy products. Google makes money by tracking users, forcefully if necessary, and abusing their advertisers. Microsoft makes money out of legacy ties these days—they don't deserve to continue existing.

Yeah I remember the time Google walked up to me on the street and shoved my face into a billboard. Those assholes.
Post reply on HN