Earlier quoted context omitted.
Wouldn't their increased strength and size also offset the increased force of the blows to make it about the same as the current situation? In my head I'm comparing it to something like: If a 250 lb NFL linebacker tackled me at full speed I am pretty sure I would break multiple bones. But NFL running backs take that kind of beating 40-50 times a game, 20 games a year.
Do RBs get the ball that many times per game? I am genuinely curious. I rarely/never watch football so that could be a low number.
Our Skulls Didn’t Evolve to be Punched
61–70 of 94 posts
Re: Our Skulls Didn’t Evolve to be Punched
#62"Given the very few fossils of the australopith face, I am not optimistic that evidence of…" That is the primary reason you shouldn't put much faith in anything you read about most early humanoids, especially not the parts that reach general audiences. We simply cannot know much from the samples we have. Yet, scientists feel the pressure of having to publish, and cannot just publish new measurements, so they hypothis…
Re: Our Skulls Didn’t Evolve to be Punched
#63http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dementia_pugilistica
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chronic_traumatic_encephalopath...
In fact, many people die from just a single punch to the head. They become unconscious and fall on the concrete, for example:
http://www.smh.com.au/national/90-killed-in-singlepunch-assa...
Re: Our Skulls Didn’t Evolve to be Punched
#64Earlier quoted context omitted.
How is that context relevant? There are rocks and sticks on the savanna. Humans are tool-users, so their most natural fighting techniques use tools.
Depends. Two guys who just want to fight are probably going to have a shoving match which will end when one gets pinned and the other guy gets pulled off. Two groups of guys who have some need to fight over are more likely to use tools.
Re: Our Skulls Didn’t Evolve to be Punched
#65I do not want to contradict the research by this, but our heads certainly aren't all too well adapted to punching. The brain is to a large extent floating quite freely in the cerebrospinal fluid in the skull, and when the head is punched it experiences an effect similar to a passenger in a suddenly breaking car - it is smashed against the skull as a result of inertia, often resulting in permanent brain trauma: http:/…
Re: Our Skulls Didn’t Evolve to be Punched
#66Earlier quoted context omitted.
Do RBs get the ball that many times per game? I am genuinely curious. I rarely/never watch football so that could be a low number.
Depends on the back, but feature back's of run heavy offenses definitely get 40-50 touches.
300 carries per season is regarded as a heavy workload, and that works out to about 20 carries per game. Of course, running backs can also catch passes, but they guys that are the featured backs in a run heavy offense rarely catch more than a pass or two per game.
Edit: I found a list of the highest numbers of rushing attempts in an NFL game since 1960. The record is 45.
http://www.pro-football-reference.com/leaders/rush_att_singl...
Re: Our Skulls Didn’t Evolve to be Punched
#67Evolution doesn't work to achieve a goal. It isn't a goal-seaking mechanism.
Are these people getting grant money to pretend they are doing science?
Unbelievable.
Somebody send them copies of "The Blind Watchmaker".
Re: Our Skulls Didn’t Evolve to be Punched
#68Earlier quoted context omitted.
And part of that is not attacking targets where you're likely to significantly injure yourself as well as your opponent. There's a lot to be said for not punching someone in the jaw.
and that part about the right way to hit different parts of the body. a slap is almost as hard, and won't hurt the slapper.
Re: Our Skulls Didn’t Evolve to be Punched
#69As human ancestors became more adept at tool usage, one would expect any evolved skull defenses to crumble. No amount of skull reinforcement will stand up to a solid strike from a club. And even if it did, it wouldn't matter - our huge brains concuss easily, meaning that even if the bone structure itself remained intact following a club blow, the brain it protects would be quite damaged. Human weapon use has been dis…
This, along with the fragility of the bones in the human hand and the hardness of the skull, make it pretty clear that we aren't evolved for punching or being punched. Boxing was developed specifically to get around the many problems with punching: protecting the hands from being broken, and developing defensive strategies to avoid blows from even padded fists. Barehanded boxing is worse. If you want to hurt someone…
One of the reasons for the excellent track record of safety in Mixed Martial Arts is the lack of reliance on heavy padded gloves.
A traditional boxing glove spreads the impact across a wider area resulting in greater likelihood of brain swelling and life-threatening injury.
Lighter gloves or bare knuckle impacts result in less internal swelling but greater likelihood of skin tears, cuts or out right deflected strikes.
Other myths you have posted -
If anything, the evolution of humans as bipedal creatures should have made the legs into the weapons of choice
Nope. Bipedal animals, particularly humans, are not evolved for effective lower leg striking. It takes years of training to be able to throw a kick which balances effectiveness, accuracy and power versus the risk of leaving oneself vulnerable.
You throw a kick and I will try and gouge your eyes out with my thumbs by grappling you. Let's see who has evolved the greater defence.
While the most direct way to hurt someone is actually a straight movement towards someone
Again, most martial artists and boxers will agree that an effective straight line jab is far less powerful than a hook or uppercut thrown with precision to the lower chin, lower jaw or temple. Very few knockouts ever arise from a straight line punch.
Even gated martials arts such as Wing Chun advocate coming in at an oblique angle whereever possible.
IMHO, the most ideal strike a human can give without injuring themselves would be from the shin or heel
In close quarters the most effective strike you can deliver to a standing human opponent is a knee strike or elbow strike. It takes repeated shin strikes in Muay Thai to weaken or disable the upper thighs or ribs.
Re: Our Skulls Didn’t Evolve to be Punched
#70I worked at an oral surgeons office for a few years. Everytime we performed jaw surgery on someone who was in a fight, 9/10 times they also had a broken hand. The hand wasn't designed for punching either.