Live data from Hacker News

HipHop: A "Popcorn Time" for music

gethiphop.net

41–50 of 163 posts

Re: HipHop: A "Popcorn Time" for music

#41

I am still consistently frustrated by lack of video content at reasonable prices, and while I never used it, Popcorn Time seemed like a good thing to me. But, music is a solved problem for me, via Spotify, and I find then that my gut feeling on this is instead that it's parasitic.

For me, video is solved by Amazon Instant Video. They have everything, and it's usually $2-3 a video.

Re: HipHop: A "Popcorn Time" for music

#42

The name is really confusing. A music app called HipHop that isn't focused in hip hop music in particular? That's like naming a bookstore "Comics" and selling all kinds of books. Rapgenius may be branching out (and I have the same doubts in them keeping the rapgenius name), but at least they actually started with rap.

"In computer networking, a hop is one portion of the path between source and destination. Data packets pass through routers and gateways on the way. Each time packets are passed to the next device, a hop occurs."

Facebook uses hiphop as a name for a php platform, and that's fine. The problem here is that you are using it in a music context.

Re: HipHop: A "Popcorn Time" for music

#43

I am still consistently frustrated by lack of video content at reasonable prices, and while I never used it, Popcorn Time seemed like a good thing to me. But, music is a solved problem for me, via Spotify, and I find then that my gut feeling on this is instead that it's parasitic.

Spotify doesn't have everything and it has ads.

Re: HipHop: A "Popcorn Time" for music

#44

The name is really confusing. A music app called HipHop that isn't focused in hip hop music in particular? That's like naming a bookstore "Comics" and selling all kinds of books. Rapgenius may be branching out (and I have the same doubts in them keeping the rapgenius name), but at least they actually started with rap.

In your example, I'd argue that hip hop is a more dominating segment of music than comics are of books. Maybe a book store called "Novel" that sold all kinds of books, which sounds less far fetched for some reason.

Dominating in youth, not well respected by older people, getting into the mainstream because people born in the 80s grew up with it... I don't know, comics sounded like a good counterpart.

Re: HipHop: A "Popcorn Time" for music

#45
post #5

The main selling point of Popcorn Time is that it allows to watch movies more easily than solutions that asks money for that. I don't think music industry has this problem — there are services like Spotify, Rdio and many more that offers painless listening. That aside, the app looks really polished and I'm glad it has Linux support backed in.

No adverts?

It always has to be free with you people... You don't want adverts? Pay for the service. Spotify is well worth the money, £10/month is almost giving it away.

Re: HipHop: A "Popcorn Time" for music

#46
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I use Spotily for streaming however I don't use it to create a offline library exactly for this DRM shit. I'd rather outright buy the songs somewhere else and have them backed up on another computer as well with btsync just in case these DRM apps try to pull some crap.

I used to buy songs from an online store ( Flyte by Flipkart.com, which later was shutdown ) and upload it to Ubuntu One ( which too is going to be shutdown ). The above scenario worked perfectly for me. I could access all my music anytime and from any device but unfortunately looks it didn't work out for the vendors :)

yeah, this still appears to an unsolved problem, even the mighty flipkart were not able to sort out the licenses properly.

I think saavn pro might be an option.

http://www.saavn.com/pro/

Re: HipHop: A "Popcorn Time" for music

#48
It seems the quality of many of the songs are sub-optimal. Would be nice to have some sort of bit rate indicator in the GUI so that I could skip the 128kbps songs. Other than that it seems to have everything I've looked for

Re: HipHop: A "Popcorn Time" for music

#49
post #35

If it sources the tracks from youtube I don't really understand why it needs to be a native app. http://streamus.com/ is a pretty neat chrome extension that does very similar but there are also plenty of websites that do this.

Some people like native apps. There's room for both here.
Post reply on HN