Live data from Hacker News

Mark Zuckerberg and his wife to donate $120M to needy Bay Area schools

mercurynews.com

11–20 of 74 posts

Re: Mark Zuckerberg and his wife to donate $120M to needy Bay Area schools

#11

Needy ... Bay Area ... hahaha!

The Bay Area is bigger than the HN bubble. There are some desperately poor school districts.

The federal government spent $683.7 billion in a year on defense alone. maybe they could spare a few million for the children. Relying on private finance to help schools simply will make matters worse from a big picture in a similar way to how Africa became addicted to overseas aid

Re: Mark Zuckerberg and his wife to donate $120M to needy Bay Area schools

#15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The Bay Area is bigger than the HN bubble. There are some desperately poor school districts.

The federal government spent $683.7 billion in a year on defense alone. maybe they could spare a few million for the children. Relying on private finance to help schools simply will make matters worse from a big picture in a similar way to how Africa became addicted to overseas aid

Sigh.

Did you spend one nanosecond of time doing any research before firing off your oh so pious comment about sparing a few pennies to save the children?

A very quick google found me ed.gov, which is the US Department of Education. Here is an exact quote [1]:

   ED currently administers a budget of $67.3 billion
   in discretionary appropriations (including
   discretionary Pell Grant funding) and operates
   programs that touch on every area and level of
   education. The Department's elementary and
   secondary programs annually serve nearly 16,900
   school districts and approximately 50 million
   students attending more than 98,000 public
   schools and 28,000 private schools. Department
   programs also provide grant, loan, and work-study
   assistance to more than 13 million postsecondary
   students.
So it turns out that the federal government is already spending more than "a few million for the children".

And in case you slept thru civics 101 class, the very next paragraph from the ed.gov website points out:

   That said, it is important to point out that
   education in America is primarily a State and
   local responsibility, and ED's budget is only
   a small part of both total national education
   spending ...
[1] http://www2.ed.gov/about/overview/budget/index.html

Re: Mark Zuckerberg and his wife to donate $120M to needy Bay Area schools

#16
post #13

From a Scandinavian point of view this seems like such a detour. Why wait for billionaires to be so kind of fund schools when you could tax wealth and fund public and universal education? Why do the American people chose this way time after time?

Brainwashing.

The US is an illusion.

Re: Mark Zuckerberg and his wife to donate $120M to needy Bay Area schools

#17
post #13

From a Scandinavian point of view this seems like such a detour. Why wait for billionaires to be so kind of fund schools when you could tax wealth and fund public and universal education? Why do the American people chose this way time after time?

The US has public and universal education.

Re: Mark Zuckerberg and his wife to donate $120M to needy Bay Area schools

#18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The federal government spent $683.7 billion in a year on defense alone. maybe they could spare a few million for the children. Relying on private finance to help schools simply will make matters worse from a big picture in a similar way to how Africa became addicted to overseas aid

Sigh. Did you spend one nanosecond of time doing any research before firing off your oh so pious comment about sparing a few pennies to save the children? A very quick google found me ed.gov, which is the US Department of Education. Here is an exact quote [1]: ED currently administers a budget of $67.3 billion in discretionary appropriations (including discretionary Pell Grant funding) and operates programs that touc…

Personal attacks are not allowed on Hacker News.

Re: Mark Zuckerberg and his wife to donate $120M to needy Bay Area schools

#19
post #13

From a Scandinavian point of view this seems like such a detour. Why wait for billionaires to be so kind of fund schools when you could tax wealth and fund public and universal education? Why do the American people chose this way time after time?

(Fellow European here)

Because:

- Obama is a socialist

- Trickle-down economics is the only thing that works

- Taxing wealth is hating the rich (so basically being a nazi)

- Taxing the wealthy doesn't give them a tax cut like donating money to schools or charities does

- Because taxing job creators just encourages the moochers and takers

(Rinse and repeat ad nauseam until it becomes a way of life)

Re: Mark Zuckerberg and his wife to donate $120M to needy Bay Area schools

#20
post #13

From a Scandinavian point of view this seems like such a detour. Why wait for billionaires to be so kind of fund schools when you could tax wealth and fund public and universal education? Why do the American people chose this way time after time?

Sweden and Denmark have abolished their wealth tax. Also, Sweden uses a voucher system for schools.
Post reply on HN