Live data from Hacker News

The Hobbit House (2012)

beingsomewhere.net

21–30 of 30 posts

Re: The Hobbit House (2012)

#21
post #19

Not that this isn't awesome, but aren't hobbit houses underground? With networks of tunnels and hillside windows and entrances? This looks like a rustic country house with a green roof. As much as I like this, I'd prefer something actually underground.

Sounds more like dwarfs. Pretty confident Bilbo's house did not have any other homes connected to it. It was built into the side of a hill as a standalone home.

Re: The Hobbit House (2012)

#22
post #19

Not that this isn't awesome, but aren't hobbit houses underground? With networks of tunnels and hillside windows and entrances? This looks like a rustic country house with a green roof. As much as I like this, I'd prefer something actually underground.

> Not that this isn't awesome, but aren't hobbit houses underground?

IIRC, there's considerable difference based around relative wealth, and many less well-off hobbits lived in above ground homes. Most of the principal hobbits in LOTR (except Sam, I think) lived in large underground mansions, but they were rather well-off hobbits.

Even so, the construction approach here (digging a partial hole, building a frame that extends somewhat above the original ground level, and then taking the dirt from the whole and covering the structure) seems a fairly practical method of building what ends up being an underground home, and the result is visually similar to the art that has accompanied various editions of the books (and the look used in the movies) for hobbit homes, so it seems pretty reasonable.

Re: The Hobbit House (2012)

#23
post #19

Not that this isn't awesome, but aren't hobbit houses underground? With networks of tunnels and hillside windows and entrances? This looks like a rustic country house with a green roof. As much as I like this, I'd prefer something actually underground.

To do it right you'd have to build the structure with reinforced concrete, able to withstand tonnes of soil while forming a desired shape. You can then decorate it from inside as you want, make an exact copy of Bilbo's house if that's your goal. Such a project would be quite expensive though and well beyond capacity of an amateur.

Re: The Hobbit House (2012)

#24
post #14

This looks like a very neat project. I am tremendously curious how this will hold up with time. I have recently finished building a house (as an inexperienced general contractor). A ton of things deal with how things will behave over time as opposed to how they will work right after construction has finished. I am particularly curious about the fairly loosely-packed bales of hay and the plastic used to waterproof the…

This has been on the internet, at least, for a few years.

Those are the original project photos--I've not seen any updated ones.

Re: The Hobbit House (2012)

#25
post #9

The only thing that concerns me here is the structural soundness, very cool project though.

I agree. From the captions on the construction pictures: > Lift logs, prop up, nail together and continue until no longer wobbly. That's not very reassuring.

On the other hand, while structural soundness was much worse in the past than it might be today, this method has served humanity fairly well for a very long time.

Re: The Hobbit House (2012)

#27
post #19

Not that this isn't awesome, but aren't hobbit houses underground? With networks of tunnels and hillside windows and entrances? This looks like a rustic country house with a green roof. As much as I like this, I'd prefer something actually underground.

Sounds more like dwarfs. Pretty confident Bilbo's house did not have any other homes connected to it. It was built into the side of a hill as a standalone home.

I meant that the several rooms of a single home were connected by tunnels, not that multiple homes were connected together.

This is always how I've imagined my dream house to be. Energy efficient, immersed in nature, easy to hide if necessary.

Re: The Hobbit House (2012)

#28
post #8
post #7

Does it, um have a toilet? Or electricity?

Read the article. It has a composting toilet, uses skylights for daylight illumination and has solar panels for electrical needs. Doesn't seem to use it for refrigeration though, which seems limiting.

I live in a similar-ish situation where I live on a narrowboat in London. I have a solar panel for electrical needs and I run the boat engine once every few days during the winter. For refrigeration, I've got a 12v fridge but many people I know use gas fridges. Fridges use up an amazing amount of power. But the fridge is really the only thing I run off electricity - occasionally charge up my laptop and charge my phone off the 12v supply. But yes, my boat batteries are pretty much there only for the fridge.

Re: The Hobbit House (2012)

#29
post #24
post #14

This looks like a very neat project. I am tremendously curious how this will hold up with time. I have recently finished building a house (as an inexperienced general contractor). A ton of things deal with how things will behave over time as opposed to how they will work right after construction has finished. I am particularly curious about the fairly loosely-packed bales of hay and the plastic used to waterproof the…

This has been on the internet, at least, for a few years. Those are the original project photos--I've not seen any updated ones.

I seem to remember reading about people living in a hobbit-house type thing (I think it may have been this one) leaving after a few years. I don't remember if the house had become unsound or if the local government finally caught wind of their "nail it together until it stops wobbling" building technique and condemned the place.

Re: The Hobbit House (2012)

#30
Love these kinds of houses, however getting a construction permit is hard. First there is the "is it structurally ok ?", but cob houses can be build correctly. And second is getting the "looks" approved, all houses have to look the same and all that :(
Post reply on HN