Live data from Hacker News

Don't mess with Newegg

blog.newegg.com

41–50 of 200 posts

Re: Don't mess with Newegg

#41
post #14

It seems to me that the legal system in the US is largely broken, and that just about anyone can be sued if only you find the right grounds. Being sued and defending yourself is enormously expensive which is what patent trolls exploit. Why not use this offensively against patent trolls? Find all sorts of ways to take them to court, the American legal seems to have plenty of opportunities in that regard. There are som…

Some may refuse to do this as a matter of principle - not sinking to the level of those you despise.

Re: Don't mess with Newegg

#43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If they can't pay due to bankruptcy, isn’t there a chance as someone they owe money you will get some of their patents (assets)?

If you win then their patents aren't very valuable.

But you've also taken away (at least some of) their tools to troll people with.

Re: Don't mess with Newegg

#45
It seems to me that there is a good way for the industry as a whole to address the issue of patent trolls without waiting for legal reform by attacking the economics of the business.

Trolls make money by simply 1. Amassing patent portfolios (the only real fixed costs for this business) 2. Sending infringement letters to victims (sorry, targets) 3. Walking to the bank to cash the checks of companies who cannot afford a legal battle.

Once a troll goes to court, the economics of the business start to fall apart as the legal fees add up and eat into profits. Also, they risk invalidating their patents which jeopardize future revenue streams.

It should be possible to create an alliance of companies (Apple, Google, Yahoo, Microsoft are obvious candidates) that have an interest in a strong ecosystem of innovation to put together a fund that makes legal defense grants available to anyone in the mobile/web space who can demonstrate they have a plausible defense case. The amount needed would not be large (less than $20 million a year should be sufficient to cover the entire industry) since just the fact that every kid on the playground now has the ability to face up to the bullies will reduce the bad behavior considerably.

Re: Don't mess with Newegg

#46
I agree with the principle presented here... but before we all hail Newegg, I'll explain why I have not conducted business with this company since 2009...

Here is a letter I wrote Amex then, disputing a nasty transaction with this company.  https://www.dropbox.com/s/8b8dg9diowqz48y/Amex%20Dispute%20R...

This is real, and I won.

Re: Don't mess with Newegg

#48
Acacia Research has been at this for a long time now. I remember when they went after porn. They claimed to own streaming media and thought the adult industry would settle. While some did, one company took them up and won. If I remember he said it cost them $500k to defend.

Re: Don't mess with Newegg

#50

I really wish NewEgg had shirts that looked better than the ones they sell.

I get plenty of compliments on my "Geek On" shirt. Of course, something more subdued and pro would be nice...maybe even a collar?

I've been down on their services the last few years, lots of headaches and noticeable lag in ship times... it feels like they had the IPO after all. Also, I don't appreciate having to take the extra step/refresh to exclude the 'Marketplace' from my searches every time... drop-ship crap has sullied their image, IMO. Anyway, I will recommence making them my 'go-to' e-tailer due to this action & for their years of providing (mostly) exhaustive product images, complete spec pages & informed reviews.

Post reply on HN