Live data from Hacker News

Questions for Donald Knuth

informit.com

11–20 of 61 posts

Re: Questions for Donald Knuth

#11
post #2

Awesome Read. Picking out a line: "For simplicity, let me say that people like me are "geeks," and that geeks comprise about 2% of the world's population."

"I know that my books still aren't terribly easy to fathom, even for geeks. But I could have made them much, much harder."

Re: Questions for Donald Knuth

#12

"So who were the geeks of the early 19th century?" This question made me pause and ask another question: Who are the geeks of the early 21st century, specifically, 2014? I fear in my heart that software development is becoming less and less of a "geek" hideout over time. I did, however, go to Maker Faire last weekend. It was a geek wonderland. There were so many cool projects on display and a huge emphasis on getting…

DIY biotech. Bespoke pets for the risk-averse, and bespoke personal physiology for the rest.

Re: Questions for Donald Knuth

#13
I've been to couple of Donald Knuth's Christmas Tree Lectures. While he was signing my copy of 'TAOCP Volume 1', I asked him if he thought anyone in the world had read all of TAOCP, himself excluded. I didn't clarify, but he seemed to assume (correctly) that by 'read' I meant 'read and comprehended.'

His reply was yes, but not many. He mentioned a guy in Germany who goes over his books again and again looking for errors. This guy is the leading recipient of Knuth's checks.

That was the question I'd wanted to ask Knuth for several years. It was a good question for a thirty second interaction and photo.

Re: Questions for Donald Knuth

#14
What an amazing exchange of ideas;

Knuths response to Tarjans Q15 was particularly interesting since he was able to illustrate his insight with a concrete example;

>Thus I think the present state of research in algorithm design misunderstands the true nature of efficiency. The literature exhibits a dangerous trend in contemporary views of what deserves to be published.

> Another issue, when we come down to earth, is the efficiency of algorithms on real computers. As part of the Stanford GraphBase project I implemented four algorithms to compute minimum spanning trees of graphs, one of which was the very pretty method that you developed with Cheriton and Karp. Although I was expecting your method to be the winner, because it examines much of the data only half as often as the others, it actually came out two to three times worse than Kruskal's venerable method. Part of the reason was poor cache interaction, but the main cause was a large constant factor hidden by O notation.

Re: Questions for Donald Knuth

#15
In the Q&A Knuth mentions TAOCP conversion to ebook several times - I did a quick search and found only millions of pirate sites. Does anyone know the legitimate source where the ebook can be bought? Informit seemed likely but there are only two digital volumes available there.

(edit: there is a note saying "as they become available". I guess TAOCP is only partially portable so far, more to come.)

(brag: I got a decimal dollar by check from Professor Knuth for finding a typo in 2010. Nothing clever, just a cheap typo, but I was happy.)

Re: Questions for Donald Knuth

#16

In the Q&A Knuth mentions TAOCP conversion to ebook several times - I did a quick search and found only millions of pirate sites. Does anyone know the legitimate source where the ebook can be bought? Informit seemed likely but there are only two digital volumes available there. (edit: there is a note saying "as they become available". I guess TAOCP is only partially portable so far, more to come.) (brag: I got a deci…

Way cool on the brag. I thought he stopped with the checks.

Re: Questions for Donald Knuth

#17

In the Q&A Knuth mentions TAOCP conversion to ebook several times - I did a quick search and found only millions of pirate sites. Does anyone know the legitimate source where the ebook can be bought? Informit seemed likely but there are only two digital volumes available there. (edit: there is a note saying "as they become available". I guess TAOCP is only partially portable so far, more to come.) (brag: I got a deci…

[deleted]

Re: Questions for Donald Knuth

#18

In the Q&A Knuth mentions TAOCP conversion to ebook several times - I did a quick search and found only millions of pirate sites. Does anyone know the legitimate source where the ebook can be bought? Informit seemed likely but there are only two digital volumes available there. (edit: there is a note saying "as they become available". I guess TAOCP is only partially portable so far, more to come.) (brag: I got a deci…

Way cool on the brag. I thought he stopped with the checks.

They are no longer legal currency but are issued on the The Bank of San Serriffe (address:Thirty Point, Caissa Inferiore, San Serriffe, Pincus).

The reason for the change: http://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~uno/news08.html

Re: Questions for Donald Knuth

#19

In the Q&A Knuth mentions TAOCP conversion to ebook several times - I did a quick search and found only millions of pirate sites. Does anyone know the legitimate source where the ebook can be bought? Informit seemed likely but there are only two digital volumes available there. (edit: there is a note saying "as they become available". I guess TAOCP is only partially portable so far, more to come.) (brag: I got a deci…

I've seen 3 volumes recently posted on Safari Books Online

Re: Questions for Donald Knuth

#20
post #7

"I did write a compiler manual in 1958, which by chance was actually used as the textbook for one of my classes in 1959(!)" How many people in the world could claim something similar?

When I first read that, I assumed he was teaching the class. But after checking Wikipedia I found that he received his bachelor of science degree in 1960. Now I'm astonished.
Post reply on HN