Live data from Hacker News

Why is San Francisco public transportation so bad?

alexmedearis.com

1–10 of 112 posts

Re: Why is San Francisco public transportation so bad?

#6
This is a great overview of the history of SF's mass transit systems, but honestly, it's really not as bad as everyone makes it out to be. Was it better when the streetcars ran everywhere? Of course. But compared to cities like Boston or Dallas or Atlanta, SF's Muni and BART are amazing, though Caltrain is admittedly the weakest link of the system.

Re: Why is San Francisco public transportation so bad?

#8

This is a great overview of the history of SF's mass transit systems, but honestly, it's really not as bad as everyone makes it out to be. Was it better when the streetcars ran everywhere? Of course. But compared to cities like Boston or Dallas or Atlanta, SF's Muni and BART are amazing, though Caltrain is admittedly the weakest link of the system.

It really is terrible. What you're saying is like saying having 5 pennies is amazing compared to having 1 penny.

Re: Why is San Francisco public transportation so bad?

#9
Coming to SF and Expecting world beating infrastructure is a very naive expectation to begin with.

Keep in mind the kind of politics (and hence policies) that SF is known for. It is not know for ruthless efficiency and well oiled policies, it is instead the "WORST run big city in the US" http://www.sfweekly.com/2009-12-16/news/the-worst-run-big-ci...

Do not expect things to get better either unfortunately.

Re: Why is San Francisco public transportation so bad?

#10
One major challenge in the Bay Area often boils down to the lack of a government with the authority to collect taxes and impetus to spend them on Bay Area infrastructure. You either need three city governments and a pile of local ones to get on the same page, or persuade a state government that is not particularly keen on Bay Area spending and hamstrung by ballot initiatives.
Post reply on HN