Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Learn AngularJS with free interactive lessons

learn-angular.org

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

21–27 of 27 posts

Re: Learn AngularJS with free interactive lessons

#21

Post by andybak »

clubhi wrote: post #16
ttty wrote: post #14

Look at the pages indexed in google: https://www.google.pt/search?q=inurl%3Ahttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.lear... Now look at the source with ctrl+u. (example url: view-source: http://www.learn-angular.org/#!/lessons/binding-css-classes ) Now you know why he needs server side rendering (: Anyway I never tried angular, and this tutorial made me try it. Is explains very very well how to get started, that's true.

Seeing how I figured out how to index angularjs pages for searching myself in one evening I imagine it won't be too long before google improves on this.

I'm not sure it's Google's job to.

Or rather - even if Google figures out how to index these pages, why should every other consumer of web content have to also figure it out when it's the fault of the content itself.

i.e. don't break the web.

Re: Learn AngularJS with free interactive lessons

#22

Post by andybak »

exodust wrote: post #3

I might take a look at this, have not yet looked into Angular. It is a little disappointing to disable javascript and refresh the page at www.learn-angular.org, it's just a blank page. As much as I'm a javascript fan, and have made single page apps, a completely blank page without JS just feels wrong. I'm guessing this isn't the fault of Angular.. or is it?

https://github.com/LeviBotelho/LearnAngular/issues/12

Re: Learn AngularJS with free interactive lessons

#23

Post by twerquie »

andybak wrote: post #21
clubhi wrote: post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Seeing how I figured out how to index angularjs pages for searching myself in one evening I imagine it won't be too long before google improves on this.

I'm not sure it's Google's job to. Or rather - even if Google figures out how to index these pages, why should every other consumer of web content have to also figure it out when it's the fault of the content itself. i.e. don't break the web.

I would argue that Google's job now includes executing javascript and evaluating dynamically loaded content.

Break the web.

Re: Learn AngularJS with free interactive lessons

#25

Post by andybak »

twerquie wrote: post #23
andybak wrote: post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not sure it's Google's job to. Or rather - even if Google figures out how to index these pages, why should every other consumer of web content have to also figure it out when it's the fault of the content itself. i.e. don't break the web.

I would argue that Google's job now includes executing javascript and evaluating dynamically loaded content. Break the web.

Be careful what you wish for.

Re: Learn AngularJS with free interactive lessons

#27

Post by devNoise »

twerquie wrote: post #23
andybak wrote: post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not sure it's Google's job to. Or rather - even if Google figures out how to index these pages, why should every other consumer of web content have to also figure it out when it's the fault of the content itself. i.e. don't break the web.

I would argue that Google's job now includes executing javascript and evaluating dynamically loaded content. Break the web.

I would tend to agree that google needs to solve this problem for indexing. They were the source for angular.js and they must realize that stuff they want to index will be buried in one page javascript apps going forward.
Post reply on HN