Live data from Hacker News

How to throttle the FCC to dial up modem speeds

gist.github.com

41–50 of 127 posts

Re: How to throttle the FCC to dial up modem speeds

#41
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agreed and also this should be true for the pay of elected officials and corporate executives.

Good luck attracting and retaining talent if you can't pay market prices for executives.

I doubt they should be so worried. Studies show no link between executive pay and executive performance: http://www.economist.com/blogs/graphicdetail/2012/02/focus-0

Re: How to throttle the FCC to dial up modem speeds

#43
post #25

Can someone ELI5 this? Why would the FCC visit your site?

Would be funny if porn sites implemented this. If FCC employees are like other federal departments there's a good chance that's how they spend a lot of their time[1]. [1] http://www.seeyounexttuesday.com/study-federal-employees-spe...

Kind of a specious leap to cite an article with a linkbait headline and lace it with words like "good chance" and "a lot of their time"

TFA cites a few isolated cases and sensationalizes it. The government is the biggest employer in the United States; a few dozen does not an epidemic make.

Re: How to throttle the FCC to dial up modem speeds

#44
The pictures comment lead me to Tom's list of speeches, the latest of which directly contradicts the claims being made here. Are we sure the FCC is the bad guy?

http://www.fcc.gov/document/chairman-tom-wheeler-remarks-nct...

"Let me be clear. If someone acts to divide the Internet between “haves” and “have-nots,” we will use every power at our disposal to stop it."

"Prioritizing some traffic by forcing the rest of the traffic into a congested lane won’t be permitted under any proposed Open Internet rule. We will not allow some companies to force Internet users into a slow lane so that others with special privileges can have superior service."

Re: How to throttle the FCC to dial up modem speeds

#45
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure fire way to encourage politicans to take bribes as well as ensuring only the independently wealthy can be politicians,

> take bribes as well as ensuring only the independently wealthy can be politicians Those are other, unrelated problems that need to be addressed in their own right, but cannot be used as justification for high pay scale of politicians.

I suspect most high ranking government officials in the US could make significantly more in the private sector so it's hard to claim there's a high scale of pay for politicians -- at least in the US.

Re: How to throttle the FCC to dial up modem speeds

#46
post #44

The pictures comment lead me to Tom's list of speeches, the latest of which directly contradicts the claims being made here. Are we sure the FCC is the bad guy? http://www.fcc.gov/document/chairman-tom-wheeler-remarks-nct... "Let me be clear. If someone acts to divide the Internet between “haves” and “have-nots,” we will use every power at our disposal to stop it." "Prioritizing some traffic by forcing the rest of th…

"Actions speak louder than words."

The FCC could put the money where their mouth is by re-classifying ISPs as "Title II - Common Carriers."

Re: How to throttle the FCC to dial up modem speeds

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> take bribes as well as ensuring only the independently wealthy can be politicians Those are other, unrelated problems that need to be addressed in their own right, but cannot be used as justification for high pay scale of politicians.

I suspect most high ranking government officials in the US could make significantly more in the private sector so it's hard to claim there's a high scale of pay for politicians -- at least in the US.

Politicians don't get rich from their paycheck.

Re: How to throttle the FCC to dial up modem speeds

#48
post #38

I think the focus on the FCC is too narrow. In my opinion throttling all .gov addresses would be more effective. Including .edu addresses would affect a population with plenty of time on their hands and who aren't afraid to let everyone know about their problems.

And a bunch of people who don't have time on their hands (staff and faculty) who will probably just go "Fuck you guys, now you're getting in the way of work."

Isn't that the idea?

Re: How to throttle the FCC to dial up modem speeds

#49

I'd like to see a law that government offices can only have an internet connection as fast as the slowest constituent.

That would basically mean that any government internal IT project would have to be able to work usable on dialup. Government IT contracting is already enough of a disaster.

Re: How to throttle the FCC to dial up modem speeds

#50
I don't think the entire FCC, and all of their employees are really out to get you and I. A few maybe but I think it's somewhat too broad an approach to punish the few by punishing everyone associated with the FCC.

Their IT staff probably doesn't deserve this either.

Post reply on HN