Live data from Hacker News

Nassim Taleb (Black Swan) open letter to David Cameron

guardian.co.uk

61–66 of 66 posts

Re: Nassim Taleb (Black Swan) open letter to David Cameron

#61
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not when it keeps being rehashed ad nauseum .

Maybe he intends to keep rehashing it until people understand . Good ideas, it seems, need to be repeated.

The only good idea that he has is to repeat and rehash in order to sell more books.

Re: Nassim Taleb (Black Swan) open letter to David Cameron

#63

This is ridiculous. The financial crisis was not a "black swan." Many people saw it coming and prepared accordingly. It was only groupthink and willful ignorance which kept most people from doing so.

It's not a black swan for everybody but it's a black swan for a lot of people.

Re: Nassim Taleb (Black Swan) open letter to David Cameron

#64
post #58
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Taleb wants financial services to come in two flavors: boring, predictable, public banking utiliies; and no-safety-net no-bailout risk-taking investment." But how do you get there? How do you make sure they don't spin out of control or even how do you decide which firms to break up and how? (I don't disagree, I am genuinely interested in learning how he sees it can be implemented and without new significant regulati…

One way to make banks boring and predictable would be to define precisely what kind of products they are allowed to sell. This sounds like what Taleb would want, but it don't think it would be good to entirely eliminate innovation. But if regulators would forbid any product valued by models they don't understand, it would probably be a good start.

Taleb has no problem with innovation - as long as the risk of the innovation is borne by the innovators, or investors putting their own money at risk. The problem occurs when people bet other people's money, reaping nost of the rewards when the bet pays off, and incurring little loss when the bet goes wrong.

Re: Nassim Taleb (Black Swan) open letter to David Cameron

#65
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe he intends to keep rehashing it until people understand . Good ideas, it seems, need to be repeated.

Good ideas, it seems, need to be repeated. Absolutely not. Ideas that are diffuse and unoriginal, on the other hand, are often repeated because they are uncompelling. I've read The Black Swan , and although it was entertaining, I didn't feel like I learned anything of value.

Absolutely not.

Bastiat articulated the Broken Window Fallacy in 1850, and here we are 159 years later shredding perfectly good cars to 'create jobs.' It certainly seems like some good ideas can't be repeated often enough.

Re: Nassim Taleb (Black Swan) open letter to David Cameron

#66
post #49
post #47

Before one gets hysterical, consider debt as a function of GDP. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:USDebt.png http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_public_debt

Yeah, but the problem is that the rest of the world is not currently blown to smithereens and in need of American labor and capital to rebuild it the way it was in 1945 (not to mention deeply indebted to the United States as well). The trough of that graph is about the point where Western Europe and Japan managed to rebuild their economies to the point where they could actually compete effectively. The United States…

So where is all the US output going?
Post reply on HN