Live data from Hacker News

AmazonCart – Add items to your Amazon.com shopping cart without leaving Twitter

amazon.com

21–30 of 38 posts

Re: AmazonCart – Add items to your Amazon.com shopping cart without leaving Twitter

#21
post #2

Very interesting merger of social and e-commerce here. I'd expect other players in the space to follow suit, or at least discover new ways to engage their clientele via social channels.

We gotta stop using the word "engage" so much.

There's a myth among social media marketers that their worth is measured by how much they "engage" users. Problem is, the word "engage" is vague enough to cover any action. Liking is engaging. Clicking is engaging. Commenting is engaging. So companies post crap on Facebook that does nothing for their bottom line, but justify it by the number of times it was liked or shared. That's how we get all this clickbait nonsense. It doesn't actually "engage" anyone, but it gets clicked.

So lets be specific. This is not "engaging clientele via social channels". This is using twitter for window shopping, not to mention free advertising. And I for one think it's a terrible idea. Twitter an unsuitable interface for shopping, and I don't want the whole world to know what I'm buying on Amazon.

Sorry to flip out on you. It just seemed like the ideal place to criticize the breezy, bs-filled lingo of the tech industry. Likewise, I'm annoyed by "other players in the space". You could have easily said "other online retailers."

Re: AmazonCart – Add items to your Amazon.com shopping cart without leaving Twitter

#22
post #8

"Garbage up your interaction with real humans to make talking to our robot a little easier."

Maybe. Or this is equivalent (better?) than liking on Facebook. This feels like a "Like" but actually takes action that is valuable to the business.

Re: AmazonCart – Add items to your Amazon.com shopping cart without leaving Twitter

#23
Wow that is a new twist to privacy I din't see coming. Let the world know what you are buying and what could possibly go wrong. How long until advertisers or spammers pull in automated scans for tweets with #AmazonCart and start delivering personalized recommendation via direct message or via a mention on their tweet. Well atleast they got to narrow it down from possible customers to potential customers.

Re: AmazonCart – Add items to your Amazon.com shopping cart without leaving Twitter

#25

What is the benefit here to the tweeter? I guess you could post an affiliate link and get paid for it. Otherwise you're just advertising for amazon for free, which hardly needs doing.

A lot of people tweet random amazon links on my feed, not affiliates, just normal people that buy stuff on amazon. I could see it coming in handy for them. I personally don't see any need for this in my life right now, though I do buy a lot on Amazon. For marketers, this could be a huge deal.

Yeah. Especially because Amazon pays to retarget people based on their cart items until they convert. So if you have goods listed on Amazon, this is a way to quickly get people that you interact with on Twitter to sign up to get more pressure on them to make the extra step from add cart -> purchase. If they can make it so that you don't even have to visit the Amazon site to give you cart reminders I could see more people than just Amazon adopting this. So you effectively get free ads on Amazon's dime if you can get customers to adopt it.

Even people like small authors could do great with this: they can have a smooth transition from talking about their book with people online to having them buy it without relying on people's keeping their short term memory together so they remember to pick up the book. Authors sell books on their book tours because people don't have a chance to forget to pick up a copy.

If you find it annoying, you can just either not follow the Amazon accounts or block them. This is a nifty little thing, and it'd be a shame if it gets screwed up.

Re: AmazonCart – Add items to your Amazon.com shopping cart without leaving Twitter

#26
post #23

Wow that is a new twist to privacy I din't see coming. Let the world know what you are buying and what could possibly go wrong. How long until advertisers or spammers pull in automated scans for tweets with #AmazonCart and start delivering personalized recommendation via direct message or via a mention on their tweet. Well atleast they got to narrow it down from possible customers to potential customers.

You can't DM someone that you don't follow. Twitter already exposes all the text of non-protected accounts to advertisers for their contextual ad products.

'Automated scans for tweets' are what Twitter already sells to advertisers. That's their entire ad product. Who you follow and what you talk about on your account are already used to target ads to your feed. @mentioning when you don't follow just dumps you into the non-default notifications tab, which users have to tap to 'all' to actually see.

You're totally correct that it's a privacy concern. It helps a little that Twitter doesn't have a real name policy. I am more concerned about the total lack of privacy in credit card transactions, because there is no way to opt out of that. In this case the user can at least opt out of sharing their transactions with the world. With credit cards we're all opted in to dumping our account data into a marketplace that can be easily connected to a real name.

Re: AmazonCart – Add items to your Amazon.com shopping cart without leaving Twitter

#27
post #23

Wow that is a new twist to privacy I din't see coming. Let the world know what you are buying and what could possibly go wrong. How long until advertisers or spammers pull in automated scans for tweets with #AmazonCart and start delivering personalized recommendation via direct message or via a mention on their tweet. Well atleast they got to narrow it down from possible customers to potential customers.

What could go wrong? Honest question.

I understand the need for privacy and announcing your purcheses to the world seems both uncomfortable and a little gauche to me but spam is a separate problem that each platform will have to deal with regardless.

Re: AmazonCart – Add items to your Amazon.com shopping cart without leaving Twitter

#28
post #23

Wow that is a new twist to privacy I din't see coming. Let the world know what you are buying and what could possibly go wrong. How long until advertisers or spammers pull in automated scans for tweets with #AmazonCart and start delivering personalized recommendation via direct message or via a mention on their tweet. Well atleast they got to narrow it down from possible customers to potential customers.

What could go wrong? Honest question. I understand the need for privacy and announcing your purcheses to the world seems both uncomfortable and a little gauche to me but spam is a separate problem that each platform will have to deal with regardless.

Well look at it from the spammer's side, you just made things easy for them, now instead of blasting out millions of spam, they can now concentrate on people who actually spend money online (and may have an impulse nature given they are shopping from twitter). I used to have random bots follow me and then include me when they tweet a spam link. Now if they were to know I purchased X, they could spam with

"@ACME I have been using X but I love this product Y more, what do you think? bit.ly/1234"

Sure most techies might not fall for it but there are plenty of others who will.

Re: AmazonCart – Add items to your Amazon.com shopping cart without leaving Twitter

#29
post #23

Wow that is a new twist to privacy I din't see coming. Let the world know what you are buying and what could possibly go wrong. How long until advertisers or spammers pull in automated scans for tweets with #AmazonCart and start delivering personalized recommendation via direct message or via a mention on their tweet. Well atleast they got to narrow it down from possible customers to potential customers.

You can't DM someone that you don't follow. Twitter already exposes all the text of non-protected accounts to advertisers for their contextual ad products. 'Automated scans for tweets' are what Twitter already sells to advertisers. That's their entire ad product. Who you follow and what you talk about on your account are already used to target ads to your feed. @mentioning when you don't follow just dumps you into th…

>You can't DM someone that you don't follow. Twitter already exposes all the text of non-protected accounts to advertisers for their contextual ad products.

I agree but think about it this way. I follow Starbucks because I like them and visit them often. Now I see a link for discounted Starbucks coffee on Amazon and purchase them via twitter. Prior to that Starbucks had to make assumptions or run some machine algo on my tweets to determine: a) I am not a bot and b) My loyalty can or cannot be leveraged. However with this purchase, whenever they bring out a new flavor they could be certain with some confidence that I would make a purchase, thus messaging me personally or including me in one of their tweets.

Its not necessarily a bad thing but history has it that convenience always has its price.

Re: AmazonCart – Add items to your Amazon.com shopping cart without leaving Twitter

#30
post #18

What's interesting to me is that this is not a partnership between Twitter and Amazon. Amazon is simply using the API to get the hashtag results. The way Twitter would want this to happen is by using Twitter Cards with a button to add to the cart. Of course they would be able to tax the use that way. I wouldn't be surprised if Twitter makes a move to block this functionality.

How could they block this? It's an incredibly general use case of their API.
Post reply on HN