Live data from Hacker News

Blackberry had its first good idea in years

wired.com

11–20 of 29 posts

Re: Blackberry had its first good idea in years

#11

The hyperbole of this line demeans the whole article, 'one of this century’s biggest corporate disasters ' 14 years into the 21st Century? Come on.

I interpreted it as "one of the biggest corporate disasters of the last 14 years," and would give the author the benefit of the doubt that that is what she meant.

Re: Blackberry had its first good idea in years

#12

The hyperbole of this line demeans the whole article, 'one of this century’s biggest corporate disasters ' 14 years into the 21st Century? Come on.

Seriously. I think the global oil companies will have something to show us about corporate disaster before the century is up.

In any case, 86 years is a lot of years remaining for someone to do a worse job than BlackBerry.

Re: Blackberry had its first good idea in years

#13
post #8

Blackberry just doesn't have traction outside of the US, since most of the rest of the world deeply distrust the architecture of the Blackberry system (i.e. all data sent back to US-based servers). I think this is the one thing they must fix - the perception by the world that Blackberry is just a front for the CIA. Laugh all you want: I've heard this expressed in more than one location here in Europe, enough so that…

"since most of the rest of the world deeply distrust the architecture of the Blackberry system (i.e. all data sent back to US-based servers). I think this is the one thing they must fix - the perception by the world that Blackberry is just a front for the CIA"

I found that funny because that's the exact opposite of what actually happened. BlackBerry was to secure and certain governments couldn't spy on their citizens. Here is an article from where this misinformation stemmed from: http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-10830485

I'm guessing people only read headlines and a lot of them had "BlackBerry" and "Security" in them and most people jumped to conclusions.

BlackBerry has many NOC's and not one is in the US.

Re: Blackberry had its first good idea in years

#14
post #7

Having an investment from a company like Blackberry may on the surface look just the same as any other investment. But in fact things are dramatically different. You may very well end up having your stock sold to the highest bidder at some future liquidation auction (there is a definitive chance of Blackberry ending like that) and then suddenly you find yourself with a new partner that you didn't choose. One that may…

The QNX kernel was released under open source in 2007. Not all other middleware is released though ...

Re: Blackberry had its first good idea in years

#15
post #7

Having an investment from a company like Blackberry may on the surface look just the same as any other investment. But in fact things are dramatically different. You may very well end up having your stock sold to the highest bidder at some future liquidation auction (there is a definitive chance of Blackberry ending like that) and then suddenly you find yourself with a new partner that you didn't choose. One that may…

The QNX kernel was released under open source in 2007. Not all other middleware is released though ...

Right, but it was closed again in 2010 and I'm not quite sure what the status is today but as far as I am aware you can not just go and fork it or even build it.

Re: Blackberry had its first good idea in years

#16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The QNX kernel was released under open source in 2007. Not all other middleware is released though ...

Right, but it was closed again in 2010 and I'm not quite sure what the status is today but as far as I am aware you can not just go and fork it or even build it.

And note it was closed by blackberry after they purchased qnx.

Re: Blackberry had its first good idea in years

#18

The hyperbole of this line demeans the whole article, 'one of this century’s biggest corporate disasters ' 14 years into the 21st Century? Come on.

Off the top of my head Enron in 2001, WorldCom in 2002, Lehman Brothers and AIG in 2008, and GM and Chrysler in 2009 all seem to be better fit than Blackberry for the 'century's biggest corporate disasters'.

Re: Blackberry had its first good idea in years

#19
post #8

Blackberry just doesn't have traction outside of the US, since most of the rest of the world deeply distrust the architecture of the Blackberry system (i.e. all data sent back to US-based servers). I think this is the one thing they must fix - the perception by the world that Blackberry is just a front for the CIA. Laugh all you want: I've heard this expressed in more than one location here in Europe, enough so that…

Blackberry is not a US company and is not based in the US. So it's just sheer ignorance on the part of your friends to assume that it is.

Re: Blackberry had its first good idea in years

#20
post #8

Blackberry just doesn't have traction outside of the US, since most of the rest of the world deeply distrust the architecture of the Blackberry system (i.e. all data sent back to US-based servers). I think this is the one thing they must fix - the perception by the world that Blackberry is just a front for the CIA. Laugh all you want: I've heard this expressed in more than one location here in Europe, enough so that…

I'll never understand why BB failed to play up the "hey, did you notice that we weren't in any of those leaked documents as a partner of the NSA - unlike all three of our major competitors" angle...

But it seems that they have a lot of marketing fails, that's only one of the more recent.

Post reply on HN