Live data from Hacker News

Macaw V1 Released

secure.macaw.co

71–80 of 86 posts

Re: Macaw V1 Released

#71
post #21

I hate to be the one ask, but where's the Linux support? I was ready to buy Macaw, but my web workflow is in Linux. Isn't it built on node-webkit? How hard could it be to port, really?

Considering it's a small team, and this is aimed mainly at designers, it's reasonable to expect they focus on a Windows/Mac build at first.

Re: Macaw V1 Released

#72
post #42
post #15

I am glad its not subscription based. "Price is a flat fee and not a subscription. Price includes all updates to version 1 of Macaw."

Yeah, but after reading their use and then privacy policy it sure looks like you have to be able to connect to their servers to start using it. I assume that if they go poof, so does your copies of application, short of cracking it. One would hope they have a provision for off-line use/starting it.

You have to sign in the first time, but after that, you should be able to use it offline.

Re: Macaw V1 Released

#73
post #21

I hate to be the one ask, but where's the Linux support? I was ready to buy Macaw, but my web workflow is in Linux. Isn't it built on node-webkit? How hard could it be to port, really?

Considering it's a small team, and this is aimed mainly at designers, it's reasonable to expect they focus on a Windows/Mac build at first.

Aimed at designers for sure. Just look at the gem of a payoff: "Stop writing code, start drawing it." Thats what we want to hear. Draw it and let the app take care of all the code with browser quirks. (Yes I know you're all dev's here, but this is how designers feel. Older designers still remember they had to write postscript). ;-)

Re: Macaw V1 Released

#74
post #34
post #15

I am glad its not subscription based. "Price is a flat fee and not a subscription. Price includes all updates to version 1 of Macaw."

I'm actually disappointed it isn't subscription based. $179 is a pretty big sum, and there's no way I can thoroughly test out the app in 2 weeks (I'm a programmer, not a designer). I would have happily bitten the bullet on a monthly fee.

> there's no way I can thoroughly test out the app in 2 weeks

With the purpose of trials being to let people test the app, surely a longer trial (e.g. 90 days) would give people more time to get hooked and realise they couldn't live without it?

With the ease of getting pirated software the argument that people would use these long trials time after time in VMs doesn't stand up I believe, and shouldn't stop them being used.

Personally I preferred the trials that allowed "30 launches" of the program - so if I only found 5 days over 6 months to evaluate the software I was able to - and still had another 25 trial-days left to test it.

Re: Macaw V1 Released

#75

The team deserves a congratulation to produce and ship a decent product on both platforms in a relatively fast pace given their limited resources (they're not Adobe or MS). However, I'm critical of the site and the HN post. It seems to me the post links to checkout page to increase conversion. Or at least that was the intent of it. However, this is not a small purchase and I think they lose even more by sending them…

Web design TUTS+ have a coupon code 'TUTS' for $30 off. http://webdesign.tutsplus.com/tutorials/getting-to-know-maca...

Re: Macaw V1 Released

#76
post #15

I am glad its not subscription based. "Price is a flat fee and not a subscription. Price includes all updates to version 1 of Macaw."

Yeah.. but burnt myself to that one where they release version '2', which is basically a 1.1

Re: Macaw V1 Released

#77
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, but after reading their use and then privacy policy it sure looks like you have to be able to connect to their servers to start using it. I assume that if they go poof, so does your copies of application, short of cracking it. One would hope they have a provision for off-line use/starting it.

You have to sign in the first time, but after that, you should be able to use it offline.

They can't enforce their "any machine, one login in per copy" policy unless you log in each time you start it. Although one wonders how they deal with logging out, especially if that machine is offline, or just plain dead, when you "logout". Would imply a timeout or periodic phone home.

Re: Macaw V1 Released

#78
post #53

It looks like an internet connection is required for the demo. When I try to open it without a connection, I'm told my trial has expired, even though I've never used the software. Is an internet connection required only for trial period verification or is this, always online, internet connection required, software?

> Each purchase of Macaw allows you one account. That account is used to log into the app. Users can login to the app on any machine. I haven't purchased it, but that sure seems like an internet connection is required unfortunately.

It's implied by their licencing policy and privacy policy, see this subthread I started: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7504932

Re: Macaw V1 Released

#79

how soon will this be pirated?

Its been pirated since at least v0.75 (I know bcd its my business to know)

I pre-ordered btw. I have no pretence to design/UX chops beyond appreciation - but for the times i want to throw a nice front end up to work towards, this is useful (esp. device preview)

Good job Macaw

Re: Macaw V1 Released

#80

The team deserves a congratulation to produce and ship a decent product on both platforms in a relatively fast pace given their limited resources (they're not Adobe or MS). However, I'm critical of the site and the HN post. It seems to me the post links to checkout page to increase conversion. Or at least that was the intent of it. However, this is not a small purchase and I think they lose even more by sending them…

OP here. I am not in any way affiliated with the Macaw team, I'm just a fan that was closely watching. The reason I linked to the checkout page was that Hacker News would not allow me to submit a link to their home page because of a past submission. I urge everybody who does not see a lot of information about Macaw here to check out http://macaw.co/ . Sorry about any confusion and to the Macaw team if this was not th…

Their navigation is not very good... I couldn't go back to macaw.co from their signup page, and I didn't know what it is.

However, once I read about it, it sounded pretty nice. My first thought is that it tries to encourage the same workflow as Microsoft's Blend?

Post reply on HN