Live data from Hacker News

Tesla and SpaceX: Elon Musk's industrial empire [video]

cbsnews.com

41–50 of 149 posts

Re: Tesla and SpaceX: Elon Musk's industrial empire [video]

#41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Makes me think how much we need a revolution in batteries. I am wondering if there will be a new type of batteries soon or maybe we'll get improved capacity by slapping a software layer that manages charging/discharging.

We've needed one for ages! Lithium ion is the best we can do so far, and it has two GAPING flaws: * tons of energy is lost as heat * volatility of the chemical storage mechanism occasionally causes that heat to get released as an explosion I'd love to see Musk's solution end up in a massive increase in battery performance.

I've looked around and it seems there are lithium-sulfur based batteries with 10x capacity and all in all lasting 4x

Source: http://www.extremetech.com/extreme/157525-new-sulfur-based-b...

Re: Tesla and SpaceX: Elon Musk's industrial empire [video]

#42
In the immortal words of Keanu Charles Reeves, "Whoa". So much admiration for this guy. For once, it's actually nice to see one of my heroes getting mainstream media coverage like this. The guy has broken through to the mainstream by being himself and staying true to his engineering roots. You look at a guy like Jobs and it was always such a hokey, patronizing, and calculated exercise with his Houdini-esque product launches. Elon's humility and grit should be an inspiration to all.

Re: Tesla and SpaceX: Elon Musk's industrial empire [video]

#43

Musk is thinking 8 steps ahead of almost everyone. While Tesla is a huge play with revolutionizing the car world, there are some other parts in play. First, his Gigafactory to produce batteries. When the other big automakers get into the electric car mindset, who are they going to buy batteries from? Musk who owns the single largest and high-tech battery factory (that produces on an enormous scale), or other battery…

It is not uncommon for manufacturers of 'systems' to hedge their bets by becoming suppliers of components to competitors. Examples abound in the cell phone industry: Samsung makes Apple's A series chips and possibly, other components.

It is not a certainty that Tesla's battery manufacturing facilities can lower the price of batteries to achieve the < $30k per-car price point. I'd imagine a single factory that also sells to other car makers will solve the existing problem with scale. Currently, making/procuring 10k batteries a year is probably a big factor in making them so costly. It is almost universally true that manufacturing in larger numbers will bring down the price (probably not in a linear way, rather logarithmically).

Re: Tesla and SpaceX: Elon Musk's industrial empire [video]

#44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There are two sides to that coin. Without an opportunity and potential like SpaceX, all the public money would have are cases like Solyndra. The reality was, NASA needed SpaceX as much as SpaceX needed NASA.

NASA needed Musk. Musk doesn't need anybody.

Did you watch the news clip? And the Department of Energy (not mentioned) was huge in getting Tesla to where it is today.

Re: Tesla and SpaceX: Elon Musk's industrial empire [video]

#45

Since the car is so quiet... I wonder if the noise the car makes on these clips is an overdub.

Jalopnik thinks they were dubbed: http://oppositelock.jalopnik.com/why-is-60-minutes-dubbing-m...

But I also remember reading somewhere that the ADA was pushing for electric cars to emit noise for deaf and hard hearing pedestrians.

Re: Tesla and SpaceX: Elon Musk's industrial empire [video]

#46
I think the most interesting thing about Tesla is it's applicability to SpaceX. If the goal of Tesla is to provide a better energy source (where "better" is defined as capacity and environmentally friendly) and SpaceX's primary constraint is the energy source, then long-term they'll be the same company.

Re: Tesla and SpaceX: Elon Musk's industrial empire [video]

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree with a lot of what you said. However, this: "Competitors will not have the ability to compete on charging when they release cars because Tesla will already have an established network." is dramatically wrong. They will absolutely compete on charging, stubbornly so, and probably leveraging politics in the process. The major energy companies will also get into the charging business (much like the oil companies…

I'm still going to bet on the guy who has put something in space.

Yes. Because it's not like the other guys have decades of experience in the automobile industry.

Re: Tesla and SpaceX: Elon Musk's industrial empire [video]

#48
post #4

Anyone have a mobile link that works? edit: link

I know I'm not the typical reader, but there's literally no single article or video that will ever get me to install an app to read it. I wonder what their conversion rate on this is.

I hope it is close to zero. Proprietary bullshit is bullshit.

Re: Tesla and SpaceX: Elon Musk's industrial empire [video]

#49

Musk is thinking 8 steps ahead of almost everyone. While Tesla is a huge play with revolutionizing the car world, there are some other parts in play. First, his Gigafactory to produce batteries. When the other big automakers get into the electric car mindset, who are they going to buy batteries from? Musk who owns the single largest and high-tech battery factory (that produces on an enormous scale), or other battery…

What's amazing is that Tesla has been providing NRE R&D for OTHER automotive companies for years already. Last year, $15 million of their revenue was from development services but as early as 2011, $55 million of revenue (>25%) was from basically doing powertrain design for companies like Toyota and Mercedes. Link to last 10-K: http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1318605/0001193125140... Tesla will definitely make…

Tesla has always said their goal is to accelerate the adoption of electric vehicles. I suspect they will try to sell other car companies the drivetrains and rights to the super chargers.

Re: Tesla and SpaceX: Elon Musk's industrial empire [video]

#50

Musk is thinking 8 steps ahead of almost everyone. While Tesla is a huge play with revolutionizing the car world, there are some other parts in play. First, his Gigafactory to produce batteries. When the other big automakers get into the electric car mindset, who are they going to buy batteries from? Musk who owns the single largest and high-tech battery factory (that produces on an enormous scale), or other battery…

What's amazing is that Tesla has been providing NRE R&D for OTHER automotive companies for years already. Last year, $15 million of their revenue was from development services but as early as 2011, $55 million of revenue (>25%) was from basically doing powertrain design for companies like Toyota and Mercedes. Link to last 10-K: http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1318605/0001193125140... Tesla will definitely make…

The charging network also has a lot of risks associated with it. There are 192 other countries in this world all of whom will be looking to charging standards as opposed to relying on a single American company. This means that some time in the near future Tesla will have to go back and retrofit their cars/stations to meet this standard.

Apple's walled garden strategy works because the devices are cheap and relatively throw away. Cars are not.

Post reply on HN