Live data from Hacker News

Stripe: Bitcoin Sign-up

stripe.com

71–80 of 198 posts

Re: Stripe: Bitcoin Sign-up

#71

I wish all these resources spent & millions of investment dollars would go to a better version of Bitcoin. BT is a major breakthru but it is still in an alpha stage. The main problem is that it is deflationary, to support a global economy it needs to slightly inflationary. This is because for hundreds of millions of people to use BT, the supply of the coins need to gradually increase to support the flow of spending.…

> The main problem is that it is deflationary

Actually it's current inflationary and will be for a while. It's deflationary eventual nature is a long term issue with plenty of time to be addressed; short term, it's inflationary.

Re: Stripe: Bitcoin Sign-up

#72
post #11
post #10

I wish they would add ACH

We have it in beta. Email amber@stripe.com!

What does the ACH process look like? As far as I understand I can simply give a customer by banks ACH/routing info and have them pay directly.

If there's some value add here I'd jump on it. Offering ACH has been a significant credibility boost with my (enterprisey) customers.

Also, wow you guys have grown. I remember when your team page had two rows.

Re: Stripe: Bitcoin Sign-up

#73

The interesting part of this from my point of view is how Stripe will manage the conversion of received bitcoin back into dollars. Will they directly sell bitcoin to consumers themselves or trade on one (or more) of the exchanges. Stripe are obviously taking the risk of the volatility so will probably want to keep the bitcoin float that they hold fairly small. They also need to keep a reasonable margin on these trans…

Payment is next day with Bitpay...

Re: Stripe: Bitcoin Sign-up

#74
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Online, it's 23 digits that you don't know, and then 3-23 more fields (shipping address, billing address, name, email, etc. etc.) That sucks. Shipping address, name, and email are necessary even if you use bitcoin. Billing address is usually the same as shipping address. That leaves the CC number, in which case the equivalent is your bitcoin address. So there's no real win here. And if you're using a regular online…

> Shipping address, name, and email are necessary even if you use bitcoin Not for digital goods (maybe email) > That leaves the CC number, in which case the equivalent is your bitcoin address Most bitcoin payments are done either through mobile phone scanning a QR-code, or through uri's opening bitcoin software. I've never manually typed in a bitcoin address (worst case is copy pasting the payee address) > I haven't…

> Not for digital goods (maybe email)

Yep, for one-time purchases of digital goods, Bitcoin is superior. For repeat purchases, like my Amazon Kindle purchases, you have to beat one-click.

> Most bitcoin payments are done either through mobile phone scanning a QR-code, or through uri's opening bitcoin software. I've never manually typed in a bitcoin address (worst case is copy pasting the payee address)

Ah yes, I forgot about this part. Although you can store your CC# in your auto-fill or password management software. And most stores will save it for you. The argument here is that is insecure, because you're storing your CC# and it can be stolen. But likewise, you're storing your Bitcoin private addresses on whatever device and they can be stolen as well. Except without any chance of recovery.

> Not sure what you've been reading, but my bitcoin purchasing experiences have all been extremely straightforward. Scan QR-code, press send, done.

Well I'm comparing getting an invoice, scanning a code, sending, waiting for confirmations with literally clicking a button to buy and then another button to tell Amazon where to ship my stuff. Or in some cases, just one button to buy and ship.

Then I accounted for the stories in which the invoice expired before enough confirmations, and apparently the order just evaporated despite the bitcoins being sent. And there's plenty of Coinbase horror stories from people trying to get refunds.

Broadening the use cases.. There's stuff like paying bills where I literally have to do nothing. Netflix, my electric company, Comcast, etc all just pull the funds necessary every month. I literally have to do nothing.

> Uh...no you aren't. There's no chargebacks, not no refunds. That is, to get a refund the merchant has to agree.

That was in reference to Overstock and Tiger Direct specifically. If I remember correctly, neither allow actual refunds of stuff bought with Bitcoin. They just give you store credit.

> Basically, risk moves from merchant to customer (banks usually require the merchant to prove they delivered the goods in chargeback cases)

That's a problem I have with it. Merchants are better equipped to manage risk than consumers, so pushing it back onto consumers is a bad thing.

> bitpay already offer 0% fees for a flat $30/month, and things can only get cheaper (as there get more/better exchanges and less volatility)

Didn't know that. I was going off of Coinbase's rates. Thanks for the correction.

Re: Stripe: Bitcoin Sign-up

#75
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Online, it's 23 digits that you don't know, and then 3-23 more fields (shipping address, billing address, name, email, etc. etc.) That sucks. Shipping address, name, and email are necessary even if you use bitcoin. Billing address is usually the same as shipping address. That leaves the CC number, in which case the equivalent is your bitcoin address. So there's no real win here. And if you're using a regular online…

> Shipping address, name, and email are necessary even if you use bitcoin Not for digital goods (maybe email) > That leaves the CC number, in which case the equivalent is your bitcoin address Most bitcoin payments are done either through mobile phone scanning a QR-code, or through uri's opening bitcoin software. I've never manually typed in a bitcoin address (worst case is copy pasting the payee address) > I haven't…

> bitpay already offer 0% fees for a flat $30/month

What about the spread? The transaction fees charged by stock brokers approaches zero because they make the real bank on the spread.

Re: Stripe: Bitcoin Sign-up

#76
Awesome. Now to see how their integration works with regards to confirmation time. The best solution IMO is to use a risk analyzer to determine the number of needed confirmations. 0 conf for small payments for a merchant with a low fraud rate, with increasing confirmations needed as the size of the payment grows. I would look at BitPay's checkout flow to see the state of the art here.

Also hoping they implement the payment protocol (BIP70), which gives a much better user experience and improved security. Instead of copy pasting an address, a signed payment request is sent to the users Bitcoin wallet with a message stating something like "Bob's shop has requested a payment of 10USD (20mBTC) - accept?". Some particularly insidious coin stealing malware has been developed that modifies the payment address in the clipboard to be changed to an attackers address, and the whole UX around copying long Base58 encoded strings is horrible. Furthermore, the signed payment request serves as a receipt. With BIP70, the UX of bitcoin payments surpasses that of CC payments, IMO.

Re: Stripe: Bitcoin Sign-up

#78
post #37
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you had the option to tap a Bitcoin card and have the same experience, but save 3% on the transaction, would you?

Probably not. I'd prefer the mileage, peace of mind that I have recourse, consolidated statementing, free 30 day loan, etc. And you would not save 3%. In fact, with Bitcoin's volatility, you might be charged 3% as you are now when you purchase in a different currency. Bitcoin enthusiasts have a difficult time understanding the cost of currency volatility.

And yet, it's pretty common to pay with cash at any brick and mortar store, where you have no electronic protection (like chargebacks) and not even any physical protection for the cash you carry around.

Re: Stripe: Bitcoin Sign-up

#79
Why are they doing this? It's too late. No one is going to want to make Bitcoin transactions through a US-based company now because you know the Fed is going to start creating all sorts of lawsuits unless people follow the rules. I have zero Bitcoins but if I had any I'd play it safe and put it somewhere overseas (or if I did put it in a US-based company I'd want to make damn sure they were backed by an overseas bank).

Re: Stripe: Bitcoin Sign-up

#80
post #4

The concept that Stripe may be moving away from strictly supporting Credit Card payments (which are awful, but necessary for now) and into alternatives is so exciting to me that I am literally shaking. We're building infrastructure to make bank-to-bank transfers palatable to consumers and drive their cost toward zero, but it's only if thought leaders like the Collisons embrace the move away from CC's that the move wi…

I thought most of Europe does bank accounts differently, in a way that allows people to safely transfer money directly?
Post reply on HN