Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

HipHop, a new Windows/Mac app that offers free music streaming

gethiphop.net

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

1–10 of 11 posts

Re: HipHop, a new Windows/Mac app that offers free music streaming

#5

Post by computer »

hiphopapp wrote: post #3
computer wrote: post #2

Just an executable? No source code? No information on who you are? I think you'll have a hard time getting people to trust you.

Good point. Wondering how to do this without open-sourcing though.

Any reason to not open-source it? I doubt you can build a startup out of something that's probably against the Youtube ToS, so not much to lose.

Re: HipHop, a new Windows/Mac app that offers free music streaming

#6

Post by hiphopapp »

computer wrote: post #5
hiphopapp wrote: post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Good point. Wondering how to do this without open-sourcing though.

Any reason to not open-source it? I doubt you can build a startup out of something that's probably against the Youtube ToS, so not much to lose.

Wanted to see how this goes first, but you are right about trust when talking about a desktop app. If this blocks everybody, I will open-source it.

Re: HipHop, a new Windows/Mac app that offers free music streaming

#7

Post by DigitalSea »

Single executable file without no source code and no real explanation what is going on behind the scenes? Seems a little sketchy to me. You don't open up .exe files you get sent in emails (if you're smart) so why would this situation be any different?

You're going to find yourself swimming upstream on this one until you release the source code on Github or something, you could have anything lurking in that executable. The product you've created looks great though, I really want to install this and try it out, maybe in a sandboxed environment though.

Do what the developers behind the Popcorn Time movie torrent streaming app did, open source it and let others make it better whilst publicly showing that it is safe.

Re: HipHop, a new Windows/Mac app that offers free music streaming

#9

Post by digisocialnet »

DigitalSea wrote: post #7

Single executable file without no source code and no real explanation what is going on behind the scenes? Seems a little sketchy to me. You don't open up .exe files you get sent in emails (if you're smart) so why would this situation be any different? You're going to find yourself swimming upstream on this one until you release the source code on Github or something, you could have anything lurking in that executable…

it's a node app and it connects to a bunch of IPs.. not sure what they are though..

node-webk 3868 198.87.51.56:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 74.125.215.179:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 lax02s20-in-f2.1e100.net:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 198.87.51.67:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 a23-214-2-217.deploy.static.akamaitechnologies.com:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 198.87.51.82:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 198.87.51.72:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 198.87.51.80:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 198.87.51.56:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 198.87.51.67:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 198.87.51.67:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 198.87.51.72:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 198.87.51.82:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 198.87.51.82:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 198.87.51.82:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 198.87.51.72:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 198.87.51.72:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 198.87.51.72:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 198.87.51.80:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 198.87.51.80:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 198.87.51.80:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 198.87.51.80:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 198.87.51.80:http (ESTABLISHED) node-webk 3868 198.87.51.67:http (ESTABLISHED)

Post reply on HN