Live data from Hacker News

New RFS – Breakthrough Technologies

blog.samaltman.com

71–80 of 219 posts

Re: New RFS – Breakthrough Technologies

#71

I hope someone is crazy enough for the Tall Tower project. It is the kind of project the Human Race needs to convince ourselves that we are still capable of getting Big Things done. If you don't know about it already, it is a project jump-started in part by Neal Stephenson, to build a 15km tall tower. http://hieroglyph.asu.edu/project/the-tall-tower/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TE0n_5qPmRM

Curious: How do you suggest funding to arrive? What is the net benefit to the stake holders?

Re: New RFS – Breakthrough Technologies

#73

Some ideas around transportation: - smart pothole patches. Currently patches barely make the road any more driveable and uneven road surfaces result in billions in economic loss due to accidents, repairs, and traffic. - drone machine equipment. Employ operators in the midwest in trailers while they control equipment all over the world. You'll get few accidents and utilize resources more efficiently. Put the operators…

re: potholes

You already have millions of internet connected (gps localized) accelerometers on the roads daily. If you could convince enough drivers to record/report that information you'd have a decent map of any rough spots.

Re: New RFS – Breakthrough Technologies

#74
I can't help feeling that there's just too much in this RFS and that much of it lies beyond the expertise of YC. The lack of focus means that the only message I can take away is that YC wants fewer frivolous startups. SpaceX and Tesla are fine for inspiration but they have absolutely exceptional funding - no YC company is going to have access to those opportunities. I'm all for ambition but I don't see how this RFS is realistic.

Re: New RFS – Breakthrough Technologies

#75
post #26

"Of particular interest to us are ways to use the Internet to fix government—for example, crowdfunding social services." Aren't all social services crowdfunded?

At least in the tech community, "crowdfunded" usually means "crowdfunded using voluntary contributions".

Re: New RFS – Breakthrough Technologies

#76
post #35

This sounds terrific, but it doesn't seem self-consistent between wanting companies with the scale of ambition of SpaceX and Tesla, but insisting on early momentum being critical and avoiding a big and expensive initial project. Tesla took four years to introduce their first product, the Roadster. When they went public two years later, they had gone through a net loss of around 300 million dollars, and were still two…

I'd like to think my last startup was a breakthrough technology startup. We were building software, not sending things into space, so weren't nearly so capital intensive, but went through several iterations (discovering breakthroughs is research, and research takes time!), had some near-death experiences, and didn't have a compelling product for 5 or so years. However, fundamental advances are incredibly valuable, and things changed quickly once we got there. I think this is a great model for startups, esp. if you have propensity for technology development. However, it can be hard to fund. I agree, the OP seems unrealistic.

Re: New RFS – Breakthrough Technologies

#77

SpaceX and Tesla were really possible because of the large amounts of money that Elon put into the companies, it is estimated that Elon invested $100MM into SpaceX. his extremely impressive resume was not enough to receive the level of funding to get the company off the ground (get it?) how can a first time entrepreneur actually receive substantial investment without putting in such a large personal investment?

You don't need to be a first time founder to apply to YC. You also can still benefit massively from the connections YC can afford you even if you're an experienced startup founder already.

Re: New RFS – Breakthrough Technologies

#79

Some ideas around transportation: - smart pothole patches. Currently patches barely make the road any more driveable and uneven road surfaces result in billions in economic loss due to accidents, repairs, and traffic. - drone machine equipment. Employ operators in the midwest in trailers while they control equipment all over the world. You'll get few accidents and utilize resources more efficiently. Put the operators…

On potholes, there is more recent technology called "infrared repair" that heats up existing asphalt instead of a cut and replace method. You have to get the government to adopt it.

https://encrypted.google.com/search?hl=en&q=infrared%20repai...

Post reply on HN