Live data from Hacker News

When Carl Icahn Ran a Company: The Story of TWA

blog.pmarca.com

31–40 of 127 posts

Re: When Carl Icahn Ran a Company: The Story of TWA

#31

For those that don't know what is going on, here is the backstory: Carl Icahn has recently bought a bunch of ebay stock. He has claimed the company is mismanaged. He has also personally attacked Marc Andreesen. Here is the accusation from Ichan: 1) Marc Andreesen was/is on ebay's board. 2) While on ebay's board, Marc bought most of Skype from eBay. 3) He flipped Skype to Microsoft in less than 2 years, earning himsel…

Reminds me of when Icahn went head to head with Bill Ackman on CNBC.

Link:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hCZRk1lL90Q

Well worth the listen.

Re: When Carl Icahn Ran a Company: The Story of TWA

#32
It's kind of absurd how closely Carl Icahn's mirrors that of the story of Gordon Gekko in Oliver Stone's movie Wall Street. What Icahn did to TWA is pretty much exactly what Gekko did (or planned to do) to Bluestar Airlines in that film. Longer period of time - but in principle, very similar.

Re: When Carl Icahn Ran a Company: The Story of TWA

#34
post #29
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Financiers like Icahn are motivated by short term profits above all else. That's one way to look at it. Another is to note that Icahn built a thriving financial company that has survived for over 4 decades, and employs over 60,000 people globally. I'd say that requires long term thinking and demonstrates a bit of business acumen.

that's the only way to look at it; Icahn is a thieving sack of shit. Look at TWA: Icahn got fucking paid no matter whether TWA succeeded or failed. I can maybe see how these leeches ought to get 1/2 billion dollar payouts if they come in and rescue a company, but 0.5B when they ruin a company? Heads I win, tails you lose.

>that's the only way to look at it; Icahn is a thieving sack of shit.

Curious what your opinion is of Mr. Andreessen, and the conflict-of-interest accusations? is he included in your "leeches" remark, or does he get the SV pass?

The story is plausible. If I were an eBay shareholder, I'd be incensed.

Re: When Carl Icahn Ran a Company: The Story of TWA

#35
post #29
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Financiers like Icahn are motivated by short term profits above all else. That's one way to look at it. Another is to note that Icahn built a thriving financial company that has survived for over 4 decades, and employs over 60,000 people globally. I'd say that requires long term thinking and demonstrates a bit of business acumen.

that's the only way to look at it; Icahn is a thieving sack of shit. Look at TWA: Icahn got fucking paid no matter whether TWA succeeded or failed. I can maybe see how these leeches ought to get 1/2 billion dollar payouts if they come in and rescue a company, but 0.5B when they ruin a company? Heads I win, tails you lose.

[deleted]

Re: When Carl Icahn Ran a Company: The Story of TWA

#36

In my view, after his humiliation by Apple's board, Carl Icahn feels his power (and by proxy the power of wall street) slowly and surely being stripped away by tech. This is at the root of his obsession with pmarca, who famously claimed that "software is eating the world." The world that's being eaten is the world of Icahn and wall street financiers like him. The tech industry has its own source of finance (namely an…

At a minimum Icahn is playing far outside of his scale. Trying to force Apple's hand - he might as well be trying to dictate terms to Exxon or Walmart, it's comical.

Icahn can bring a modest fraction of his $22 billion to bear on any given situation. That might work against financially weak companies, or companies he dwarfs (like if he picked a fight with Groupon's leadership).

Financial power players like Icahn will never go away so long as there is wealth and capital. Mostly I think he's guilty, in the Apple and eBay situations, of thinking he is much more powerful than he is (and that's saying something given his history), as he has lately been starting fights with very healthy companies far larger than he is.

Re: When Carl Icahn Ran a Company: The Story of TWA

#37
post #29
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Financiers like Icahn are motivated by short term profits above all else. That's one way to look at it. Another is to note that Icahn built a thriving financial company that has survived for over 4 decades, and employs over 60,000 people globally. I'd say that requires long term thinking and demonstrates a bit of business acumen.

that's the only way to look at it; Icahn is a thieving sack of shit. Look at TWA: Icahn got fucking paid no matter whether TWA succeeded or failed. I can maybe see how these leeches ought to get 1/2 billion dollar payouts if they come in and rescue a company, but 0.5B when they ruin a company? Heads I win, tails you lose.

What puts you in a position to be an objective judge of the dealings of billionaires?

Re: When Carl Icahn Ran a Company: The Story of TWA

#38
I submitted this under the permalink URL earlier in the day: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7421591

Can any mods delete my submission and update this URL to that URL? It seems illadvised to have this item pointed at pmarca's blog homepage vs. the item we're discussing.

Re: When Carl Icahn Ran a Company: The Story of TWA

#39

Andreeson's defense seems to be that Icahn has had as many conflicts of interest and selfish motives on boards as he has, if not more. I'm not sure that's a good defense: "He's killed twice as many people as I have, and he's been at it longer, too!" When people so alike bicker like this in movies, they're usually about a minute away from kissing.

Marc has already pointed out that he removed himself from the decision making process regarding the divestiture of Skype and fully disclosed his conflict. ebay held 30% to his 3% during all of this so Icahn's claims seem pretty baseless and should be easily confirmed or denied by another member of the ebay board with knowledge of the proceedings.

Re: When Carl Icahn Ran a Company: The Story of TWA

#40
post #11
post #7

Can someone explain to me the significance of the animosity between Carl Icahn and pmarca? There are half a dozen posts on pmarca's blog discussing how Icahn is making claims against Andreessen. I understand these claims, but I don't understand their significance. I deeply respect pmarca but I can imagine that he, like any high visibility person, has many detractors. What power does Carl Icahn have that warrants such…

Icahn called out his conflict of interest in Ebay: http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB1000142405270230407100...

Andreessen responded:

http://blog.pmarca.com/2014/03/03/my-statement-on-ebay-direc...

Post reply on HN