Live data from Hacker News

When Carl Icahn Ran a Company: The Story of TWA

blog.pmarca.com

11–20 of 127 posts

Re: When Carl Icahn Ran a Company: The Story of TWA

#11
post #7

Can someone explain to me the significance of the animosity between Carl Icahn and pmarca? There are half a dozen posts on pmarca's blog discussing how Icahn is making claims against Andreessen. I understand these claims, but I don't understand their significance. I deeply respect pmarca but I can imagine that he, like any high visibility person, has many detractors. What power does Carl Icahn have that warrants such…

Icahn called out his conflict of interest in Ebay:

http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB1000142405270230407100...

Re: When Carl Icahn Ran a Company: The Story of TWA

#12
post #7

Can someone explain to me the significance of the animosity between Carl Icahn and pmarca? There are half a dozen posts on pmarca's blog discussing how Icahn is making claims against Andreessen. I understand these claims, but I don't understand their significance. I deeply respect pmarca but I can imagine that he, like any high visibility person, has many detractors. What power does Carl Icahn have that warrants such…

Icahn has bought a stake in eBay. It appears to me like he is trying to force out some of the eBay board by publicly criticizing. If he succeeds in basically kneecapping the current board then he can have much more control of the company. Just skim his wikipedia page to get an idea of what the possible outcomes are: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_Icahn .

Re: When Carl Icahn Ran a Company: The Story of TWA

#13
I like to see them swinging back at Icahn.

He uses wildly over-dramatic statements ('ebay is the worst run company ever') to try to force boards to do things that are specifically in his short term interests. He has absolutely no concern for the long-term well being of a company. After he gets his stock pop, he liquidates and is gone. Icahn's entire strategy operates strictly on the basis of greenmailing the leadership of a company into discharging cash into his lap. He will say anything he has to in order to generate that outcome.

Re: When Carl Icahn Ran a Company: The Story of TWA

#14
I love Marc and understand he's upset about the accusations, but it's time to move on. Nobody who knows anything about Marc takes them seriously. I'm obviously not privy to what goes on in eBay's boardroom, but the notion of Marc being some svengali forcing them to cede him 100s of millions is blatantly ludicrous, not to mention insulting to the other board members. If I were Marc (and it's probably much easier to say this since I'm not) I'd just ignore.

Re: When Carl Icahn Ran a Company: The Story of TWA

#15
post #9
post #2

Financiers like Icahn are motivated by short term profits above all else. Building a company takes people with a long term vision. The two are often not compatible. Having a leech trying to bleed out every cent as soon as it's made is not generally a good thing unless your company throws off wads of unneeded cash like nobody's business.

> Financiers like Icahn are motivated by short term profits above all else. That's one way to look at it. Another is to note that Icahn built a thriving financial company that has survived for over 4 decades, and employs over 60,000 people globally. I'd say that requires long term thinking and demonstrates a bit of business acumen.

Can you explain how his financial company employs 60,000 people?

Or did you mean he has ownership stakes in industrial firms that employ 60,000 people? Because he most certainly has never created 60,000 jobs by starting a company.

Re: When Carl Icahn Ran a Company: The Story of TWA

#16

What is it with pmarca? As a subscriber of his blog, he's been lambasting Carl Icahn for awhile now. Don't get me wrong! I hate Carl Icahn, but pmarca's critique is hard to get and overobsessive.

It's because it has gotten personal between Icahn and Andreessen. Icahn has been specifically dragging Andreessen's character through the mud since it became obvious he wasn't going to get his way on eBay.

Re: When Carl Icahn Ran a Company: The Story of TWA

#17

For those that don't know what is going on, here is the backstory: Carl Icahn has recently bought a bunch of ebay stock. He has claimed the company is mismanaged. He has also personally attacked Marc Andreesen. Here is the accusation from Ichan: 1) Marc Andreesen was/is on ebay's board. 2) While on ebay's board, Marc bought most of Skype from eBay. 3) He flipped Skype to Microsoft in less than 2 years, earning himsel…

[deleted]

Re: When Carl Icahn Ran a Company: The Story of TWA

#18

For those that don't know what is going on, here is the backstory: Carl Icahn has recently bought a bunch of ebay stock. He has claimed the company is mismanaged. He has also personally attacked Marc Andreesen. Here is the accusation from Ichan: 1) Marc Andreesen was/is on ebay's board. 2) While on ebay's board, Marc bought most of Skype from eBay. 3) He flipped Skype to Microsoft in less than 2 years, earning himsel…

I think Marc Andreessen position is weak in this fight. I have absolutely no empathy for Carl Icahn, but on this issue, he's got a good point. It seems Marc Andreessen had a conflict of interest and instead of showing that wasn't the case, Andreessen decided to attack Icahn for stuff that aren't related to this issue, even if they were definitely questionable.

Re: When Carl Icahn Ran a Company: The Story of TWA

#19
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Financiers like Icahn are motivated by short term profits above all else. That's one way to look at it. Another is to note that Icahn built a thriving financial company that has survived for over 4 decades, and employs over 60,000 people globally. I'd say that requires long term thinking and demonstrates a bit of business acumen.

Can you explain how his financial company employs 60,000 people? Or did you mean he has ownership stakes in industrial firms that employ 60,000 people? Because he most certainly has never created 60,000 jobs by starting a company.

>Can you explain how his financial company employs 60,000 people?

Do you think that large, multi-billion dollar financial conglomerates run themselves?

>Or did you mean he has ownership stakes in industrial firms that employ 60,000 people?

Both. Through wholly-owned subsidiaries and the financial holding company. What does it matter?

My point is, painting him like he's some inexperienced financier is utterly disingenuous. I know it's en vogue to hate on "banksters", but his business experience (and, in my opinion, economic value-added) is of a magnitude greater than Mr. Andreesen's.

Re: When Carl Icahn Ran a Company: The Story of TWA

#20

For those that don't know what is going on, here is the backstory: Carl Icahn has recently bought a bunch of ebay stock. He has claimed the company is mismanaged. He has also personally attacked Marc Andreesen. Here is the accusation from Ichan: 1) Marc Andreesen was/is on ebay's board. 2) While on ebay's board, Marc bought most of Skype from eBay. 3) He flipped Skype to Microsoft in less than 2 years, earning himsel…

Reminds me of when Icahn went head to head with Bill Ackman on CNBC.
Post reply on HN