Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Apple and Google use cash to buy...treasuries?

money.cnn.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–20 of 26 posts

Re: Apple and Google use cash to buy...treasuries?

#11

Post by magicalist »

TrainedMonkey wrote: post #6

Given that: 1. Some publicly traded companies have been sued for not maximizing shareholder value. 2. Not utilizing all of tax exempt vehicles provided to them could be counted as not maximizing shareholder value, unless of course there is a better investment they can make with their cash pile. 3. Given inflation of 1.5%, $100 billions in cash that Apple has would be losing $1.5 billions per year in terms of buying p…

There is no requirement that companies maximize shareholder value. At best you might be able to hold them to something in their charter, but generally lawsuits attempting this are thrown out pretty quickly, and even if it's not, except in cases of blatant mismanagement, it's difficult to prove that someone else there would done better with different decisions.

I know this meme is persistent, but it's really not true. If it were, you'd end up with ridiculous situations, like every company with a down quarter would be sued in an effort to get a windfall out of a loss.

Re: Apple and Google use cash to buy...treasuries?

#13

Post by wmf »

julespitt wrote: post #7
itg wrote: post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Reading the news as of late, there seems to be a new narrative against the tech companies, as if they are the new Wall St. See the bus protests, gentrification protests, aren't involved in their communities, complaining they don't pay enough taxes (while some other companies, such as oil, are receiving tax subsidies), etc. If someone can spin negative news against them, they will.

The article goes on to criticize American tech companies for not moving overseas funds here; this after they are being criticized for buying Government debt with the money they already have here. I am at a loss.

The article hypothesizes that they are buying treasuries with their foreign cash.

Re: Apple and Google use cash to buy...treasuries?

#16

Post by seanmcdirmid »

selectodude wrote: post #5
robgering wrote: post #2

Treasuries are often used as a "risk-free" asset to adjust a portfolio in order to meet a predetermined level of risk. Someone who works in finance can probably tell us more.

There the "risk free" aspect, but there also just really isn't much else in the world that you can buy 100 billion dollars of in just a few years. Even the entirety of taxable property in Manhattan can be had for just over twice that amount of money. Not to mention good luck trying not to move the market while buying 100 bn of anything.

Exactly. Treasuries are just so useful for stashing money. Even if the rate of return is below inflation, the Chinese really have no choice when dealing with their dollar reserves. Treasuries also make the dollar attractive in the first place, since the USA is more than happy to act as a debtor of last result resort....remember money can only be saved if it's borrowed!

Re: Apple and Google use cash to buy...treasuries?

#17

Post by steven2012 »

This article is inane. The authors have no understanding of what it means to have large amounts of money.

Where else should companies store their billions of dollars in cash? You can't just store money in a bank, because that bank could go belly up, meaning there is a certain amount of risk. Having money in US treasuries is essentially the lowest risk you can get, and they are extremely liquid.

Re: Apple and Google use cash to buy...treasuries?

#18

Post by steven2012 »

TrainedMonkey wrote: post #6

Given that: 1. Some publicly traded companies have been sued for not maximizing shareholder value. 2. Not utilizing all of tax exempt vehicles provided to them could be counted as not maximizing shareholder value, unless of course there is a better investment they can make with their cash pile. 3. Given inflation of 1.5%, $100 billions in cash that Apple has would be losing $1.5 billions per year in terms of buying p…

There is zero legal basis to sue a company for not maximizing shareholder value. A company does not have the legal obligation to maximize shareholder value.

Of course, anyone can sue for any reason, and I'm sure companies may have been sued over something as dumb as this, but they won't win, unless there is fraud/negligence involved. Not deciding to put money into alternative investments is not an issue of maximizing shareholder value.

Re: Apple and Google use cash to buy...treasuries?

#19

Post by drawkbox »

Repatriating money should be tax free or very minimally taxed. Granted it is nice to have investment in treasuries but most of this is a game to keep money untaxed overseas. So just let them bring it back and use it here, that money will go on to pay many more taxes, just not directly from that exchange.

Re: Apple and Google use cash to buy...treasuries?

#20

Post by joncooper »

AnimalMuppet wrote: post #15

Why Treasuries? Well, they're really liquid. You can sell them in a hurry if, for example, there's some juicy company you decide you want to buy for $19 billion. (As selectodude pointed out, they probably won't move the market much by doing so.)

This is an extraordinarily important point and one that nearly everyone misses. Treasuries are some of the most liquid instruments that exist, especially at shorter durations.
Post reply on HN