Live data from Hacker News

Google’s suggestion for a better infinite scroll?

scrollsample.appspot.com

111–120 of 168 posts

Re: Google’s suggestion for a better infinite scroll?

#111
post #31

One of my favorite features of infinite scroll is how it can make clicking on the footer of a page nearly impossible. E.g. try clicking on "About" or "Careers" on the bottom of http://venturebeat.com

This is an implementation choice, and not the failure of infinite scrolling: you could embed the infinite scrolling inside a DIV and have a visible footer DIV underneath. Or alternatively, implement a sticky footer, or e.g. a fixed footer that appears on certain conditions.

Re: Google’s suggestion for a better infinite scroll?

#112
post #16

It still jumps around if you hold and drag the scrollbar - always my complaint with these.

I wonder how many people do hold and drag the scrollbar, I am so used to scrolling using a touchpad on Mac and mousewheel on PC, so I never even touch a scrollbar.

It is very inconvenient on a large page like this, should you need to quickly move up/down to read a related comment. If you know it, dragging the scrollbar, on the other hand, is quick to land you in the approximate target region.

Re: Google’s suggestion for a better infinite scroll?

#114
post #95
post #75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I also wonder about "memory problems", but of the soft kind. I like to consuming "pages" of content at a time, spread between many tabs. Usually I read to the bottom of a "page", and then switch tabs. When I come back to that tab, I'm ready to go to the next page. But with infinite scrolling, I feel like I'd be re-reading content to find my exact spot I left off..

Isn't that sort of what the OP is attempting to solve? It's paginated but still scrolls infinitely.

I guess not, although the page number is shown for you to see which page you are on, but you may forget where you were after you visit a particular link. It's improved to resolve the memory issue, I think. So when you browsed to page 10 and want to get back to page 3, it will reload for you seamlessly, rather than let the browser to keep all the pages in memory.

I agree the parent post, I'd like to keep where I was when I open each link in a new tab. Then the infinite scroll just helps to eliminate the click of the next page.

Re: Google’s suggestion for a better infinite scroll?

#115
post #59

I would feel kind of okay with infinite scroll if it wasn't creating memory problems. Especially on image-heavy (tumblr) / DOM-heavy (facebook) pages. If I browsed the web in 90s mode (one window, one page opened) that would maybe work, but when I have dozens of tabs opened, youtube playing in background and I start browsing an endless memory-hungry page, my laptop (3 GB RAM) starts dying. Another issue is the one me…

When you're loading more elements at the bottom - drop the equivalent count of elements from the top of the list. Problem solved.

The memory issue is solved, but the browser and CPU are so busy because when you want to get back to page 3 from page 10, page 3 has to be reloaded.

Re: Google’s suggestion for a better infinite scroll?

#117
post #102
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's an elegant way to add some sort of progress indicator to infinite scroll. I just haven't figured it out yet :)

Have a little screen overlay that displays how much memory your browser is using. As it climbs higher and higher, you'll know that you are making progress.

You're so funny. I guess they will make a fix number of items in the memory for the DOM.

Re: Google’s suggestion for a better infinite scroll?

#118
post #46
post #38

I'm surprised at how many people here seem to like infinite scroll. I personally can't stand it. Imagine having a book where no matter how much you read, it never seems to end. No milestones, no sense of progress. Just page after page after page. It just feels... icky.

There's an elegant way to add some sort of progress indicator to infinite scroll. I just haven't figured it out yet :)

They do have a page list on the bottom and show which page you are on.

Re: Google’s suggestion for a better infinite scroll?

#119

Why do so many designers/developers of pages with infinite scroll forget they put their footer menu in there and it is now inaccessible due to the scroll ?

I'm also concerned about the footer menu, may it be sticky or keep it on the bottom not shown. Looks like most of the sites have the latter. Maybe the footer is not that important, just to embed more links.

Re: Google’s suggestion for a better infinite scroll?

#120
post #92
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You could solve a lot of problems with position: absolute and javascript, which you assume is on. A bigger problem is that mobile safari doesn't let you execute js during scroll. One way around that is by hsing iScroll which fakes scrolling using CSS.

You can use the touchmove event to do things while mobile safari scrolls.

Really?

http://stackoverflow.com/questions/10482227/javascript-dom-c...

Post reply on HN