Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How to create an anonymous site?

news.ycombinator.com

51–53 of 53 posts

Re: Ask HN: How to create an anonymous site?

#51
post #22
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From the way the question was phrased, I think this is precisely for learning how to do such things. You still need to start somewhere, and as long as you know you should not take inconsiderate risks, you can screw up sometimes and learn from your errors.

Importantly, you don't get to learn from your mistakes in "opsec." Dread Pirate Roberts asked a question about connecting to a tor site using curl on StackOverflow under his own name. Seconds later he realized "D'oh, that is in hindsight a bad move." and changed his name to a pseudonym. Choose your own adventure: a) He got to learn from his mistake. b) That incident was recounted years later in the criminal indictmen…

It's not clear that was a mistake. The indictment merely lays out relevant evidence in chronological order, not in investigative order: we don't actually know how the FBI cracked DPR and found Ross Ulbricht. My own favored theory is that they only learned DPR==Ross Ulbricht in early 2013 when DPR paid for the first hit (of Curtis Green) by wiring 2 bank payments from an Australian bank account (Ulbricht lived in Australia with his sister for a year or two while running SR) to the undercover FBI agent. Yes, bank wires, not bitcoins. Since banks offer essentially zero security, it's very plausible his true name was on it and everything after that was just filling in the details as they investigated 'so who is this Ulbricht guy anyway?'

(These sort of leaks are always much easier to find in hindsight: no one ever noted the Shroomery or Bitcointalk or Stackoverflow leaks before the indictment was released, yet once you knew what you were looking for, you could find the posts in minutes.)

Re: Ask HN: How to create an anonymous site?

#52
It is not as much creating an anonymous website as it is about protecting the users (keeping their anonymity) and their content (from prying eyes). A service can be in plain sight, but if it employs the correct (often needed - extreme) practices, it can provide its users with this level of confidence. I happen to be a Co-Founder of such a service :-) www.anongrid.com is an extremely secure and anonymous content sharing service. still in its infancy but you're welcome to check it out and see what I mean.

Re: Ask HN: How to create an anonymous site?

#53
post #9

Maybe someone with experience of such hosting? Like: http://www.nearlyfreespeech.net I should add: Goes under US Law, so forget pirating or illegal content.

Nearlyfreespeech is explicitly not for anonymous hosting. They are just very unlikely to take anything down without a court order forcing them to do so.

They do accept anonymous money and do not keep logs of who you are, but yes, they will take down stuff based on court order - but so will all public hosting.
Post reply on HN