Live data from Hacker News

We made something. We use it. We love it. Apple rejected it

huemanapp.com

21–30 of 319 posts

Re: We made something. We use it. We love it. Apple rejected it

#22

With all their patent trolling and absurd tyrannical control over the app store, I have no idea why so many tech-saavy people still love Apple.

IMHO, They don't love Apple perse but some of their products. In my case atleast, i don't like Apple but i would like to have a macbook-pro or something of that sort.

Re: We made something. We use it. We love it. Apple rejected it

#24

With all their patent trolling and absurd tyrannical control over the app store, I have no idea why so many tech-saavy people still love Apple.

We love what Apple did for the industry, we love using their products, we have varying levels of problems with them as a company. Some are very high, some are low, but that's unrelated to what you're perceiving, which is a love of what they did for the industry and the products that we use.

Re: We made something. We use it. We love it. Apple rejected it

#26

I've been there, had an app I used daily in my job. I valued it for how fast it got me the information I needed (aviation weather) without features that I didn't need getting in the way. A few friends thought it looked useful so I put it on the store and got the same rejection. I added a couple of features that nobody uses (saving weather for later viewing) and got it through. I always suspected it was that I wanted…

This sounds similar but different to something I did. I needed a basic calculator for work, and colleagues did too. A dead simple app, but it was free and was accepted.

Re: We made something. We use it. We love it. Apple rejected it

#27
post #22

With all their patent trolling and absurd tyrannical control over the app store, I have no idea why so many tech-saavy people still love Apple.

IMHO, They don't love Apple perse but some of their products. In my case atleast, i don't like Apple but i would like to have a macbook-pro or something of that sort.

I would also like to have a retina MBP. Dat screen resolution and battery...

My current POS Dell XPS laptop lasts 2 hours max, has a 17 inch 1080p screen, and weights a ton. Worst of all, the Windows drivers that Dell provides don't even work properly and cause frequent BSODs, so I can't even play games.

I would love to have a retina MPB, but unfortunately, I can't afford it.

Re: We made something. We use it. We love it. Apple rejected it

#28
post #4

I wonder if it was partially rejected due to the use of 'webviews'.

Silly but this could be part of it. Apple directs people that just make an app that is a phonegap wrapper of a website to just make a website. I have seen apps be rejected for just being website wrappers or webview apps without other integration points. The fact that it doesn't tie in any services is also sometimes a factor. Integration of iCloud, GameCenter, etc always make for an easier review time.

Re: We made something. We use it. We love it. Apple rejected it

#29

With all their patent trolling and absurd tyrannical control over the app store, I have no idea why so many tech-saavy people still love Apple.

Because of technical merit? Everything you mentioned is politics. I can see how that's not the most important to most people.

Re: We made something. We use it. We love it. Apple rejected it

#30
post #13

Maybe not related, but is it possible that Apple does not want this app to exist because parts of it could be considered prior art for it's patent application?: http://www.pocket-lint.com/news/126980-apple-seeks-to-scan-y...

Pretty recently filed on Jan 23rd, not saying this has anything to do with the OP's rejection, but it could be planned future technology.
Post reply on HN