Live data from Hacker News

Today is The Day We Fight Back

thedaywefightback.org

251–260 of 267 posts

Re: Today is The Day We Fight Back

#251

Earlier quoted context omitted.

politicians ignore campaign promises You should back or elect different candidates. Don't simply choose the candidate others have chosen for you, get involved earlier in the process to make sure the person you're voting for has a greater chance of voting for the issues you care deeply for.

That worked really poorly with the last "Hope & Change" candidate. If you suggest voting for an independent... That is sort of a pipedream in the current US election climate. Noble thought and effort to push for such a candidate, but they have little to no chance of actually being electable. And even if they do get elected... Whats to stop them from being totally corrupted, or just overtly ignored by the rest of the…

There are 3rd party candidates...

Re: Today is The Day We Fight Back

#253

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're not following, but that's expected. It's not exactly difficult to see reasons for why governments should not exist. They're all around you, and there are countless of them. As a very simple example, why are laws like SOPA and CISPA passed in secret, unless there's a massive uprising against them? Obviously, they're passed in secret, or stealthily, or all of a sudden - they're just rammed through exactly becaus…

It's not difficult to see that government should not exist ... Do you have any idea how ridiculous you sound? No one should take you seriously; I don't see what espousing that ideology is going to get you.

> Do you have any idea how ridiculous you sound?

Did you even read what I wrote? But I get it. It's difficult to process this information.

> No one should take you seriously

Don't just take my word for it. Go investigate the collective works of the people I listed above. If you do that, you'll agree with me (unless you've been severely traumatized as a child).

> I don't see what espousing that ideology is going to get you.

Me? -Possibly nothing. But it's good if I can help ordinary people everywhere avoid whatever seriously unpleasant fate awaits us all if we don't wake up in time. People not being subjected to coercion is not much of an ideology by the way.

Re: Today is The Day We Fight Back

#254
post #214

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're not following, but that's expected. It's not exactly difficult to see reasons for why governments should not exist. They're all around you, and there are countless of them. As a very simple example, why are laws like SOPA and CISPA passed in secret, unless there's a massive uprising against them? Obviously, they're passed in secret, or stealthily, or all of a sudden - they're just rammed through exactly becaus…

Yeah, having roads and running water are just awful. Schools, sanitation, energy, parks, rights for minorities and laborers. I just HATE that stuff.

Ah, this again. Is there something special about all those services that makes them impossible to provide with money that has not been extorted from millions of people?

Re: Today is The Day We Fight Back

#255

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Great site and resource, thanks! When I shared the link with a friend he mentioned he was uncomfortable giving his number and email address. Maybe consider having a link close to those fields to help the visitor find the number or email address of their Representative. That way if someone doesn't want to give out that information there is a quick alternative available.

Yes, this is always what I look for when I see one of these sites. As well-intentioned as you may be, I have no way of verifying that you're not putting me on a bother/solicit list, so the thing that is most likely to get me to participate is if you take all the "we do it for you" machinery and have an option where I can walk through the flowchart myself. Provide me a way of doing the mapping from my home address to…

Exactly. It's asking to help get back privacy by giving private information. I understand why it's done, and it's quite useful to a lot of people. Still, having another option would be nice.

Re: Today is The Day We Fight Back

#256
post #214

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, having roads and running water are just awful. Schools, sanitation, energy, parks, rights for minorities and laborers. I just HATE that stuff.

Ah, this again. Is there something special about all those services that makes them impossible to provide with money that has not been extorted from millions of people?

Yes. It's called a coordination problem: http://raikoth.net/libertarian.html#coordination_problems

Re: Today is The Day We Fight Back

#257
post #185
post #143

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> When the NSA demands your data, you're not really entering a business partnership. True, but I saw the original comment as relating more to recruiting. The NSA works just as hard as any tech company to compete for skilled employees. If you're the kind of person they want to hire, you have lots of fantastic other choices. So choose something else. Unless you're planning to pull a Snowden (and have gonads of steel).…

>If you're the kind of person they want to hire, you have lots of fantastic other choices. So choose something else. I am the kind of person they'd want to hire and what has kept me from applying is the relative low pay and not being in my area. As an engineer, you'd get access to cool tech in an interesting domain. >And if you do decide to help code the surveillance state, the rest of us may take that into considera…

In this scenario, the qualifications of the person or what function they served at the NSA is pretty much irrelevant. (That said, as a hiring manager I wouldn't take what a former NSA employee told me about the functions they served at face value.) The poster is brainstorming ways in which average citizens could cripple an organization seen as out of control. While this particular method may hurt the individuals who work there, and leave the overall hiring a little less unqualified, it doesn't mean that the idea has no credence.

Re: Today is The Day We Fight Back

#258

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ah, this again. Is there something special about all those services that makes them impossible to provide with money that has not been extorted from millions of people?

Yes. It's called a coordination problem: http://raikoth.net/libertarian.html#coordination_problems

That FUD is not relevant to my question, and I don't have the time and energy to dissect his contrived, unrealistic fearmongering scenario now.

But for example, why would other people let Mike pollute the water despite everyone else having signed the "Filter Pact"? Mike's selfish actions would directly affect other people making a living, and therefore, some kind of intervention would be warranted - and would happen too! After that, everything is fine again.

Even if you're silly enough to argue against your own freedom, you can't just leave things at presenting a problem, expecting it would not get solved, and thinking you've proven that freedom "doesn't work".

Re: Today is The Day We Fight Back

#259

I really like the banner, although, in all honesty, I don't think this will have any effect on spying. I truly believe that the NSA cannot be stopped by words alone. People lie all the time. The only thing I think words can do in situations like this is drive it more underground, and make the NSA lie that everything is back to normal... Presidents lie. Politicians lie. Now, if every American refuses to work 1 day, an…

> Now, if every American refuses to work 1 day, and all head to the NSA's office, datacenter (and actually destroy the thing), that'd really mean taking matters into our own hands

You forget the part where the USA is a militarized police state that, unlike (say) the Ukrainian government/police will not hesitate to use lethal force at these people.

Not that it will happen, but if it were to happen, that's what's going to happen.

Remember the police violence excesses with the peaceful Occupy protest? They didn't get friendlier in the mean time. The police did, however, get equipped with more shiny military war toys.

Re: Today is The Day We Fight Back

#260
post #146

What disturbs me is not once was Obama's image shown in this video. More than anyone he is the person pressure should be put on to start change(no pun intended). Before we knew the extent of surveillance we saw images like this of Bush: http://www.funny-games.biz/pictures/648-vampire-bush.html I never had to go looking for the imagery above during Bush's tenure it was everywhere. Where is it now for the current admin…

Obama is the Smiler.
Post reply on HN