Live data from Hacker News

Mozilla to deliver ads in its Firefox browser

zdnet.com

21–30 of 60 posts

Re: Mozilla to deliver ads in its Firefox browser

#21

This seems like a massive amount of hypocrisy on the part of Mozilla. "We don't want you to ever have to see ads in your browser -- except our ads!" I had an angry knee-jerk reaction to this, and while in practice it probably won't be annoying, it's a step in the complete wrong direction.

What is the right direction for an organization like Mozilla that needs to keep its lights on and pay a sizeable host of highly skilled developers?

Re: Mozilla to deliver ads in its Firefox browser

#22
post #14

Firefox will NOT include ads - Stop the misinformation!! currently the default new tab page on a NEW installation is mostly empty: http://i.imgur.com/z71I89i.jpg What will happen is that it will be pre-filled with sites that are popular in your locale, organizations that Mozilla likes, and sponsored sites: http://cl.ly/image/3I172o2f202k The pre-filled sites disappear and are replaced by your own top sites as you sta…

To me, "sponsored sites" is just another word for "ads".

In that case Ff has included "ads" for years by taking money from Google to have Google as a default page.

Re: Mozilla to deliver ads in its Firefox browser

#24
post #14

Firefox will NOT include ads - Stop the misinformation!! currently the default new tab page on a NEW installation is mostly empty: http://i.imgur.com/z71I89i.jpg What will happen is that it will be pre-filled with sites that are popular in your locale, organizations that Mozilla likes, and sponsored sites: http://cl.ly/image/3I172o2f202k The pre-filled sites disappear and are replaced by your own top sites as you sta…

To me, "sponsored sites" is just another word for "ads".

It depends, if it is like the OP posted then no, it's not really an ad any more than this is - http://www.yahoo.com.

On the other hand, if you saw this - http://mediamemo.allthingsd.com/files/2009/09/yahoo-ad-campa... then ya, it's an ad.

/unfortunately no, I am not getting paid by yahoo.

Re: Mozilla to deliver ads in its Firefox browser

#25
post #14

Firefox will NOT include ads - Stop the misinformation!! currently the default new tab page on a NEW installation is mostly empty: http://i.imgur.com/z71I89i.jpg What will happen is that it will be pre-filled with sites that are popular in your locale, organizations that Mozilla likes, and sponsored sites: http://cl.ly/image/3I172o2f202k The pre-filled sites disappear and are replaced by your own top sites as you sta…

Huh. That looks absolutely fine, if this is it. I get that Mozilla can't solely rely on Google. That article was vicious.

Re: Mozilla to deliver ads in its Firefox browser

#26
post #3
post #2

These will only be visible for empty history thumbnails on new profiles for new users. There are example mockups here: https://twitter.com/clarkbw/status/433333066514198528

That thumbnails page is the first thing I disable in my Firefox, so I am mostly unconcerned. Then again, "first they came to add ads to thumbnail tiles, I didn't speak up because I don't use thumbnail tiles..."

I'm pretty sure that thumbnail ad tiles isn't going to lead to a Holocaust.

Re: Mozilla to deliver ads in its Firefox browser

#27
post #14

Firefox will NOT include ads - Stop the misinformation!! currently the default new tab page on a NEW installation is mostly empty: http://i.imgur.com/z71I89i.jpg What will happen is that it will be pre-filled with sites that are popular in your locale, organizations that Mozilla likes, and sponsored sites: http://cl.ly/image/3I172o2f202k The pre-filled sites disappear and are replaced by your own top sites as you sta…

To me, "sponsored sites" is just another word for "ads".

By that token, the pre-installed search sites are ads. There's big money associated with those things, yet I haven't heard anyone complaining about them.

I like the look of this new feature—I think it will be more useful to beginning users, it produces a nicer first-run user experience, and it gets out of the way very quickly.

I'm not sure if people think that Google Chrome has ads like this or not—to my view, the whole product is laced with ads for Google products, far more intrusive, obnoxious and anticompetitive than anything Firefox has been able to produce.

(You might guess that I'm a Mozilla fan. That perception would be accurate.)

Re: Mozilla to deliver ads in its Firefox browser

#28
post #5
post #2

These will only be visible for empty history thumbnails on new profiles for new users. There are example mockups here: https://twitter.com/clarkbw/status/433333066514198528

This reminds me very strongly of the Opera web browser...

Safari also has a similar pre-filled splash screen, last time I checked. I wonder if IE still defaults to showing msn.com?

Re: Mozilla to deliver ads in its Firefox browser

#29
post #14

Firefox will NOT include ads - Stop the misinformation!! currently the default new tab page on a NEW installation is mostly empty: http://i.imgur.com/z71I89i.jpg What will happen is that it will be pre-filled with sites that are popular in your locale, organizations that Mozilla likes, and sponsored sites: http://cl.ly/image/3I172o2f202k The pre-filled sites disappear and are replaced by your own top sites as you sta…

You don't understand, people HAVE to be OUTRAGED, ADS in Firefox, god's heaven no, until now it was working on happy thoughts and unicorn powder[1].

I'm probably one of the rare person to think it's a pretty well designed idea that will bring money to Mozilla without compromising their users' privacy or computers well being, so a welcoming change.

I'm going to my happy place again.

[1] Incidentally, the process to get some is probably gruesome.

Re: Mozilla to deliver ads in its Firefox browser

#30
This is a very sensible thing on part of Mozilla. Community needs an open source browser to exist and thrive for number of reasons and hence Mozilla needs to figure out different ways to make money.

Mozilla is one brand I really trust for various reason. I am willing to rely more on Mozilla than on say Google for all my online existence.

One good business model for Mozilla could be to provide a subscription version of browser which is tightly integrated with more services of Mozilla including Webmail, Calendar, Photo and File Storage. Mozilla could charge me a monthly sum + show me ads on these services. Currently I use Zoho for many such services.

Post reply on HN