Live data from Hacker News

Imgur is Covertly Redirecting Image Links on Facebook and Twitter

minimaxir.com

1–10 of 75 posts

Re: Imgur is Covertly Redirecting Image Links on Facebook and Twitter

#3
post #2

I honestly don't see an issue. if you're sharing links to images on imgur, you're denying them ad revenue and just leaching bandwidth. I'm all for adblockers, but complaining you can't direct link images is kinda...

One of the problems is the comments on imgur. If you thought youtube was bad. Now imagine posting a picture of a sunset or a cute dog or whatever, your mom or 8 year old nephew or whoever clicks it and it's full of "look at the fucking sun!" or similar.

Re: Imgur is Covertly Redirecting Image Links on Facebook and Twitter

#4
post #2

I honestly don't see an issue. if you're sharing links to images on imgur, you're denying them ad revenue and just leaching bandwidth. I'm all for adblockers, but complaining you can't direct link images is kinda...

Imgur was founded as a reddit-friendly image host. "The new site for reddit images, written by a redditor. None of the slow ad-laden crap of imageshack!"

Now, it is slow ad-laden crap, to the point that I just hit Back button after hitting a link and seeing the page frame load before the image.

It has been fascinating to watch the common startup pattern of "I am one of us, making our life awesome" messaging covering a standard 2-year bait-and-switch free product flip.

Imgur will be dumped as fast as all the image hosting sites it replaced on reddit.

Re: Imgur is Covertly Redirecting Image Links on Facebook and Twitter

#6
post #2

I honestly don't see an issue. if you're sharing links to images on imgur, you're denying them ad revenue and just leaching bandwidth. I'm all for adblockers, but complaining you can't direct link images is kinda...

imgur was basically founded on the principle that it will allow hotlinking.

Re: Imgur is Covertly Redirecting Image Links on Facebook and Twitter

#8
@judk's comment should be higher... it is the unfortunate cycle of ad-supported startups.

imgur grew out of the garden that is reddit; it was suppose to replace all those other crappy hosting services. It's been known for a while that directly navigating to a i.com/direct-link.jpg link costs imgur because they get no ad impressions from those loads.

While I think this is the eventual trend of every imgur page load, they are saving reddit for the last as that is the last community they can afford to piss off.

I feel for them though... it is really hard to stomach how expensive bandwidth and storage can get for a "free" media startup like this -- I am guessing they are slowly shifting scope and "growing" though as they hire more people, like every other startup in history... at some point they grow out of that sweet spot they supported (easy/fast image hosting) and into a realm no one really wanted or needed them (but makes them money).

Oh well. Every time a company does this, it leaves the door open for another company to come up behind them and re-solve that problem in another interesting way. It is the way of growth and change.

Re: Imgur is Covertly Redirecting Image Links on Facebook and Twitter

#9
post #7

This could easily be because the redirected domain allows them to provide og:image meta data specifically tailored for the sites.

I thought that at first too, but for some reason, the Open Graph and Twitter cards don't render on their respective services. (although the meta information is present, which makes it weird. I believe Facebook/Twitter can still get meta info through redirects.)
Post reply on HN