Live data from Hacker News

DevArt: your code belongs in an art gallery

googledevelopers.blogspot.com

21–23 of 23 posts

Re: DevArt: your code belongs in an art gallery

#21
post #15

"competition" "art" "must use google technologies" wtf is going on here? This sounds like a huge advertisement for google under the premise that "if we put your stuff in a gallery, you will be an artist." One that the public in another country will pay (the gallery) to see. > "Sometimes we just need some inspiration and an outlet." Folks, your outlet for your art is the entire world around you. It is your friends and…

Curmudgeonly naysaying.

It's one thing if Google was being dishonest about the opportunity on offer. That it sounds like a premise you particularly dread hardly makes it actually operate under said premise.

In the face of a profession that worships craft-as-opposed-to-art, Google sounds an encouraging note: that code can be/can produce art and that it wants to promote that idea, and show off those who avail themselves of that idea.

Are you under the impression that artists in this sphere are in it for the money?--and that Google is therefore somehow swindling aspiring participants? We could do worse than have an online art hack month. The modest constraint of using a single Google product in exchange for participating a well-supported competition seems reasonable for most. And that will hardly, "for God's sake", "limit [them] to showing [their] work in this one gallery." Like game jams, this is about kickstarting creativity.

You decry mercenary motives and then evaluate this opportunity purely in terms of profit. You can't have your urinal cake and eat it too.

Re: DevArt: your code belongs in an art gallery

#22
post #15

"competition" "art" "must use google technologies" wtf is going on here? This sounds like a huge advertisement for google under the premise that "if we put your stuff in a gallery, you will be an artist." One that the public in another country will pay (the gallery) to see. > "Sometimes we just need some inspiration and an outlet." Folks, your outlet for your art is the entire world around you. It is your friends and…

I think art is all about constraints. It is a challenge to say "I'm going to make this next piece using only this one shade of blue and sponge instead of a paint brush", and I think the same goes for "I'm going to make this next piece only using Google technology." In fact, my project Layer Synthesis Device was a direct result of me challenging myself to make a VJ app using only HTML5, and it must work on my phone (a bigger feat at the time since HTML5 was in its infancy.)

Was what I made art? Maybe not. But it was a great creative exercise: the less you have to work with, the more you do with what you have. Sure the cash prize and the free marketing Google is using you for is sketchy, but it's giving people a challenge, which is where great things come from.

Re: DevArt: your code belongs in an art gallery

#23
post #17
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"The only requirement is that you use at least one Google technology from any of the four groups below:" You can use Go or Chrome or Android.

Then show me how to deploy to the store such APK, done in Go for example.

It is not a constraint to deploy an Android app in Go. You can use Go, or create an android app for example.
Post reply on HN