Live data from Hacker News

Satya Nadella email to employees on first day as CEO

microsoft.com

11–20 of 55 posts

Re: Satya Nadella email to employees on first day as CEO

#11

"Who am I? I am 46. I’ve been married for 22 years and we have 3 kids." -> Who cares?

Are you American? I was wondering about this too. As a Frenchman, I had the same reaction as you, but I think Americans care a lot about this. I've been told for example that in the US it would be completely impossible for a president to be elected if he didn't had a solid marriage and family.

I find those cultural differences fascinating

Re: Satya Nadella email to employees on first day as CEO

#12
post #7

As an ex-MSFT employee and somebody who actually got a chance to talk to Satya I found the letter to be very true to his personality. Excited to see what he does in Redmond.

Is he a conservative type of manager who will try to come-up with completely new kind of products or someone who will keep chasing Google in Apple in what they do best?

Re: Satya Nadella email to employees on first day as CEO

#13

"Who am I? I am 46. I’ve been married for 22 years and we have 3 kids." -> Who cares?

Are you American? I was wondering about this too. As a Frenchman, I had the same reaction as you, but I think Americans care a lot about this. I've been told for example that in the US it would be completely impossible for a president to be elected if he didn't had a solid marriage and family. I find those cultural differences fascinating

"a president to be elected if he didn't had a solid marriage and family" + religious.

Re: Satya Nadella email to employees on first day as CEO

#14
post #10

> Today is a very humbling day for me. The first sentence of the email, statement that seems entirely appropriate given the circumstances. Nonetheless, I find it curious that we expect people who reach the highest levels of accomplishment to describe those accomplishments as humbling. It seems natural to us for someone promoted to the heights of their profession, such as Satya Nadella in this case, or the winner of a…

It is humbling because you are elected by a group of your peers to lead. It also gives implicit credit to all the people that helped make him successful. Leadership is not zero sum and it doesn't follow specific rules. If anything the rules of promotion are codified by practice and not necessarily logical and prescribed but in general most people aspire to be fair and merit based.

> It is humbling because you are essentially elected by a group of your peers to lead.

I don't understand this. It would be more humbling if, being at the top of your game and fully expecting to get the job, you were turned down for the CEO position. Or they demote you to a lower position. /That/ would be humbling. You're humlbed when you suddenly are forced to re-evaluate your self-worth after it's made clear it doesn't match the real-world scenario, not when you reach the top or reaffirm your position.

Re: Satya Nadella email to employees on first day as CEO

#15

> Today is a very humbling day for me. The first sentence of the email, statement that seems entirely appropriate given the circumstances. Nonetheless, I find it curious that we expect people who reach the highest levels of accomplishment to describe those accomplishments as humbling. It seems natural to us for someone promoted to the heights of their profession, such as Satya Nadella in this case, or the winner of a…

> Today is a very humbling day for me.

When I read that I knew this guy would fail as MS CEO. It's a proper jungle out there and a humble Indian guy will be eaten alive by the aggressive confident westerners.

Re: Satya Nadella email to employees on first day as CEO

#17

"Who am I? I am 46. I’ve been married for 22 years and we have 3 kids." -> Who cares?

Are you American? I was wondering about this too. As a Frenchman, I had the same reaction as you, but I think Americans care a lot about this. I've been told for example that in the US it would be completely impossible for a president to be elected if he didn't had a solid marriage and family. I find those cultural differences fascinating

Surely, if he strongly identifies as a family man, and having a family is something that has shaped his growth as a human being, it's something he finds worth mentioning, no?

Re: Satya Nadella email to employees on first day as CEO

#18

> Today is a very humbling day for me. The first sentence of the email, statement that seems entirely appropriate given the circumstances. Nonetheless, I find it curious that we expect people who reach the highest levels of accomplishment to describe those accomplishments as humbling. It seems natural to us for someone promoted to the heights of their profession, such as Satya Nadella in this case, or the winner of a…

It's humbling, in the sense that you don't really know how tall the mountain is until you get to the top and look around. When you become CEO of a company as big as Microsoft, or so I'd imagine, you get a true sense of just how vast and all-encompassing your responsibilities have become. The task is much bigger than you are.

That said, I'm sure at least 50% of the usage choice in his email was rhetorical gesture. It's become commonplace for people receiving awards, honors, or offices to describe themselves as "humbled." Somewhere in the semi-distant past, someone determined that this was a good PR move.

Re: Satya Nadella email to employees on first day as CEO

#19

> Today is a very humbling day for me. The first sentence of the email, statement that seems entirely appropriate given the circumstances. Nonetheless, I find it curious that we expect people who reach the highest levels of accomplishment to describe those accomplishments as humbling. It seems natural to us for someone promoted to the heights of their profession, such as Satya Nadella in this case, or the winner of a…

Isn't it rather because it's like grabbing the controls of a star cruiser and realising how small you are?

Re: Satya Nadella email to employees on first day as CEO

#20

> Today is a very humbling day for me. The first sentence of the email, statement that seems entirely appropriate given the circumstances. Nonetheless, I find it curious that we expect people who reach the highest levels of accomplishment to describe those accomplishments as humbling. It seems natural to us for someone promoted to the heights of their profession, such as Satya Nadella in this case, or the winner of a…

> Today is a very humbling day for me. When I read that I knew this guy would fail as MS CEO. It's a proper jungle out there and a humble Indian guy will be eaten alive by the aggressive confident westerners.

I think most will ignore your comment for what it is but I want to respond.

He didn't become CEO because he played it nice. I'm sure he's been as aggressive and mean when he's needed to be to advance himself and his work.

It's humbling because out of the many many top candidates he got the job. It's humbling to be considered at that level among your peers and be picked.

I would venture to say that he mixes the best of east indian tradition and western tradition.

The board is filled with very capable people, especially John W. Thompson. He was the CEO of Symantec and took that company from its early beginnings to a major player.

Time will tell if this was a right pick for CEO but I believe that most will be very happy with the choice as its a good contrast to what Steve Ballmer was.

Post reply on HN