Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft Said to Be Preparing to Make Satya Nadella CEO

bloomberg.com

11–20 of 132 posts

Re: Microsoft Said to Be Preparing to Make Satya Nadella CEO

#11
post #5

That's disappointing. I was really hoping that it would be someone external to the company who would be visionary enough to take them to new heights. Instead, they're picking the safe, enterprise bet, who won't change things too much. I would say Microsoft's consumer facing days are numbered.

They basically own the entire PC market, and most of the enterprise market. What more do you want?

It's like bitching that Walmart hasn't cornered Starbucks. Jesus.

Re: Microsoft Said to Be Preparing to Make Satya Nadella CEO

#12
I think an interesting side effect of this; his vacating of the Cloud/Enterprise role provides a natural succession up the chain for Scott Guthrie. It also gives Scott (who has more of an effect on the Microsoft dev community than any other person) a direct pipeline and solid personal relationship with the CEO.

Re: Microsoft Said to Be Preparing to Make Satya Nadella CEO

#13
Big mistake IMO. I can't imagine Satya "the enterprise guy" being CEO of the devices company (he's probably qualified to be CEO for the "services" part of Microsoft). I'm wondering if him and Elop would work as co-CEOs, but history shows that's not a good idea either.

Re: Microsoft Said to Be Preparing to Make Satya Nadella CEO

#14
Observations:

⚫ This spot's proving very difficult to fill. Both in terms of finding the right person, and in getting them to accept. It's been 160 days from the initial announcement of Ballmer's retirement.

⚫ Given Ballmer's long-standing deficiencies and publicly-voiced dissatisfaction with his performance, this also speaks to very poor succession planning on the part of the Board. This would be they: http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/news/exec/bod.aspx

⚫ Enterprise + cloud is probably a safe pick for now. It suggests a de-emphasis of consumer and mobile, and a retrenchment to core strengths, if not enduring ones.

⚫ I'm not sold that bringing in external talent solves problems that insiders can't tackle. The insiders will be well aware of strengths and weaknesses, the challenge is in acting on them given existing internal relationships and politics.

Re: Microsoft Said to Be Preparing to Make Satya Nadella CEO

#15
post #8
post #5

That's disappointing. I was really hoping that it would be someone external to the company who would be visionary enough to take them to new heights. Instead, they're picking the safe, enterprise bet, who won't change things too much. I would say Microsoft's consumer facing days are numbered.

As a Microsoft Developer, I don't want a Microsoft with new vision. I want a Microsoft that will continue to build a great platform to build business applications on. We moved away from WPF after Windows 8. We gravitated towards ASP.NET MVC, but increasingly started using Angular JS. While I love these new javascript libs, I miss the great tool set that Microsoft always provided. Without that, I think we can eventual…

You do realize that you're confirming the previous point of the "consumer side days are numbered". Platforms for business applications are not good for consumers.

Re: Microsoft Said to Be Preparing to Make Satya Nadella CEO

#16
post #4

From one former Milwaukeean to another, I hope this kicks more recruiters to the area. With three major universities in the city, there was a dismal number of national recruiters dropping by when I lived there (about a decade ago now, maybe things are different).

I grew up in Milwaukee and (in 2002) applied only to California universities because I thought the tech industry/opportunities out there were much more substantial, and I'd have a leg up on professional networking. Has worked out well. YMMV

Re: Microsoft Said to Be Preparing to Make Satya Nadella CEO

#17
Background != Direction

All this banter about it being a bad choice or a good choice because Satya's current role is enterprise focused is just goofy. Had Elop been chosen we would not be acting as if Microsoft is only a phone company now and is abandoning the enterprise.

Re: Microsoft Said to Be Preparing to Make Satya Nadella CEO

#18

I think an interesting side effect of this; his vacating of the Cloud/Enterprise role provides a natural succession up the chain for Scott Guthrie. It also gives Scott (who has more of an effect on the Microsoft dev community than any other person) a direct pipeline and solid personal relationship with the CEO.

If Satya is indeed promoted to CEO, Soma -- not Scott -- will be promoted to EVP.

Re: Microsoft Said to Be Preparing to Make Satya Nadella CEO

#19
As I said 50 days ago[1] Nadella was always the most likely internal candidate. It's a choice that makes some sense to me - he's a technologist, which I think is important (note that at some point the Ford CEO was tipped). However, his background is all in Enterprise software.

Microsoft's most successful products recently have all been in the Enterprise field, so that reflects well on him. But there have to be questions about his experience with consumer software.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6871957

Re: Microsoft Said to Be Preparing to Make Satya Nadella CEO

#20

I think an interesting side effect of this; his vacating of the Cloud/Enterprise role provides a natural succession up the chain for Scott Guthrie. It also gives Scott (who has more of an effect on the Microsoft dev community than any other person) a direct pipeline and solid personal relationship with the CEO.

If Satya is indeed promoted to CEO, Soma -- not Scott -- will be promoted to EVP.

I imagine that Satya would know the people well and where he wants them so we may see some shuffling in the next 6-9 months. Scott is a great public persona and clicks with developers far more than Soma. Soma is stronger operationally and there are going to be other ops critical roles to fill because Satya's elevation to CEO will certainly cause some high level people to leave.

Going to be an interesting next couple years.

Post reply on HN