Live data from Hacker News

Court: Google infringed patents, must pay 1.36 percent of AdWords revenue

arstechnica.com

11–20 of 193 posts

Re: Court: Google infringed patents, must pay 1.36 percent of AdWords revenue

#11

Is there any push right now to enact legislation that makes patent litigation available only to entities that actively participate in the relevant marketplaces? It doesn't seem like there is, but maybe I'm not that informed in these affairs.

No. Just stop granting patents on software or business processes. Copyright, yes, patents, no.

Re: Court: Google infringed patents, must pay 1.36 percent of AdWords revenue

#12
Google is already appealing, but what happens if Google loses ? Would the supreme court agree to hear this case ? If so, the silver lining might be that the supreme court overturns this decision and in doing to comes up with something useful like the 2007 decision which limits a patent troll's ability to get an injunction to knock out a product.

Re: Court: Google infringed patents, must pay 1.36 percent of AdWords revenue

#13
post #10

> US-based revenue from AdWords, Google's flagship program Given Google's structure and revenue recognition, I'd be surprised if they had to pay out anything significant.

Google's corporate structure is designed to hide and move profit, not revenue. If this ruling is upheld we're talking a super-massive quantity of money going to someone who did nothing.

And the patent system will still not get reformed.

Re: Court: Google infringed patents, must pay 1.36 percent of AdWords revenue

#15
post #13
post #10

> US-based revenue from AdWords, Google's flagship program Given Google's structure and revenue recognition, I'd be surprised if they had to pay out anything significant.

Google's corporate structure is designed to hide and move profit, not revenue. If this ruling is upheld we're talking a super-massive quantity of money going to someone who did nothing. And the patent system will still not get reformed.

[deleted]

Re: Court: Google infringed patents, must pay 1.36 percent of AdWords revenue

#16
So is the tech industry as such not interested in changing this system? I find it inconceivable that the entire tech industry is not able to change the law about just software patents, not all patents, but just software patents. All the old laggard companies have invested a lot of time and money and hoarded a bunch of patents and so they do not care enough. Eventually the companies that are hurt in this are the small ones.

Re: Court: Google infringed patents, must pay 1.36 percent of AdWords revenue

#17
The Microsoft settlement for the same was interesting:

"Vringo also sued Microsoft over ads in its Bing search engine. Microsoft settled that case in May, agreeing to pay $1 million plus 5 percent of whatever Google ultimately pays."

It's strange agreeing to pay 5% of Google outcome on the same and quite clever the more I consider the pros/cons.

Post reply on HN