Live data from Hacker News

Why isn't People-Centric UI Design taking off?

hanselman.com

21–30 of 78 posts

Re: Why isn't People-Centric UI Design taking off?

#21
post #16

I don't have any friends or know any people. This wouldn't help me much.

You could still list people you stalk, or give machines anthropomorphic names, the ever so stereotypical pr0n star name or star trek character name for each server, etc.

"In a shocking turn of events, it looks like Jenna is, erm, down again...?"

Re: Why isn't People-Centric UI Design taking off?

#22
"Even on my iPhone or iPad I can't have an icon that represents a document."

You can do that easily on Android, using a file manager, and on a desktop you can do it too. There's nothing difficult about this, it's just not on iOS. It is an interesting point though, I wonder if a people widget for Android would be useful. I seem to remember having a most contacted or similar by HTC a while ago, but there's nothing for stock Android atm. There are of course some on the store, but it just doesn't seem particularly useful. I guess it just doesn't seem easier to me, the task context seems useful.

Edit: Contacts widget = widget for People :)

Re: Why isn't People-Centric UI Design taking off?

#23
without getting into too much about how I can put icons to documents and people right on my Windows desktop and Android start screens, my amateur psychologist thinks that the reason people-centric UI design hasn't taken off is that we subconsciously associate functions with people. In other words, our interface with another person centers around the functions that person supplies us with. For example, I have a few friends that I only ever play online games with, so my functional connection to them is via games or game-centered social networks. I think "play games with..." first before I decide on a person to play with.

This is why it's natural to chart out social relationships as entities/nodes for people and relations as modes between the nodes. Navigating to another person involves traversing this graph over a selected relation.

I think this is the reason I go to facebook before I think about posting something on a friend's wall, or open up my email client, or picking up a phone first, before finalizing my internal decision on who to call.

Re: Why isn't People-Centric UI Design taking off?

#24

"Even on my iPhone or iPad I can't have an icon that represents a document." You can do that easily on Android, using a file manager, and on a desktop you can do it too. There's nothing difficult about this, it's just not on iOS. It is an interesting point though, I wonder if a people widget for Android would be useful. I seem to remember having a most contacted or similar by HTC a while ago, but there's nothing for…

I just put shortcuts to contacts on the homescreen and it works fine.

Re: Why isn't People-Centric UI Design taking off?

#25
This works for devices that are primarily communication devices, i.e. ~2008-era phones. Today I use my phone to browse the web, check the weather, read the news and tweets, trade some stocks, post a few pictures to facebook, and maybe send an email or text. Oh, and occasionally make a phone call. Of these, only 3 activities are 'people'-centric. The rest are activity-centric and apps are the modern smartphone's encapsulation of an activity.

Re: Why isn't People-Centric UI Design taking off?

#26
The issue is that texting, with a few interesting exceptions, completely dominates most people's daily personal communication. I mean, the "People" app on my Android phone can do what he describes, but 99.99% of the time, my most recent text conversations are all I want to see when I pick up my phone to communicate. Both Hangouts and iOS's messages have convenient links to their phone app, making this pretty much a solved problem.

The only notable exceptions are the privacy-oriented messengers like Snapchat... but I imagine having the messages be silo'd is more of a feature than a bug for a lot of the users.

Re: Why isn't People-Centric UI Design taking off?

#27

"Even on my iPhone or iPad I can't have an icon that represents a document." You can do that easily on Android, using a file manager, and on a desktop you can do it too. There's nothing difficult about this, it's just not on iOS. It is an interesting point though, I wonder if a people widget for Android would be useful. I seem to remember having a most contacted or similar by HTC a while ago, but there's nothing for…

> I wonder if a people widget for Android would be useful

Is the contact widget what you are looking for?

Re: Why isn't People-Centric UI Design taking off?

#28
post #27

"Even on my iPhone or iPad I can't have an icon that represents a document." You can do that easily on Android, using a file manager, and on a desktop you can do it too. There's nothing difficult about this, it's just not on iOS. It is an interesting point though, I wonder if a people widget for Android would be useful. I seem to remember having a most contacted or similar by HTC a while ago, but there's nothing for…

> I wonder if a people widget for Android would be useful Is the contact widget what you are looking for?

Yep! Thanks, I hate the Android widget menu so I just guessed it'd be called People since the app is now.

Re: Why isn't People-Centric UI Design taking off?

#29
I think that part of it is that the thought process is closer to "I want to send an email to my friend Bob" than "To Bob I want to send an email".

I realize that sounds contrived, but I think activity/tool/app centric experiences are more closely tied to "solving a problem" and people centric experiences are more obscure/less obvious in what you can do.

Perhaps the problem is that people think more about what they want to do than who they want to do it with.

Post reply on HN