Live data from Hacker News

An 11.88” Retina MacBook Air

fpblog.net

31–40 of 64 posts

Re: An 11.88” Retina MacBook Air

#31
post #17
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If they are both Retina, then the weight difference is the biggest deal. Reducing the screen size from 13" to 12" would let them make it significantly lighter than the MacBook Pro.

Right. And people will ask themselves ... why have I paid more for a heavier notebook?

I imagine that a 12" retina MBA will mean the death of the 13" MBP. I further imagine that Apple is perfectly OK with that.

Re: An 11.88” Retina MacBook Air

#34

Time to upgrade from my 2009 MBP? It's so hard to "throw away" a perfectly functional laptop that does everything I need - just not as well (I realize) as a faster, lighter, machine would.

I know what you mean my Vostro from a few years ago is still a decent spec (i5-2430/16Gb DDR) however I found out today you can now get the X1 Carbon with the 2560x1440...my Vostro is looking more and more like it needs replacing.

I would check out the X1 Carbon in person before making that decision. The display is terrible. It's the only device over ever used that's given me significant headaches after even moderate use.

Re: An 11.88” Retina MacBook Air

#36

Time to upgrade from my 2009 MBP? It's so hard to "throw away" a perfectly functional laptop that does everything I need - just not as well (I realize) as a faster, lighter, machine would.

I know what you mean my Vostro from a few years ago is still a decent spec (i5-2430/16Gb DDR) however I found out today you can now get the X1 Carbon with the 2560x1440...my Vostro is looking more and more like it needs replacing.

If you're a developer - take a look at the keyboard first. They replaced the F keys with capacitive buttons (ie. touch sensitive buttons as opposed to physical buttons) and the capslock key was split into a home/end key instead. Sure it's still a nice laptop, but that sort of thing would drive me crazy.

Re: An 11.88” Retina MacBook Air

#38
An 11/12" MacBook Air with a touchscreen that could also run iOS apps with cellular connectivity would be the ideal iPad Pro for my needs. Using a touchscreen on a small laptop is no worse than using an iPad in a stand or flat on a desk.

Re: An 11.88” Retina MacBook Air

#39
post #31
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Right. And people will ask themselves ... why have I paid more for a heavier notebook?

I imagine that a 12" retina MBA will mean the death of the 13" MBP. I further imagine that Apple is perfectly OK with that.

I'm really struggling to imagine customers are going to be ok with that.

Just because a smallish form factor proved propular doesn't mean you're not suddenly going to find a size which is a dealbreaker.

12" is tiny and doesn't really improve portability for a laptop-like device (which goes in a backpack).

Re: An 11.88” Retina MacBook Air

#40
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I know what you mean my Vostro from a few years ago is still a decent spec (i5-2430/16Gb DDR) however I found out today you can now get the X1 Carbon with the 2560x1440...my Vostro is looking more and more like it needs replacing.

If you're a developer - take a look at the keyboard first. They replaced the F keys with capacitive buttons (ie. touch sensitive buttons as opposed to physical buttons) and the capslock key was split into a home/end key instead. Sure it's still a nice laptop, but that sort of thing would drive me crazy.

http://www.lenovo.com/images/gallery/1060x596/lenovo-laptop-...

Oh god, you're right, they did! That's horrible!

Post reply on HN