Live data from Hacker News

Growth Hacking Is Bull

marketingland.com

21–30 of 36 posts

Re: Growth Hacking Is Bull

#21

If you use the word "hack" and "hacking" as synonym for "unprofessional" (ex: he is just a hack), then growth hacking makes sense that it's not good. (Also, when non pro's write code, that is a hacking)

That's not what hacking, in this sense, means.

Hacking is getting something done creatively. As in, hacking away at a problem.

Re: Growth Hacking Is Bull

#22
Waaaahhh, somebody used a new term to describe tried and true marketing activities to make them sound new/sexy/novel.

People reapply the same concepts and ideas, but with new terminology all the time. It's good marketing :)

Now, I must get back to word sculpting...

Re: Growth Hacking Is Bull

#24

I am largely to blame for the recent tirade against “growth hacking.” I’ve let the term be bastardized and redefined a lot since my original blog post on it back in 2010 http://www.startup-marketing.com/where-are-all-the-growth-ha... . I wrote that blog post primarily for startups that had achieved product/market fit. The idea was not to replace marketing, but to create a category of marketing activities that have a…

> Growth hacking (to me anyway) is a subset of marketing activities too.

I've always thought that it was the other way around, i.e. marketing is one of the things you can do in growth hacking, but not everything. To me growth hacking means doing/focusing on things that help grow the business, and marketing is just one of the things you can do. Other things that you can do to help growth include actually improving the product and reduce friction, which are not marketing. Maybe I've misunderstood the term "growth hacking" then.

Re: Growth Hacking Is Bull

#25
I view growth hacking as online marketing done by people who don't need permission or help to get things done.

Traditional online marketers are paralyzed by their lack of technical and design skills. The best they can do is brainstorm ideas and spend money on ads.

Re: Growth Hacking Is Bull

#26
post #8

The difference between "growth hacking" and "online marketing" as I understanding it is that the former involves dedicating engineering effort: building repeatable automated systems that operate at scales that are untenable with manual effort. Marketing, as a business objective, has historically been underserved by engineering. "Marketing engineering" occupied approximately the same status level as internal IT. "Grow…

This is exactly how I view it. Well said!

Re: Growth Hacking Is Bull

#27
This is my response --http://brandonpindulic.co/2014/01/10/growth-hacking-defined/

Summary: This is simply an opinion piece that I wrote to try to get the point across that growth is everywhere, and constraining it to a definition is simply counterintuitive.

In short, if it grows your business, then by all means do that, whatever it is, and to keep learning, experimenting and testing new strategies.

Re: Growth Hacking Is Bull

#28
Saying what Airbnb isn't growth hacking doesn't mean it wasn't. There were no protocols into Craigslist for cross-posting and they had to hack them together to get growth - that's growth hacking.

Re: Growth Hacking Is Bull

#29

"Growth hacking" is like an SUV: an attempt to take something stigmatized as effeminate (minivans) and masculinize it, to the point that it develops its own mancult.

I like the analogy, but I think SUVs were really a way to exploit a loophole in emissions regulations. Because of the technical definitions, SUVs count as trucks not cars for emissions standards.

Re: Growth Hacking Is Bull

#30
post #24

I am largely to blame for the recent tirade against “growth hacking.” I’ve let the term be bastardized and redefined a lot since my original blog post on it back in 2010 http://www.startup-marketing.com/where-are-all-the-growth-ha... . I wrote that blog post primarily for startups that had achieved product/market fit. The idea was not to replace marketing, but to create a category of marketing activities that have a…

> Growth hacking (to me anyway) is a subset of marketing activities too. I've always thought that it was the other way around, i.e. marketing is one of the things you can do in growth hacking, but not everything. To me growth hacking means doing/focusing on things that help grow the business, and marketing is just one of the things you can do. Other things that you can do to help growth include actually improving the…

Its probably better represented as a venn diagram. Applies to potentially many disciplines within an operation.
Post reply on HN