Live data from Hacker News

Get Facebook WiFi for your business

facebook.com

201–210 of 293 posts

Re: Get Facebook WiFi for your business

#201
post #175

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Also if you look at the page, you can see you can change who you share the check-in with. It's just like Facebook app integrations: you can switch the share settings to "only me" if you want a private check-in if you're worried about spamming others.

Wait I thought he was joking. Facebook actually suggests that you share your current location with everyone?

Maybe you're new to Facebook..

Re: Get Facebook WiFi for your business

#202
post #179

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Actually I'd trust Boingo more than Facebook as a platform. They've been around since 2001, Facebook since 2004.

That finally explains what that preinstalled crapware on my previous Asus laptop was. Never came across any hotspot with Boinggoboing though.

I see them in airports...

Re: Get Facebook WiFi for your business

#204

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the point of the story is to illustrate that a Facebook account is not a useful way to validate a customer's identity.

I think the point is it's useful enough for many situations.

No, it's really not. Its very simple to create a fake FB account, all you need is an email. Relying on FB login is a really stupid way to try to verify identity - why not just use emails if they want some minimum bar for registration? FB is no more useful, ubiquitous, or reliable.

I see the attraction for FB in this though; they're desperately trying to come up with ways to avoid becoming the next geocities or myspace - if lots of websites or services use their login or comments system, they will manage to stay at least minimally relevant for a bit longer.

I'm not really sure what's in it for the businesses or consumers though, unless they trust FB...[1]

[1] http://www.businessinsider.com/well-these-new-zuckerberg-ims...

Re: Get Facebook WiFi for your business

#205
post #166

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, said ice cream shop had a fully open wifi before going through the hassle of creating the captive portal by themselves two years ago. The thing that really irks me is the assumption that nowadays everyone has facebook. Isn't it surprising that in a country that finds national IDs liberticide the problem of identifying people is being outsourced to a corporate monopoly?

> The thing that really irks me is the assumption that nowadays everyone has facebook With over a billion users, you'll have that. My POV is... look, you get to be as contrarian as you want. Feel free to never jump on the FB band wagon. But understand you're in the minority. Facebook is that big, and is that established in our culture. So, feel free, choose your own path, but then stop whining about the hassle of bei…

My POV is... look, you get to be as contrarian as you want. Feel free to never jump on the Dictatorship band wagon. But understand you're in the minority. The Dictator is that big, and is that established in our culture. So, feel free, choose your own path, but then stop whining about the hassle of being in the minority. Nobody cares about your freedom concerns.

Re: Get Facebook WiFi for your business

#206
post #188
post #109

Real conversation happened to me in an ice cream shop with a home-brewed facebook captive portal in Cambridge, MA. me: Excuse me, is there a way to log into the wifi if you don't have a facebook account? clerk: No, we've had a lots people doing illegal stuff on our wifi, so we need to verify their identity. me: I understand, however I don't have a facebook account. Would you like to verify my identity with a photo id…

What do you imagine, the clerk has access to the a wifi panel where he can just enter in your details, match it to your mac address, and you can bypass the facebook login? That this guy has been trained on a complex system, which has very little use, makes them no direct extra money, would be more expensive and a pain in the ass? So you acting like a jerk just makes you look stupid, and then you write about it online…

So, asking for alternatives to what you consider ethically questionable makes you a jerk then? And opression is not to be questioned if getting rid of it and its externalities would cost something?

Re: Get Facebook WiFi for your business

#207
post #149
post #109

Real conversation happened to me in an ice cream shop with a home-brewed facebook captive portal in Cambridge, MA. me: Excuse me, is there a way to log into the wifi if you don't have a facebook account? clerk: No, we've had a lots people doing illegal stuff on our wifi, so we need to verify their identity. me: I understand, however I don't have a facebook account. Would you like to verify my identity with a photo id…

Where is this, Toscanini? I don't think the guy running the register and dipping the ice cream has the ability to override whatever settings the tech guy put into the router for the owner in the first place but can't you just walk down the street to the free Starbucks? These are their terms, why does everyone have to argue with others about free services provided?

Why do you think that it is wrong to argue for something that you think would make the world a better place?

Suppose I offered free drinking water that had radon in it, would it be wrong for you to argue for getting rid of the radon because it's free, and my terms are that there is radon in it?

Re: Get Facebook WiFi for your business

#208

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are you really claiming that creating a fake facebook account is "abuse"?

In the sense that it violates a social contract? That is, WIFI access in exchange for repping this spot to your friends in however minor a fashion? In the sense of behavior that you as a service provider wish to prevent? Yeah, in all those senses, it is "abuse."

I think you overlooked that they violated the social contract first by requiring you to submit to surveillance, so all I am doing is to protect me from their abuse.

Re: Get Facebook WiFi for your business

#209
post #149

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Where is this, Toscanini? I don't think the guy running the register and dipping the ice cream has the ability to override whatever settings the tech guy put into the router for the owner in the first place but can't you just walk down the street to the free Starbucks? These are their terms, why does everyone have to argue with others about free services provided?

Why do you think that it is wrong to argue for something that you think would make the world a better place? Suppose I offered free drinking water that had radon in it, would it be wrong for you to argue for getting rid of the radon because it's free, and my terms are that there is radon in it?

If those are your terms, it's up to the customer to decide whether they would accept those terms in exchange for the water. I don't see the problem

Re: Get Facebook WiFi for your business

#210

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The thing that really irks me is the assumption that nowadays everyone has facebook With over a billion users, you'll have that. My POV is... look, you get to be as contrarian as you want. Feel free to never jump on the FB band wagon. But understand you're in the minority. Facebook is that big, and is that established in our culture. So, feel free, choose your own path, but then stop whining about the hassle of bei…

My POV is... look, you get to be as contrarian as you want. Feel free to never jump on the Dictatorship band wagon. But understand you're in the minority. The Dictator is that big, and is that established in our culture. So, feel free, choose your own path, but then stop whining about the hassle of being in the minority. Nobody cares about your freedom concerns.

Like a drug, nobody knows yet the long term effects of Facebook. So when someone acts super paranoid about the effects of something yet unproven, other people come out of the woodwork and try to give the guy some perspective.

It's kind of the same negative attitudes we see towards GMO's, drones or RF radiation.

I mean people could easily flip their perspective and, instead, see these tools as very powerful and, if used correctly, could have massive positive impact on humanity. They can then educate themselves about these tools and figure out how to be the very ones to incur that massive positive impact on humanity using these tools.

Post reply on HN