Live data from Hacker News

I Decided to Delete All My Facebook Activity

slate.com

61–70 of 72 posts

Re: I Decided to Delete All My Facebook Activity

#61
post #57
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I also use Youtube, Google Music, Gmail etc > a G+ account was forced on me again To be clear, a G+ account is a Google account. It ties together all Google properties. Just seems bizarre to use these and consider G+ as being forced on you - it is just your Google account. One doesn't need to actually use the social features provided by one's Google account.

This is false.

No, this is not false.

Re: I Decided to Delete All My Facebook Activity

#62
post #28

Cough..snapchat..this is the value it brings.

Except that's not really secure, either.

I never claimed it was secure, or private, or whatever. Just that the functionality of Snapchat embodies what the author was saying.

Re: I Decided to Delete All My Facebook Activity

#63
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I deleted my Twitter account, LinkedIn, and Google+ a couple of years ago. I also Googled myself and slowly removed myself from every other service I haven't used in years. Facebook was the only one I kept as I get a lot of value from it. The only server that has crawled back into my life is Google+, and only for one reason - Android. It's the easiest way to backup all my photos. Not to mention the fact I also use Yo…

> I also use Youtube, Google Music, Gmail etc > a G+ account was forced on me again To be clear, a G+ account is a Google account. It ties together all Google properties. Just seems bizarre to use these and consider G+ as being forced on you - it is just your Google account. One doesn't need to actually use the social features provided by one's Google account.

You can delete your Google+ account without deleting your Google account [1].

[1] https://support.google.com/plus/answer/1044503?hl=en

Re: I Decided to Delete All My Facebook Activity

#64
I think this is why Snapchat strikes fear into the heart of Facebook. It's not the current business model of sending drunken cleavage shots and not charging for them... it's the potential for a social network that really states the present, not the forever. I think there's tremendous value there.

Re: I Decided to Delete All My Facebook Activity

#65

I "deactivated" my Facebook account long ago. I'd like to delete it, but that apparently involves sacrificing some small animal and studying the entrails for clues. I deleted by Google+ account(s) recently, as well. I have several Twitter accounts with no tweets. I'm thinking of sanitizing my LinkedIn account soon. It's not that I'm anti-social (well, maybe); I am just one of those elder geeks who once dreamt of trul…

Here's for you my friend:

http://www.accountkiller.com/en/

alternatively, you could give http://www.howtoleavefacebook.com/ a try

Re: I Decided to Delete All My Facebook Activity

#66

I "deactivated" my Facebook account long ago. I'd like to delete it, but that apparently involves sacrificing some small animal and studying the entrails for clues. I deleted by Google+ account(s) recently, as well. I have several Twitter accounts with no tweets. I'm thinking of sanitizing my LinkedIn account soon. It's not that I'm anti-social (well, maybe); I am just one of those elder geeks who once dreamt of trul…

Deleting your Facebook is difficult? I believe mine is hard deleted (not deactivated), and it was the same workflow as deactivating it, if I remember correctly. I just clicked "delete" instead of "deactivate" or whatever. Facebook leaves the account deactivated for a week so you can ponder on your choice, but if you don't do anything, it was my understanding that the account gets deleted.

You can't delete the data you gave to facebook, you can make it disappear to the other facebook registered slaves but it will live forever in facebook storage.

Re: I Decided to Delete All My Facebook Activity

#67
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I believe doing the delete account via Facebook will only delete [your own] posts and things on "your timeline/wall". Any comments you made on other peoples posts do not get deleted. I believe, using the "automation" method or similar methods actually goes through and finds all your posts and comments on other people's walls/timelines and also deletes them.

I deleted my account and I am pretty sure all your comments on others' things do get deleted..

Nothing gets deleted ever, your account and related data still lives in facebook servers but only accessible to facebook and their commercial partners (also NSA, US government, spy agencies and crackers).

Re: I Decided to Delete All My Facebook Activity

#68
post #30
post #20

What most people seem to be missing and which the article does not properly explain is why some people think it is necessary to delete each item individually. Yes you can both deactivate (soft delete) an account and you can actually say to facebook to actually delete it. Deleting an account does not allegedly remove your data from the Facebook servers. Deleting items however will remove your data from the servers. Th…

> "Deleting items however will remove your data from the servers" Why are you so sure about this?

It will remove the data from the cache servers but the data will not be deleted from facebook storage.

Re: I Decided to Delete All My Facebook Activity

#69
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Good point. In my mind, ideally the next big social media platform will be P2P and open source. I have some ideas on how this might work and the features this would include, but I've never hashed them out since my programming ability doesn't approach the level required for such an undertaking. Maybe I will as a thought experiment and publish my ideas so that anyone can use them.

Are you aware of Diaspora ? It's both distributed and open source.

Diaspora is a poor attempt at copying facebook, it's nothing like the distributed I have in mind, which would be easy to use encrypted self-hosting and not tied to a specific network/website/technology.

Re: I Decided to Delete All My Facebook Activity

#70
I cringed when I read "(...) and since it's my data, I want to be in control of its disposal.", OP obviously makes the confusion between providing the data and owning the data. It's regrettable that she contributes to propagating the idea that users own their data on facebook, when in reality once it is on facebook server it's not their data anymore, it now belongs to facebook.
Post reply on HN