Live data from Hacker News

British government porn filters block EFF, Linux, Amnesty and more

tgdaily.com

21–22 of 22 posts

Re: British government porn filters block EFF, Linux, Amnesty and more

#21

Can anyone in the UK verify this?

This is not the new uk gov porn filter. It is an optional fter, like any other net nanny filter or any enterprise style filter. It's restrictive because that's what those kinds of filters do. It is purely optional, and supposedly granular so the user could just block search engines but nothing else.

This is different to the proposed uk gov porn filter.

Re: British government porn filters block EFF, Linux, Amnesty and more

#22

How do British folks feel about this? I mean if they tried to pull shit like this in Canada, people would flip, burn down the parliament building.

If you mean the filter: most of the support is from Conservative voters, especially the older voters and parents. Labour and the Conservatives support it, I think many Lib Dems oppose it. A few years ago I would have said the same thing - "If they did this here, Brits would go mad!" - I think everyone wants to believe that about their country, but when it comes to it people are surprisingly accepting. Also, it's wort…

I think the spread of support is less clear. I vaguely recall some survey a few months back that posed a carefully-phrased question along the lines of "ISPs should do more to control what children see online (agree/ disagree)" and the support from Guardian readers was clearly in favour (can't rememeber the percentage).

There's a split in the Conservative party about infantilising adults - you just have to read ConservativeHome to see that. I would go as far to say that a majority of activists dislike what Cameron is being seen to do with the ISPs.

Contrast his current actions with his words several years ago: http://order-order.com/2007/11/24/cameron-we-are-libertarian...

I feel he's dangerous because he doesn't espouse an ideology. He doesn't offer a sense of where he wants to take the country - just wherever the newspaper headlines will take him. It might most kindly be described as a misguided sense of noblesse oblige.

Post reply on HN