Live data from Hacker News

Learn Sanskrit Online

learnsanskrit.org

61–70 of 83 posts

Re: Learn Sanskrit Online

#62
its great that such a resource exists. However when you want to learn a language that is still used and has similar grammar features you might want to opt for something like icelandic or polish.

Then also Turkish (although not indo-european) might be interesting since it has a really logical and regular grammar.

Re: Learn Sanskrit Online

#64

Oh, gosh, the usual Hindutva nonsense. Let me first of all dispel any notion that I don't like learning languages "for fun." See my Hacker News user profile for more details on what languages I have learned. I have learned enough facts about Sanskrit and the various languages that are written in the Devanagari alphabet to know 1) The written history of Sanskrit is much less that 3,000 years long. (The historiography…

I know nothing about Sanskrit to verify or refute what you claim, but why the negative attitude? This resource seems good. Maybe people are interested in Sanskrit just for the sake of learning it? Maybe some people want to learn Sanskrit and not other languages of south India, or Estonian, or Modern Standard Chinese.

I'm not aware of what the "usual Hindutva nonsense" is. I'm going to guess there's a group of people in India who think Sanskrit and/or Hindu culture are the best thing since sliced bread. Who cares? When fans of a language, culture (or technology! :P ) are trying to convince you to learn it, they will sometimes make highly biased claims. This is to be expected.

The only thing that would matter to me is if someone claimed this particular resource for learning Sanskrit is not very good, is hard to follow, or has many mistakes.

Re: Learn Sanskrit Online

#65
post #49
post #3

Why would someone, Indian or not, want to learn Sanskrit online?

As an Indian, 1. For the same reason as solving sudoku online i.e. for the joy of it. 2. Some interesting literature was written in Sanskrit. I may want to read that. 3. To be able to judge when a hindu preacher is bullshitting me. 4. To be able to critically analyze some of the religious stuff e.g. does the age of Sun god tally with what the modern physics tells us. 5. Its grammar expands my view of what is possible…

"For the joy of it" is probably the most important motive. For archeology is also good, though I assume a serious student of ancient languages won't learn from online guides.

Re: Learn Sanskrit Online

#66
post #3

Why would someone, Indian or not, want to learn Sanskrit online?

I imagine people like you breezing through life maximizing some objective function, never waiting to admire poetry or relish a moment, only to die at the end. Hyper-practical no-nonsense men questioning the value of everything for everyone. (The funny thing is Sanskrit is incredibly practical for lots of reasons.)

>>Sanskrit is incredibly practical for lots of reasons.

Well forget Sanskrit for just one minute. The utility of any language in the modern world today, apart from day-to-day conversation(Which happens only because that's the only language accessible to kids at birth through their parents) by and large depends on what scientific, economic, art and other kind of growth happens in that language.

Nearly all Indian languages lack vocabulary for most common objects. We don't have words for mobile phones, cars, buses, microwave ovens etc.. the list is endless. By and large any Indian language today looks like English words connected through that language's grammar.

Nearly all Indian languages are practically useless for any kind of serious work. You can't do any scientific work in it, no serious text books on any topic are ever written in it, You can't use these languages to get any kind of serious work done. In short these language only work for local communication with the help of English vocabulary added to local language.

Re: Learn Sanskrit Online

#67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Derived from Sanskrit is probably wrong, but German, Finnish and Sanskrit belong to the Indo-European language family ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indo-european ). Sanskrit is a very old language in this family tree ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proto-Indo-European_language ) and thus very close to the common ancestor. Being close to the ancestor probably means that it shares many traits with it that were inheri…

Finnish is Uralic, not Indo-European.

Oops, thanks. For a possible relationship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indo-Uralic_languages

Re: Learn Sanskrit Online

#68

Oh, gosh, the usual Hindutva nonsense. Let me first of all dispel any notion that I don't like learning languages "for fun." See my Hacker News user profile for more details on what languages I have learned. I have learned enough facts about Sanskrit and the various languages that are written in the Devanagari alphabet to know 1) The written history of Sanskrit is much less that 3,000 years long. (The historiography…

There is large body of ancient Sanskrit literature that is very interesting and ubique. Some of the poetry and prose like Kalidasa, Jayadeva etc. are exquisite.

If you are interested in Yoga, Meditation - you will appreciate the ability study the original texts. Yoga is now a global phenomenon and I personally know many people in the west and elsewhere study Patanjali and other texts.

There is great body of ancient knowledge (like Upanishads) on philosophy, the nature of mind, ego and the true nature one's self which is very unique.

The original texts for the ancient science of Ayurveda are in Sanskrit. There are many good universities in India that offer degrees in Ayurveda and Sanskrit is a prerequisite for studying Ayurveda.

There are several ancient astronomical and mathematical texts in Sanskrit like Sulaba Sutra etc. which are very interesting.

In the Indian tradition all rituals and rites of passage like birth, naming, marriage etc. are in Sanskrit and used on a daily basis although very few people speak the language.

India has an ancient system of classical music which is actively pursued and enjoyed by millions. Many compositions that people learn and sing are in Sanskrit.

Re: Learn Sanskrit Online

#69
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>>>>>>>Why would someone, Indian or not, want to learn Sanskrit online? >>>>>>>>There's nearly an infinite amount of knowledge in the world. And each of us has a finite amount of time. Why not is not an answer. You can apply that flawed reasoning to pretty much everything. It would've been a perfectly valid question if you had said "Why would I want to learn Sanskrit?". Please don't universalize your opinion by sayin…

I maintain that very few people have a reason to learn Sanskrit. It is a dead/dying language that will add zero value besides the esoteric joy of knowing a language for the sake of knowing it. If you feel that is not the case, please elucidate your reasons. I'll be happy to be proven wrong.

And very few people have reason to learn LISP or programming languages, for that matter. (If we are generalizing, we might as well go the full length and include the entire world population)

You seem to be mistaken that folks would learn a language for just the sake of knowing it. Far from it. Language is just a tool for communication of ideas. There have been some brilliant treatises, thoughts, ideas, and philosophies expressed in Sanskrit. Folks are more interested in accessing the thoughts and works in Sanskrit as opposed being infatuated with the technical aspects of the language.

Re: Learn Sanskrit Online

#70

The point is what would you do after learning or may be spending real good amount of time with it, what is the real need. I learnt sanskrit for more than 6 years and have passed upto threeeteeya(an exam to test your sanskrit skill). When i learn something i should be able to converse about it with many people as i can and help spread the knowledge or information. But learning an old language like sanskrit. What i fou…

Tritiya just means third.
Post reply on HN