Live data from Hacker News

Google Destroys Rap Genius’ Search Result Rankings As Punishment For SEO Spam

techcrunch.com

11–20 of 103 posts

Re: Google Destroys Rap Genius’ Search Result Rankings As Punishment For SEO Spam

#11
post #8

Still, the real story here is that almost all small businesses depend on the mercy of one giant corporation. This Google monstrosity / police man should be split up into smaller, competing search engines.

You realize the impossibility of this and this is a joke comment right?

Re: Google Destroys Rap Genius’ Search Result Rankings As Punishment For SEO Spam

#12
post #8

Still, the real story here is that almost all small businesses depend on the mercy of one giant corporation. This Google monstrosity / police man should be split up into smaller, competing search engines.

Ever heard of Bing, DuckDuckGo, Yahoo, etc.? Google just does it better than anyone else at the moment.

Now I'm not saying Google doesn't have a de facto monopoly, but I'm wary of anyone who says a private company should be forced to split. Should they be punished for being the most popular?

Re: Google Destroys Rap Genius’ Search Result Rankings As Punishment For SEO Spam

#14

It's probably a temporary ban that will last up to 90 days once appealed.

What grounds would they have for appealing? They haven't denied the original email posted was authentic. It seems to be black and white that they were engaging in blackhat SEO.

Re: Google Destroys Rap Genius’ Search Result Rankings As Punishment For SEO Spam

#15
post #8

Still, the real story here is that almost all small businesses depend on the mercy of one giant corporation. This Google monstrosity / police man should be split up into smaller, competing search engines.

Frankly I think it's an inherently monopolistic industry.

In the current state of affairs (i.e. web browser interfaces and mobile phone integration), it's quite inconvenient for people to switch up their search engine regularly, or even use multiple ones regularly.

With say, supermarkets, it's pretty easy to shop at Acme one day, Trader Joes another, and Superfresh the third. Search engines aren't like this, or at least, we haven't figured out a way to use them in a way that is conducive to fast-paced, low-barrier-to-entry (or at least not astronomically expensive barrier to entry) competition. Maybe we should.

Re: Google Destroys Rap Genius’ Search Result Rankings As Punishment For SEO Spam

#16
post #8

Still, the real story here is that almost all small businesses depend on the mercy of one giant corporation. This Google monstrosity / police man should be split up into smaller, competing search engines.

But in this case, we would have been worse off. It's hard to imagine that a fragmented ecosystem of smaller search engines would all reacted this quickly to a case of someone engaging in blackhat SEO, so there'd be a lot more temptation for sites to try to get away with this sort of thing.

Re: Google Destroys Rap Genius’ Search Result Rankings As Punishment For SEO Spam

#17
post #8

Still, the real story here is that almost all small businesses depend on the mercy of one giant corporation. This Google monstrosity / police man should be split up into smaller, competing search engines.

Online startups comprise a small portion of all small businesses. Most small businesses do not rely on Google.

Re: Google Destroys Rap Genius’ Search Result Rankings As Punishment For SEO Spam

#19

Now RapGenius.com doesn’t appear on the first page of results for a search of “Rap Genius” Readjusting their rankings is one thing, but that is just google breaking their own service. If people have typed "rap genius" into google, there is a reasonable chance that they might want to get to the thing named "rap genius", which is on page 5 in the search I just did. And the thing is, that nearly all the rest of the resu…

No, this is google enforcing a harsh penalty for one site to discourage other people from trying to game search which basically makes us all suffer through content farm links, etc.

I don't agree. I see the need for punishment of this kind of behavior, but removing the site from a Google search that seems to specifically be looking for that site is a bridge too far in my book.

Re: Google Destroys Rap Genius’ Search Result Rankings As Punishment For SEO Spam

#20

NOTE: There is an update not in the original report, apparently RG is working with Google to resolve the issue: We are working with Google right now to resolve this. They’ve been really great, helping us identify changes we need to make, even on Christmas. We’re working on it as fast as we can, and expect to be back on Google very soon. It sucks to be off Google for us and for the thousands of our community members w…

By working with Google they mean they're going to work with them to identify the links they need to clean up, try and get those links "cleaned up" themselves, submit a disavow file and then get them to reconsider the site as outlined here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6963785 It happens all the time and no disrespect to RapGenius, to companies much bigger than them.

And for far less reason.
Post reply on HN