Live data from Hacker News

Many private college presidents make $1 million

cnbc.com

11–20 of 46 posts

Re: Many private college presidents make $1 million

#11
...this doesn't bother me nearly as much as some people. Certainly not while college football coaches earn far more. The top ten highest paid football coaches are all taking home $3.7 million+, and that's at state universities[1]. Personally, I would value the university president more than the football coach.

[1]:http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1840036-usa-today-reveals...

Re: Many private college presidents make $1 million

#12
post #8

This isn't an issue, despite the article's implication otherwise. Being a president of a college isn't exactly a low-impact position: in addition to being a public emissary to the college, they send the majority of their time on the road, raising money for their endowment. Colleges who offer poor compensation for their presidents will generally receive a commensurate return on their investment (though I'd love to see…

Right. As the alum, I don't want my university to skimp on its President or on fundraising. It's a small part of the budget but a major impact on how much money goes into the school. I'm far more interested in controlling bottom line costs (administrators, faculty salaries, construction). It doesn't seem to me that the salaries of university presidents (or the financial managers of the university endowments) are responsible for growing tuition. I feel like having an administrator for every imaginable function and the demolition and replacement of perfectly serviceable academic buildings might be more of a factor...

Re: Many private college presidents make $1 million

#13
post #8

This isn't an issue, despite the article's implication otherwise. Being a president of a college isn't exactly a low-impact position: in addition to being a public emissary to the college, they send the majority of their time on the road, raising money for their endowment. Colleges who offer poor compensation for their presidents will generally receive a commensurate return on their investment (though I'd love to see…

With millions of your countrymen without basic health care, shelter and food, you think it's not a problem that someone makes $1 million a year? Wow.

Re: Many private college presidents make $1 million

#14
post #3

U of C has an endowment of about $6.6 billion. Much of the job of the President of the University is to raise money for this fund. In any other context, $3.4 million/year for the chief fundraiser of a $6.6 billion fund would not cause anyone to bat an eyelash. Since 2000, despite two major economic downturns, U of C's endowment almost doubled, from $3.8 billion. About half that time was during Zimmer's tenure, and hi…

This is exactly the point. University presidents are not hired primarily to manage an institutions education, but to fundraise. I recall a specific example in which the regents of the University of Virginia attempted to remove their president for not meeting a $3B fundraising goal. A chief fundraiser asked to bring in that much money should be compensated like those in industry dealing with similar amounts. Otherwise how will systems attract the best for the position.

Re: Many private college presidents make $1 million

#16
Supply and demand, supply and demand, supply and demand.

I wish more people understood this most basic law of economics.

If the supply of people who are both willing and able to handle the position of university President is low, wages (which are the price of labor) will rise, thus enticing those who are able but not willing to meet the demand. The prevailing average wage rate for university Presidents is simply a reflection of the price point at which the supply and demand curves of capable labor for this position meet. Conversely, if there was an abundance of people who could fulfill this position, wages would decrease commensurately. There is nothing wrong with someone making $1 million, or $10 million, or $100 million for performing a function, provided that wage is being offered to everyone who can perform that function indiscriminately. Of course, a system made up of imperfect agents will not function in a theoretically perfect fashion, but this is more or less how things work. I'm sure that being the President of a university is not without its myriad challenges, and it is unlikely that the average Joe off of the street could perform this function well. Thus, wages for university Presidents are going to be higher than the average Joe's wages. The solution for the average Joe is not to attempt to bring down the wages of the university President, but to aspire to become capable of performing the function of the university President himself.

Simplistic? Perhaps, but sometimes it's advantageous to think of things in simplistic terms. No one escapes the pot when everyone is being pulled back down.

Re: Many private college presidents make $1 million

#18
post #13
post #8

This isn't an issue, despite the article's implication otherwise. Being a president of a college isn't exactly a low-impact position: in addition to being a public emissary to the college, they send the majority of their time on the road, raising money for their endowment. Colleges who offer poor compensation for their presidents will generally receive a commensurate return on their investment (though I'd love to see…

With millions of your countrymen without basic health care, shelter and food, you think it's not a problem that someone makes $1 million a year? Wow.

I think the solution is that everyone should get subsidized health care, shelter, and food. I don't think you should need to work to have these things.

Re: Many private college presidents make $1 million

#19
post #11

...this doesn't bother me nearly as much as some people. Certainly not while college football coaches earn far more. The top ten highest paid football coaches are all taking home $3.7 million+, and that's at state universities[1]. Personally, I would value the university president more than the football coach. [1]: http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1840036-usa-today-reveals...

Universities make a boat load of money on football. It's important to have a great coach.

Re: Many private college presidents make $1 million

#20
post #13
post #8

This isn't an issue, despite the article's implication otherwise. Being a president of a college isn't exactly a low-impact position: in addition to being a public emissary to the college, they send the majority of their time on the road, raising money for their endowment. Colleges who offer poor compensation for their presidents will generally receive a commensurate return on their investment (though I'd love to see…

With millions of your countrymen without basic health care, shelter and food, you think it's not a problem that someone makes $1 million a year? Wow.

Even with all the problems that this (or any other nation) has, do you really think that it would help if every single individual made under $1M/year (which I admit is a big salary, but it is not outrageous, in the marketplace of talent, in this big world)?

If someone provides this value, then they are this valuable. If they don't, then the salary should be lower. It is that simple.

Or, to put it in entrepreneur terms: If I start a company and sell it for $100M, and I keep $20M for myself, is this wrong, because there is hunger in the world? No!

PG has an essay about this. http://paulgraham.com/inequality.html tl;dr: If you take away inequality, you take away the appetite for people to take any risks, because there will be no payout. You will then have fewer entrepreneurs, leading to fewer big companies, and fewer jobs. Read the article, it is an interesting perspective on the matter.

Post reply on HN