Live data from Hacker News

Amazon Prime Air

amazon.com

41–50 of 604 posts

Re: Amazon Prime Air

#41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The vast majority of the US isn't in an urban area, where these would thrive (presuming they could get the distance thing down). Edit: maybe not (see below).

Actually, 80% of US citizens are in "urban areas." http://www.census.gov/newsroom/releases/archives/2010_census...

Interesting, thanks for the research. I guess I shouldn't be too shocked, but it is a bit surprising (we have an enormous land mass).

Re: Amazon Prime Air

#43
post #10

Cool tech, but I question the practicality of it. This seems fraught with problems that a human on a bike wouldn't have. They're also entirely unsuitable for urban areas.

No, they're not entirely unsuitable for urban areas. Instead, their (relatively) short range means that they're unsuitable for anything except urban areas. If designed poorly, they would be very unsafe, but there are plenty of ways to increase the safety. For example, notice that the drones have more than 4 rotors. This gives a bit of redundancy so that a motor can fail without causing the drone to crash.

Can't wait until the first time one shreds a customer's dog, (or face, child, etc.) as it tries to deposit a package on her front porch.

Re: Amazon Prime Air

#45
post #10

Cool tech, but I question the practicality of it. This seems fraught with problems that a human on a bike wouldn't have. They're also entirely unsuitable for urban areas.

The vast majority of the US isn't in an urban area, where these would thrive (presuming they could get the distance thing down). Edit: maybe not (see below).

Are you considering land mass or where people actually live? Large sections of the country are practically unpopulated.

Re: Amazon Prime Air

#46
I don't understand how this would work without having distribution centers that fully cover the nation to within 30 minutes, and having every item they sell at every such center.

Even if you just want to cut UPS out of the last 30 minute radius and not stock everything at every distribution center... that's still distribution centers everywhere.

Re: Amazon Prime Air

#47
Well, not a day goes by that I don't already hear multiple airplanes and even more gas powered leaf blowers from my back yard.

I expect drones will increase that form of ambient noise in my neighborhood substantially.

Those who live in high vehicle traffic areas may not notice a difference.

Re: Amazon Prime Air

#48

Just watched the 60 minutes segment: Bezos say they won't be ready until 2015 at the earliest, likely 2016. (Edit: as the commenter below pointed out, I misheard the timeframe: is is 4-5 years out) He said the range is 10 miles, which is good enough for most residential areas. They are aiming for delivery in 30 minutes. The drones are autonomous: you plug in the GPS coordinates and away they go. The biggest challenge…

I have a feeling they are doing it to garner support for drones in general, which will help them with the FDA when it comes to getting approval.

Re: Amazon Prime Air

#50

NFW does this not run into all sorts of regulatory hurdles.

This will be a huge issue, even if Amazon gets this through the FAA, there are going to be all kinds of local interests expressing their concerns. What happens when one of these gets tied up in an overhead power lines? Did folks living near the fulfillment centers (assuming the warehouse were there first) sign up to live near a heliport, with dozens+ of aerial noise sources buzzing off every day? What about trees, etc?

This looks cool, and Amazon has some smart folks so this will likely work itself out over time, but there is going to be a lot to overcome.

Post reply on HN